A year and a half after a historic legal shake-up that was supposed to reinvent how homebuyers and home sellers pay real estate agents, little has actually changed.

The 2024 class-action settlements against the National Association of Realtors were supposed to give buyers and sellers the power to negotiate commissions rather than accept long-standing “standard” rates. But a new report from the Consumer Policy Center shows that most agents are sticking to the old playbook.

“The settlement provided homebuyers with new opportunities to negotiate commissions, but the industry has figured out how to minimize these opportunities,” said Stephen Brobeck, a senior fellow at Consumer Policy Center.

While conducting mystery-shopper interviews from July through September, CPC researchers found that 95% of the 281 buyers agents they contacted in 26 metropolitan areas still quoted commissions between 2.5% and 3%, which is nearly identical to pre-settlement norms.

Advertise with us

“It is very difficult for buyers to negotiate lower commission rates,” the report said. “Buyers who try to do so are met with a barrage of arguments starting with the statement that negotiation was not necessary because sellers pay the buyers commission.

“Several agents said they were charging the ‘standard’ or usual rate in their area,” the report said, pointing out that it could be “evidence of price-fixing.” While other agents told the mystery shoppers that if sellers didn’t offer compensation, that “discourages buyers agents from showing a house.”

The mystery shoppers who conducted the interviews with agents posed as a couple planning to move in two months to a town the agents worked in. They were looking to buy a $400,000 to $700,000 home in cash.

In about two dozen cases, agents agreed to show homes to the fictitious couple without requiring a signed written agreement upfront — simply ignoring the rule put in place by the settlement to ensure consumers understand how much they owe and to whom.

The findings paint a picture of a homebuying market that looks remarkably similar to the pre-settlement world. For decades, the real estate industry charged a standard 5% to 6% commission on home sales, which was split between the listing and buyers agent.

Advertise with us

In addition, the report found that commission rates are actually rising instead of going down. “There is evidence that more agents are trying to charge 3% today than three years ago,” the report said.

In March 2024, the National Association of Realtors agreed to pay $418 million to settle a nationwide claim that the industry conspired to keep commissions high and force home sellers to pay for the buyers agent commission.

As part of the settlement, NAR agreed to abandon the longstanding industry practice that tied the buyer and seller commissions together in favor of a new system that allows both to negotiate their commissions separately.

At the time, consumer advocates praised the settlement, saying that it would benefit home sellers and homebuyers greatly, eventually lowering agent commissions by billions of dollars a year.

But rates have not gone down. Sellers are still often financing both sides of the transaction. And there’s less transparency now.

Advertise with us

“Before the settlement, rate uniformity was greatly assisted by the mandatory rates published by the local [Multiple Listing Services],” the report said. “All agents could see what sellers [and their listing agents] were offering.

“Today, information flows within the industry about commission rates are more complex. But the private communications between listing agents and buyers agents on individual sales likely exert a powerful effect on the entire local marketplace.”

In individual metro areas, the report noted, there is remarkable homogeneity of quoted rates.

“This homogeneity largely reflects the influence of informal industry standards that are supported and enforced by most agents and brokers,” said Wendy Gilch, a CPC fellow.

“Unlike prices for other consumer services, real estate commissions do not vary with the competence, reputation and efforts of individual agents,” she said.

Advertise with us

The CPC report goes on to say that “listing agents do not want to gain the reputation of approving lower buyer agent rates, which would encourage buyer agents to steer clients away from them. Also, almost all listing agents are buyers agents on other sales so they have an interest in maintaining current buyer agent rates.

The report’s authors also offer some advice to consumers in the housing market.

“Buyers should negotiate their agent commission upfront ... as commissions are negotiable at multiple points,” Ms. Gilch said.

The CPC recommends that the industry goes back to prioritizing the complete separation of buyer and seller compensation, with buyers and sellers compensating their own agents.

“The most viable way to facilitate this separation is for federal agencies to more easily allow buyer agent compensation in their mortgages,” the report said.

“Over time, with mortgage lenders also offering this opportunity, this compensation, now implicitly financed as part of the sale price, would be explicitly financed, allowing much more meaningful buyer negotiation with their agents.”