Customs brokers like Chas Watson have spent months preparing customers for potential tariffs. It wasn’t a secret that President Donald Trump was looking to slap duties on Chinese products.
But a proposed 25% tariff on goods from Canada and Mexico?
That came as “a surprise to the trade community, to say the least,” said Mr. Watson, who founded the Moon-based R.L. Swearer Co. and is one of the largest customs brokers in Appalachia, helping importers and exporters navigate the legal requirements of crossing borders.
Just as he was absorbing the shock early last week, the Mexico tariffs were delayed by 30 days. In a few hours, a similar arrangement was reached with Canada.
“That’s literally how fast these things are going down,” Mr. Watson marveled.
But even the threat of tariffs can upend business and markets, economists said last week.
Read More
Stocks took a nosedive but mostly recovered by Tuesday as Trump agreed to suspend the 25% import levies on the nation’s two neighboring countries, and its largest trading partners, for at least a month.
A 10% tariff on all Chinese imports remained in effect. In retaliation, China said it will impose tariffs of 15% on U.S. natural gas and coal imports and 10% on crude oil, farm equipment and some vehicles on Monday.
Mr. Watson said he was almost certain the tariffs on Chinese goods will go even higher, mirroring a similar escalation with China during the first Trump administration.
But if the tariff train moves to Europe, as Trump has signaled, impacts to this region would be outsized, Mr. Watson said.
“China, everybody’s kind of gotten used to,” he said, referring to tariffs and counter tariffs that lasted for two years during the last Trump presidency.
“Europe would hit this region very hard.”

Hundreds of European companies operate in the Pittsburgh region, many specializing in high tech and industrial items for which they import spare parts and components from Europe.
“It would be impossible not to pass those price increases along [to consumers],” Mr. Watson said.
A month of reprieve
The spasmodic announcement and delay of large tariffs on America’s closest trading partners did little to reassure companies and customers who would be impacted.
Steel companies earlier in the month had canceled contracts in anticipation of the tariffs, a centerpiece of Trump's campaign. Alcoa CEO William Oplinger said aluminum prices could shoot up by $2 billion and force the Pittsburgh-based company to shift its supply chains.
The Canadian Consulate warned that Pennsylvania industries like coffee and timber could be directly affected by retaliatory tariffs. In the short term, such measures were averted by promises by Mexico and Canada to beef up border security. Still, economists said the disruptions could chill business decisions and depress the economy, even as they revealed how integrated the nations' industries have become.
“We're looking at a vast range of products and things that are going to be affected by this,” said Risa Kumazawa, a Duquesne University economics professor and president of the Economic Club of Pittsburgh.
Tom Clark, Canada’s consul general in New York, said Canada had already taken steps to bargain with Trump, though it wasn’t entirely clear what the president was angling for.
“We're kind of confused as to what this is all about,” he said. “We were told that it was about the border and fentanyl, and so we responded. We spent $1.3 billion. We put up drones, we put up Black Hawk helicopters. We've increased the actual presence of people at the border, both federal police forces and provincial police forces. And really, what they do more than anything else is act as eyes for [U.S. Customs and Border Protection].”
Canada is the top destination for goods exported from Pennsylvania and from the Pittsburgh region. In 2023, the latest data available from the U.S. Commercial Service, companies in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area sent $2.8 billion worth of goods to Canada and another $1.2 billion to Mexico. More than a third of all exports from this region go north or south across the country’s borders.
The interdependency of North American economies had been strengthened by the “near shoring” efforts in the wake of supply chain disruptions during the COVID pandemic. Near shoring refers to moving the supply chain closer, if not into the same country.
Car manufacturing, in particular, would be derailed by severed links between North American countries, Mr. Watson said.
“Some automotive companies may have a part cross the border two or three times during the manufacturing process,” he said. “Let’s say it’s an engine: It can be manufactured in Canada, then shipped to the U.S. [where] more steps are performed, and shipped back to Canada or to Mexico and put into a vehicle.”
Today, those trips are duty and hassle free, like driving a truck from Pennsylvania to Ohio, he said.
The energy and mining sector, too, sends equipment and tools to Canada freely, he added.

