The Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority says it needs to raise rates by 33% to fund its debt service, as the nonprofit utility continues an aggressive rehab of its century-old system, some of it mandated by legal settlements with environmental authorities.
The company filed its rate case with the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission on Wednesday — launching a months-long process that typically results in a settlement, with the PUC granting a smaller increase than originally requested.
Pittsburgh Water is asking to stagger the proposed increase over two years, beginning in 2026.
If the request were granted in full, the average residential monthly bill would increase from $100.27 to $123.02 in 2026 and to $135.49 in 2027.
For low-income customers enrolled in the authority’s bill discount program, the average monthly bill would increase from $49.94 to $55.31 in 2026 and $60.81 in 2027.
Most of the increase would go toward paying for debt, which the utility issues to fund its capital improvement projects, like the Water Reliability Plan, a $500 million multi-year series of projects that include new pump stations and large main replacements.
Read More
“Pittsburgh Water is very much in a ‘building’ mode, in which Pittsburgh Water’s operating expenses, total debt, and debt service costs, have and will continue to go up every year,” Ed Barca, the utility’s director of finance, wrote in testimony provided to the PUC.
The utility’s last rate case, filed in 2023, resulted in a 16%, or $13.84, increase to the average monthly bill for a residential customer using 3,000 gallons of water per month. That rate went into effect in February 2024.
Pittsburgh Water’s CEO Will Pickering said the new ask reflects both the rising cost of everything — from materials to construction work — and the historic underinvestment in the utility’s system that’s now coming home to roost.
“The philosophy, if you want to call it (that), prior to more recent leadership, was fix it as it surfaces and fails,” Mr. Pickering said. “We know, often, it’s exponentially more expensive to do it at that point. And it's just no way to responsibly operate a system that is required to maintain public health in our region.
“Going out to the public and asking for more is painful,” he said. “Really, what we’re doing here is playing catch up.”
Cost and capacity issues
Pittsburgh Water came under the oversight of the PUC in 2018 and since then it has filed four rate cases. Each time the settled amount was much lower than what the utility said it needed to execute its capital plan. But even at those lower levels, Pittsburgh Water wasn’t actually able to spend all the money it was approved for until the past fiscal year.
In 2024, it spent around $200 million on capital projects, a sizable jump from the $115 million the year before.
Mr. Pickering said Pittsburgh Water has spent the past five or six years ramping up and is now ready to tackle more and bigger projects.
Its staff, which was around 300 five years ago, is now 423 people, with plans to hire 16 more. Last month, it leased a 127,000-square-foot warehouse near the Heinz Lofts to centralize its vehicles and equipment, and create space for more field crews.
In August, the utility will begin construction of the Aspinwall Pump Station, the Bruecken Pump Station, and Clearwell By-Pass projects, “the largest capital improvements in Pittsburgh Water’s history to date,” according to its rate case filing.
The ramp-up period is likely to last another five to seven years, Mr. Barca said.
“With all the regulatory requirements, just all the infrastructure needs that we have, that's why we have to take this approach to increasing our debt service drastically in such a short period of time.”
Pittsburgh Water is under a consent decree with the Department of Environmental Protection for its water reliability plan. Another consent decree is in the works with federal agencies over management of combined stormwater and sewage overflows.
The everyday work of running a water utility is also strained by cost and capacity issues.
For example, as of early April, there were more than 1,000 sites where Pittsburgh Water dug up and replaced lead lines or other old pipes but has yet to pave them. The authority’s paving contractor couldn’t keep pace.
Millions of operating dollars are needed to pay on-call contractors to make emergency repairs, which the authority said would continue to be frequent because of the system’s age and historic underinvestment.
It now costs $2.82 on average to print and mail a single monthly bill. To encourage customers to switch to online billing, the utility is proposing a $15 credit for those who do.
New vehicle purchases, a new labor contract, and higher utility costs all add to the revenue recruitment, Pittsburgh Water said.
