In Sewickley Heights, a mansion has been waiting 15 years for a buyer.

Tucked inside 10 acres of private woods, the six-bedroom, 11-bathroom estate was meant to be a statement when it hit the market in 2010 at $7.75 million — the highest residential asking price the Pittsburgh region had ever seen.

Instead of selling, buyers made a statement of their own.

“The Western Pennsylvania market was not ready for a $7 million listing. It’s that simple,” said listing agent Carol Ferguson, an agent at Howard Hanna Real Estate Services in Sewickley. “The sellers were only asking for what they put into it.”

Advertise with us

Fifteen years later, and after several price cuts, the spectacular Sewickley Heights property remains unsold — marked down to $4.975 million — and now facing a lot more competition for the spotlight in this region’s ultra-luxury market.

Once rare, the number of houses on the market in Pittsburgh priced $4 million or higher has hit a record number of listings — 15, nearly triple the usual count of six or so.

Add in a few more properties that recently dropped their prices below the $4 million threshold when buyers didn’t show up, and then include the $7 million Fox Chapel seller who yanked his listing off the market in June after failing to get his price, and it becomes clear that Pittsburgh’s ultra-luxury housing market is ballooning well past its normal size.

Now sellers are waiting for demand to catch up.

In the past 10 years, only 10 homes in the Pittsburgh region have sold for $4 million or more, according to West Penn Multi-List data. One sale per year — hardly enough to soak up today’s inventory.

Advertise with us

A big reason so few homes sell above $4 million comes down to what it takes to own one.

For example, the Sewickley Heights estate, even at its reduced price, requires nearly $1 million down and a monthly mortgage payment of around $33,000, which includes about $6,000 in property taxes, and monthly insurance premiums of $1,650, according to the listing.

That kind of carrying cost alone narrows the field of qualified buyers down to a precious few.

“When I think of people that have purchased our homes that are over $3.5 million in the last 18 months, a lot of those folks are not just in Pittsburgh,” said Dennis Cestra Jr., president of Howard Hanna Real Estate’s Pennsylvania market.

He said ultra-luxury home buyers often relocate here from higher cost of living economies such as California and New York.

Advertise with us

“Your money can go a lot further here,” Mr. Cestra said. “What you get for $4 million in Pittsburgh can be a lot different than what you get in those gateway markets.”

Savvier buyers

Even so, Pittsburgh’s reputation as a bargain for West Coast buyers isn’t carrying as much weight as it once did.

Out-of-town buyers are savvier now and less dazzled by the discount, local agents say. Luxury real estate agent Roz Neiman of Howard Hanna’s Shadyside office recalls one sale last year that drove that lesson home.

“I know of one huge sale where the agent never told the out-of-town buyer that nothing had ever sold above $4.2 million, and they paid $6 million,” Ms. Neiman said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Neiman said she met the buyers some time later and they had no clue that they had paid a record price for a city property.

“When they found that out, they were not happy,” she said. “They were a bit shocked. But they really didn’t care that much because they had the money.”

For every buyer hesitating at the top end of the market, there are multiple sellers hoping to land them. Each new listing is entering an already crowded field.

This home at 134 South Drive, in Fox Chapel, shown here on Sept. 3, 2025, is listed for over $4 million. As more sellers list their luxury mansions for millions of dollars, agents wonder -- who's going to buy them? (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

As she prepared to put a $4.25 million property on the market in Squirrel Hill’s Murdoch Farms community, Berkshire Hathaway agent Julie Rost looked around at the competition — a $6 million mansion on Northumberland Street, a $5 million home on Ellsworth in Shadyside, and then another one in the $3 million range on Dunmoyle Street.

“We’ve been bringing some larger properties to the market, and I’m figuring out how we could pose them in a good light and think about who are the buyers that are going to be living in some of these places,” Ms. Rost said.

Advertise with us

“Is that buyer going to be somebody who lives locally and wants more space? Or is it somebody who is moving here for a job?” she asked. “And frankly, I wonder how many buyers there are to go around in any given year in the city at this price point.”

She doesn’t see the high number of multimillion-dollar listings now as unusual. What raises her eyebrows are some of the price tags. She traces part of that back to the record-breaking $7 million Fox Chapel sale two years ago to billionaire tech entrepreneur Luis von Ahn.

“It seems to get other sellers in the mindset that they can command that for their house and that there would be lots of buyers,” Ms. Rost said. “When, in actuality, that was an outlier in terms of the transaction.”

She believes something similar played out recently in the city when Steelers offensive coordinator Arthur Smith reportedly spent between $6 million and $7 million for a Northumberland Avenue home. “And now that number is popular with sellers,” Ms. Rost said. “Perhaps that sometimes skews expectations for what they can get for their own home.”

But the market has a way of correcting itself. Many sellers who go with sky-high prices are met with silence from buyers — until they either pull the listing or slash the price down to something more realistic.

Advertise with us

Mr. von Ahn pulled his $7 million Fox Chapel property off the market for the second time in June when full-price offers didn’t come in. A Shadyside listing on Ellsworth Street hit the market for $5.3 million on Aug. 2, and was removed from the multi-list 10 days later. Other properties sit for much longer before being yanked off the market or their prices slashed.

Finding the big buyers

So who buys these $4 million-plus properties? And how do agents find them?

Kim Marie Angiulli, a luxury agent in Coldwell Banker’s McCandless office, believes many of today’s ultra-luxury listings come from longtime owners ready to trade down.

“These are people who no longer have a young family using the pool or the tennis court, or the six or seven bedrooms,” Ms. Angiulli said, adding that the buyers tend to look very different from the sellers.

Advertise with us

“Most of the time, it’s going to be a younger family who has done really well. They can afford the big house. They want the pool, the six bedrooms, room for the kids to entertain,” she said “They’re going to use the house.

“The buyer is probably not going to be a couple in their 60s and can afford it,” she said. “That would be the exception.”

Marketing to that narrow pool is a challenge all its own. Unlike a $500,000 property, a $4 million home can’t simply be posted on the multi-list and left to sell itself. Many of them are tucked away on acres of land behind gates and trees, not visible from the main street.

Ms. Angiulli said she takes her listings to where her audience lives — by advertising in magazines that reach people who own airplanes and yachts, and sometimes even in the Wall Street Journal. “You’re actually looking for people who are global, or people who can be global.”

Referrals and social networks are just as important, with listing clients often moving in the same circles as qualified buyers.

Advertise with us

Howard Hanna’s Ms. Neiman takes a more personal approach.

“What I find to be most effective is I’m out there,” she said. “I don’t sit at my desk. I go to benefit parties. I’m on boards. I know wealthy people. I know who to call and they know me.”

That kind of networking can pay off, which is what happened with a recent $3 million Shadyside sale she made to buyers who are from Pittsburgh, but were living in Washington, D.C.

“I knew they’d like it,” Ms. Neiman said. “I called them up and said ‘I want you to come home right now.’ They said ‘nah, we’ll come home Saturday.’ I said ‘you’re going to miss your house.’ They got in their car, drove in and put down a check for $3 million.”

For now, the Sewickley Heights mansion that shook the region with its $7.75 million opening price 15 years ago is still waiting for its next owner. Sometimes it just comes back to patience.

Advertise with us

About two months ago, Ms. Ferguson said she sat down with the owners and agreed it was time to adjust expectations. They lowered the price to $4.995 million and immediately, she said the house drew more foot traffic in August than it had in the previous six months combined.

Meanwhile, the family is still enjoying the house and they aren’t in a rush.

“They don’t have any pressure to move,” Ms. Ferguson said. “They just want to do something different.”