Pittsburgh’s trade links
Pennsylvania’s largest export is chemicals, including pharmaceuticals. The state sent $14 billion worth of chemicals abroad in 2023.
That “largely goes to Mexico,” said Ariel Zetlin-Jones, a Carnegie Mellon University professor who studies the impact of tariffs. “One of the second or third largest is steel that goes to Canada.”
Some steelworkers saw the tariffs imposed during Trump’s first presidency as a boon to the industry. They remained partially in place during Joe Biden’s term, though many steel customers received exemptions.
Kevin Dempsey, president and CEO of the American Iron and Steel Institute trade group, said earlier in the month that the president’s “reinvigorated trade policy agenda” would “tackle many of the issues that are priorities for the American steel industry” including unfair trade.
Trump also said tariffs, rather than foreign ownership, were the best path forward for U.S. Steel, a Pittsburgh icon that has spent the past year trying to close a merger with Japan’s Nippon Steel. He upended that idea Friday, however, when he said during a press conference with Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba at the White House that Nippon would invest in U.S. steel, but not buy it.
“They've agreed to invest heavily in U.S. Steel, as opposed to own it. And that sounds very exciting,” the president said, reiterating that the steelmaker “is a very important company to us” and that the “concept psychologically [of selling is] not good.”

The protectionist instinct isn’t unique to this administration, said Ms. Kumazawa, the Duquesne University economist.
“The best time for us to compare was the Great Depression, because all of this happened,” she said. “We were promoting ‘buy American, hire American.’ We imposed tariffs during the Great Depression [and] we didn’t anticipate the retaliatory tariffs that were going to be placed by our trading partners.”
This is what keeps economists up at night, Ms. Kumazawa said — not just the action but the cascading reactions.
Others warned that even the potential for sweeping taxes on all imports would chill business between the nations as companies grappled with an uncertain global market.
“People don't like making investments that are irreversible in times of uncertainty,” Mr. Zetlin-Jones said. “If you look at the VIX index, it's way up since the weekend. [That] creates a pause for businesses, and so that's going to have a drag on our economy.”
The so-called volatility index is a measure of the expected volatility of the S&P 500 stock market over the next 30 days. An immediate impact of the disruption could be hiring, the CMU professor said.
“Hiring workers is also an investment, right?” he said. “We often think of labor as easily adjustable, but they're big HR expenses, they're big investments made to bring new workers on, especially in large industries. And so I think that uncertainty is likely to kind of slow down hiring, not just physical investment in infrastructure and plants.”
Farm to tariff
Across Pennsylvania, nearly 5,000 dairy farms — the second largest number in any state — could feel the impact of tariffs on the U.S.’s top three trading partners.
Canada, Mexico and China accounted for about half of all American agricultural exports in 2023, the U.S. Department of Agriculture reported.
Retaliatory tariffs could drive up prices for American dairy abroad and, in turn, drive down demand, according to Jayne Sebright, executive director of Pennsylvania’s Center for Dairy Excellence.
“Any change in supplier demand dramatically changes the price [of milk],” Ms. Sebright said.
Milk prices are federally regulated, and fluctuation could hit hard in Pennsylvania. The dairy sector contributes $11.8 billion to the state’s economy annually. But the number of Pennsylvania dairy farms is declining, down at least 13% since 2020, according to the Center for Dairy Excellence.
In a statement Monday, U.S. Dairy Export Council President Krysta Harden urged the U.S. and its trading partners to “preserve the livelihoods of dairy farmers and manufacturers in rural America.”
Retaliatory tariffs from China alone resulted in an approximate $2.6 billion in lost revenues for U.S. dairy farms from 2019 to 2021, Ms. Harden said.
Dawn Gibel, owner of JIMDI, the O’Hara-based manufacturer of swine flooring, recalled when the last round of Chinese tariffs and counter tariffs left its mark on American farms.
JIMDI exports about 10% of its products, mostly to Canada and Mexico where clients have proactively moved up shipments to get ahead of potential tariffs. The firm makes slotted plastic tiles that lay on top of a holding basin that collects manure.
But sows prefer a cooler temperature, so their flooring is made from cast iron, which JIMDI imports from China. Ms. Gibel said she hasn’t been able to find cast iron in the quantity and quality she needs and a cost she could afford anywhere in North America.
“We’re being cautious about what we purchase right now until the dust settles,” she said.
JIMDI’s flooring is one puzzle piece in building a swine barn. Much of the penning also comes from China, too, Ms. Gibel said.
If other parts of the facility are too expensive to build, some projects won’t go forward and JIMDI’s demand will fall.
“The disruption of all these tariffs and the unknown associated with that has, in the past paralyzed that building industry,” she said. “It all has ripple effects.”
Mr. Clark, of the Canadian Consulate, has encouraged U.S. companies to lean into that interconnectedness to advocate against tariffs.
“To be honest with you, what we're hoping — and what we think would be reasonable — is that all the American companies, large and small, that’ll suffer as a result of these tariffs are the ones who are going to say, ‘What the heck are we doing, punching our closest friend and ally in the nose?’ I mean, what is the point? And especially when we're sitting here going, ‘We don't know what you want.’”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.