“We're one of Duquesne Light’s largest customers. It takes a lot of energy to move our water around our system,” Mr. Pickering said. The cost of electricity in Duquesne Light’s territory went up June 1.
Unlike investor-owned utilities which finance their operations through a mix of debt and equity, Pittsburgh Water, which has no shareholders, only has debt at its disposal.
Mr. Pickering said part of his strategy is to “go really aggressive” after funding available through Pennsylvania’s infrastructure bank called Pennvest, which has been bolstered by large infusions from the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. Pennvest gives low-interest loans and grants for water infrastructure projects.
“It’s generally assumed that there’s not going to be another infrastructure bill at this scale anytime soon,” he said. And it’s much cheaper to borrow money from Pennvest than it is to issue bonds.
Pittsburgh Water said 76% of the proposed increase is needed to meet its debt service coverage ratio, a metric used by lenders to compare how much money a borrower has coming in to how much it owes.
Falling below the coverage ratios in its debt covenants results in penalties and higher borrowing costs, which would be passed on to ratepayers, the utility warned.
The utility plans to continue to issue increasing amounts of debt. Thus it will continue to ask for more revenue increases from higher rates to keep that debt coverage ratio at a level that complies, Mr. Barca said.
That’s why it’s advocating, again, for a multi-year increase. Pittsburgh Water has tried it twice before but its settlements included a uniform rate. Consumer advocates and the PUC have been skeptical of multi-year rate escalations without the utility having to come back to regulators and present its evidence that costs have increased.
Pittsburgh Water said in its new filing that it wants to “break the cycle of having to file a rate increase every 2-3 years in order to recover increased costs.” Going through the rate case process costs the utility about $1.5 million.
“Because of the many and varied commitments to which Pittsburgh Water is subject, its planned capital budget increases are a certainty. Also certain is that Pittsburgh Water will have to issue additional debt to pay for this additional construction,” Mr. Barca wrote in his testimony.
“In today’s environment, prices for materials and equipment are only going up. It is to everyone’s best interest to complete capital projects as expeditiously as possible.”
System expansion
Pittsburgh Water’s largest customers are municipal water utilities, including Fox Chapel, that get their water from the Pittsburgh utility but manage their own distribution and customer billing.
“Acquisition, consolidation, regionalization is something that we really want to consider and discuss with them,” Mr. Pickering said.
Pittsburgh Water’s treatment plant near Aspinwall pumps out 70 million gallons of water a day, but it is permitted to produce up to 100 million.
Low income programs
The utility is proposing several changes to its customer assistance programs, which are available to any residential customer whose income is at or below 200% of the federal poverty level.
- Arrearage forgiveness: Pittsburgh Water eliminates $40 of past unpaid charges each month that a current payment is submitted on-time. The utility is proposing to change the program so that the arrearage is reduced by 1/24th each month, which would eliminate all past due charges in two years for customers that keep up with current payments.
- Line repair: Pittsburgh Water ran a pilot program that provided free leak repairs and covered a portion of installing water saving devices for some low-income customers. The rate case proposes making the program permanently available to all such customers and raising the installation allowance from $1,356 to $1,600 per property.
- Bill discount program: The proposed rate case would apply a fixed monthly discount of $5 for water and $2.50 for wastewater to all customers enrolled in the bill discount program. Pittsburgh Water proposes to automatically enroll customers when they receive a grant through Dollar Energy, which administers the hardship funds for local utilities.
Other proposed changes that would apply to all Pittsburgh Water customers include swapping the minimum use charge introduced during the last rate case for a service charge, which the utility said would result in lower payments. It is asking for the switch to become effective in 2027.
The minimum use charge is assessed for all customers. For most residential accounts, it assumes 1,000 gallons of water is used each month. Households that use less are still charged that amount. The proposed service fee is a flat charge not based on the volume of water used.
The proposal also includes a $2 rise in the stormwater fee in 2026 for the average residential customer, and an additional 50 cents in 2027. The stormwater fee is assessed based on a property’s paved surface area.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.