Luxury real estate agent Lynne Bingham spends part of every week hunting for houses that most buyers will never see.

The Howard Hanna Real Estate agent routinely emails colleagues and checks in with top-producing agents across the region, searching for exclusive “pocket listings” — houses that are quietly marketed before they appear on West Penn Multi-List.

Pocket listings — used most commonly in conditions when inventory is low and demand is high — allow agents to match buyers and sellers privately before deciding whether to list homes publicly. In some cases, the homes sell before ever reaching West Penn Multi-List.

Bingham said her weekly routine has become essential in a luxury housing market where some of the most desirable properties are sold before they ever go public. One of her clients is currently searching for a home in the $1.2 million range. And tracking down the right property isn’t easy.

Advertise with us

“You can’t find them. The minute they come in, they’re gone,” Bingham said.

Pocket listings, bidding wars and a shortage of available houses has resulted in a luxury real estate boom unlike anything Pittsburgh has seen.

In the 46 days between May 1 and June 15, buyers purchased 81 homes costing $1 million or more across the Pittsburgh region, according to West Penn Multi-List data. Those sales generated nearly $134 million in volume — up from 60 sales totaling $88 million during the same period a year ago.

The average sale price of million-dollar homes climbed from $1.46 million to $1.6 million, while the number of sales of homes priced above $2 million jumped from eight to 13 this year.

It adds up to a record number of million-plus-dollar deals recorded this spring from the East End to luxury enclaves in suburban communities such as Adams, Pine, Mt. Lebanon and Edgeworth.

Advertise with us

That’s a striking development in a metropolitan area better known for its modestly priced houses and blue-collar neighborhoods than bidding wars for seven-figure homes.

Kim Marie Angiulli, a luxury real estate agent for Caldwell Banker, sold this home in Gibsonia, on Tuesday, June, 23, 2026. (Justin Guido for the Post-Gazette)

Arthur Smith’s home sale sets a record

The recent frenzy of million-dollar sales is occurring throughout the region — West Penn Multi-List data defines the Pittsburgh region as Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Westmoreland, Washington, Fayette and Lawrence counties, with 95% of the recent sales in Allegheny County.

The East End continues to attract an outsized share of Pittsburgh’s luxury real estate activity.

From May 1 to June 15, Shadyside and Squirrel Hill alone recorded 11 home sales of $1 million or more, totaling $23.2 million. Leading the pack was the sale of Steelers offensive coordinator Arthur Smith’s Shadyside residence, which changed hands for $5.529 million after being listed for $6.5 million.

Roz Neiman, a luxury real estate agent in Howard Hanna’s Shadyside office, said that until recently, she had sold the two most expensive homes in Shadyside.

Advertise with us

In June, she sold a Shadyside house for $4.45 million and had previously sold one in the neighborhood for $4.4 million — both were record prices before the Arthur Smith home sale.

“Nothing had sold in that price range, and then all of a sudden we get $6 million and $7 million this week,” Neiman said, adding that those sales were private “pocket listings” only marketed to wealthy people and were never posted on West Penn Multi-List.

“There was a bidding battle on the $7 million listing,” Neiman said.

“The last month has been the most incredible month in the upper price range that I’ve ever seen,” Neiman said, adding that buyers were lining up for her recent $2.24 million Squirrel Hill listing before she even formalized her agreement with the seller. “I just mentioned it to one agent and got six calls already,” Neiman said.

She finds it interesting that some of the strongest momentum in Pittsburgh’s luxury market is occurring in the city rather than in Fox Chapel, the community most closely associated with multimillion-dollar real estate.

Advertise with us

About nine years ago, Neiman sold what was then the borough’s most expensive home for $5 million. And homes there are still changing hands at that price point today.

The difference now, she said, is that Fox Chapel has seen activity slow down because there are few homes available for sale.

“But the city has never seen $5 million, $6 million and $7 million sales,” Neiman said. “And now we’re seeing them.”

A small pool of affluent buyers

The luxury market surge comes as Pittsburgh’s broader housing market also continues to post steady gains.

