Recession risks have increased as higher tariffs are set to weigh on the U.S. economy over the next few months.
According to the June Blue Chip survey of economic forecasters (PNC is a participant), the probability of recession over the next 12 months is 41% as of June, up from 26% at the beginning of 2025.
And it’s not just professional forecasters who are anxious; when I discuss the economic outlook and talk with individuals and businesses, concerns are much higher than they were a few months ago, before the Trump administration dramatically increased tariffs. Surveys of consumers and businesses show increased concern about the economy, although the numbers looked a little better in May after the administration rolled back some of the tariff increases.
But there’s a divide between “soft” data — survey-based measures of what people think about the economy, and “hard” data — data on actual economic activity, such as jobs, consumer spending and production. While the soft data have weakened in 2025, the hard data are holding up. And while the soft data can sometimes tell us where the economy is headed, they can also be misleading.
There’s no question that the soft data are not as good now as they were a few months ago.
For households, the consumer confidence index from the Conference Board fell in each of the first five months of 2025, to its lowest level since the pandemic. It rebounded somewhat in May, but remains well below its average over the past few years (see Chart 1).
Read More
The recent decline in the index has come primarily from consumers’ short-term expectations for income, business and the job market, which have dropped sharply this year, especially in April after President Donald Trump announced large tariff increases on “Liberation Day.” It made up some of its decline in May, although it is still lower than it was in the first three months of 2025.
The present conditions component of the overall index, which is consumers’ take on current business and labor market conditions, also fell from January to April, but by much less than the expectations component; the present conditions number also improved in May.
There’s a similar pattern with the Small Business Optimism Index from the National Federation of Independent Business. It also dropped in each of the first four months of 2025, although it remained above its 2024 average, and then improved in May. The NFIB number is aggregated from 10 components, such as expansion plans, views on the economy and expected sales.
Other consumer and business surveys are reporting similar results.
But weaker soft data doesn’t always mean problems for the economy.
Consumer confidence fell steadily from mid-2021 to mid-2022 even as the economic recovery from the pandemic continued. Job growth was very strong and the unemployment rate was falling rapidly from almost 6% to below 4%, near a decadeslong low. And then, after recovering, consumer confidence fell again from mid-2023 to mid-2024, even as the economy remained in good shape.
Similarly, the Small Business Optimism Index was lower in most of 2022 and 2023 than it was during the worst of the pandemic, when the unemployment rate hit its highest level since the Great Depression.
Some of the weakness in consumer confidence was because of the highest inflation in 40 years, even as the labor market was historically strong.
And the Small Business Optimism Index has a noted political bent; it tends to be higher during periods when Republicans hold the presidency, independent of actual economic conditions.
But these points just highlight the unreliability of these measures as economic predictors. Sometimes consumers say they’re anxious about the economy, but they continue to buy more. And business owners may say they’re less optimistic, but that doesn’t mean they aren’t investing and hiring.
These measures are generally lower during recessions than during expansions, and can start to turn south before other, more tangible measures of economic activity, but they aren’t foolproof predictors. In fact, there’s a noticeable disconnect, at least for now, between the soft and the hard data, with the hard data looking good in mid-2025.
The labor market is still solid, and employment is up by more than 7 million from before the pandemic with continued job growth. And the unemployment rate has stayed between 4.0% and 4.2% for the past year (see Chart 2). Plus, consumer spending is still increasing, at least through April, even as consumers say they’re uneasy.
But if the economy does start to weaken because of tariffs, the best signal will come from initial claims for unemployment insurance, the number of people filing for unemployment benefits.
This report is very timely: it comes out every Thursday from the Labor Department, based on claims filed through Saturday of the previous week. The data can be noisy, bouncing around from week to week. But looking at the pattern over a few weeks can provide an indication of where the job market is headed.
Jobless claims have picked up over the last few weeks, but at around 230,000 per week, are still well below their long-run average. If claims start to move closer to 300,000 the labor market is likely headed for trouble and recession is more likely.
PNC usually makes a write-up on claims available Thursdays at www.pnc.com/economicreports, so follow that for timely updates on the job market.
Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.