The average home in the region sold for $319,115 in May, up about 6% from $301,231 a year earlier, according to West Penn Multi-List data. By comparison, the average luxury home sold for $1.6 million during the spring selling season, up 9.6% from $1.46 million a year ago.

Advertise with us

While the broader housing market remains balanced and competitive, agents say the high-end segment follows a different set of rules.

Many of the region’s most desirable luxury homes are one-of-a-kind properties that cannot easily be replicated, so a small pool of affluent buyers competes aggressively for an even smaller pool of available homes.

But not every luxury listing sparks a bidding war.

Some multimillion-dollar properties sit on the market for extended periods, endure multiple price cuts or get removed from the market unsold. Agents say those situations typically occur when sellers overestimate what buyers are willing to pay rather than because demand has disappeared.

“What we’re seeing also shows that this market in Western Pennsylvania can support these prices,” said Dennis Cestra Jr., president of Howard Hanna’s Pennsylvania market.

Advertise with us

The market for average-priced homes remain healthy as well, he said.

“The market is really strong throughout,” Cestra said. “When you’re talking about the high end, that’s a much smaller snapshot.”

Part of the reason luxury prices have accelerated faster than the broader market is because the homes are fundamentally different properties than they were years ago due to extensive renovations, he said.

“The renovations mixed with the price increase is bringing them up over $2 million, $3 million, $4 million, maybe even more,” Cestra said. “There’s some great products out there.”

School districts impact home prices

Some of the strongest luxury-home activity this spring occurred outside the city, where communities accounted for a significant share of the region’s 81 sales of $1 million or more homes.

Advertise with us

No suburban community recorded more million dollar sales this spring than Adams in southern Butler County, which posted eight transactions of $1 million or more between May 1 and June 15, according to West Penn Multi-List.

Mt. Lebanon followed with seven sales of million-plus properties, while Pine recorded six.

Kim Marie Angiulli, a Coldwell Banker agent who specializes in luxury properties in the northern suburbs, said demand remains particularly strong in communities with highly rated school districts.

“We’re seeing a lot of multimillion-dollar sales right now, especially in new construction and in certain school districts,” Angiulli said.

Among the most sought-after districts in the northern suburbs, she said, are North Allegheny, Pine-Richland and Mars Area.

Advertise with us

Unlike luxury buyers in some of Pittsburgh’s established neighborhoods, suburban purchasers are often drawn to newer homes with modern finishes and open-floor plans.

“If they can sell the other home and move up and get something newer without having to do remodeling, they’re attracted to that idea,” Angiulli said. “And they’re pretty much ready to move because oftentimes they’re cash buyers.”

The dynamic is somewhat different in Sewickley, she said, where luxury purchases are often driven by deep family roots rather than a search for new construction.

“Those homes in Sewickley are often sold to move-up buyers that grew up in Sewickley,” Angiulli said. “They have a strong interest in staying within the community. Oftentimes, they are second- and third-generation families that have gone to Sewickley Academy.”

‘That’s the market that we’re in now’

Meanwhile, agents in the city said luxury buyers are finding a level of housing stock that scarcely existed a decade ago.

Advertise with us

Neiman said the buyers of her recent multimillion-dollar listings in the East End have all been local residents moving up rather than newcomers relocating to Pittsburgh.

“People want to live in the city, but there has been nothing worthwhile for that price range,” she said.

That is beginning to change as longtime owners who poured millions into renovations are finally bringing those properties to market, she said.

“People that have bought houses for $3 million and have put $3 million into them are putting them on the market," Neiman said. “They never were before. I never had that caliber of house. And now we do.”

Many of the homes have undergone extensive upgrades, from chef’s kitchens and luxury master bedroom suites to resort-style outdoor living spaces and six-figure bathroom renovations.

Advertise with us

“The renovations are spectacular,” Neiman said.

The result is a city luxury market that has entered a new era of pricing.

“It’s mind-boggling,” Neiman said of the recent surge in high-dollar home purchases. “It’s only been a couple of weeks. I’m now just absorbing all this.”

She recently met with a homeowner who believed her property might sell for about $1.5 million.

“I said, ‘No, we’ll get $2.3 million,’” Neiman said. “She said, ‘I can’t believe it.’ I said, ‘That’s the market that we’re in now.’”