You may not have noticed it when it happened a decade ago, but on June 12, 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Clark v. Rameker.
While this case does not draw attention like politicians or Hollywood actors on trial, it has set the parameters for how one of the most valuable assets a person owns may no longer be protected.
The facts of the case indicate that Ruth Heffron established a traditional Individual Retirement Account (IRA) naming her daughter, Heidi Heffron-Clark, as the sole beneficiary of the account. After Ms. Heffron’s death, her daughter inherited the IRA, which was worth approximately $450,000.
Several years later, Ms. Heffron-Clark and her husband filed a Chapter 7 bankruptcy petition and requested that this inherited IRA should be exempt from being part of the bankruptcy estate (and thus subject to repayment to creditors) as protected “retirement funds” under federal statute.
It is common that when people file for bankruptcy that retirement funds are protected from being included in any payment to creditors. The policy stems from an incentive for people to save money for their later years.
There are complex income tax rules for establishing, maintaining and ultimately distributing these tax deferred accounts.
Read More
However, in the Clark case, the court drew a distinction between a retirement account owned by the person who actually earned the money that went into the account and the person who was simply the beneficiary of a retirement account created by someone else.
Therefore, under this decision, if a person inherits an IRA or other retirement account, it can be subject to the claims of creditors.
Why is this important?
According to statistics published by the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, non-business bankruptcy filings in the U.S rose from 374,000 to 434,000 for calendar years 2022 and 2023, respectively, a 16% increase in one year. While the family home used to be the most valuable asset a person owns, this is quickly being replaced by one’s IRA.
Furthermore, people who inherit IRA’s typically hold them for a long time because of the income tax deferral.
In the Clark case, the IRA was held for approximately 10 years after it was inherited from the original IRA owner before bankruptcy ensued. Using an average of 400,000 bankruptcy filings per year over a decade gets you to about four million people who may have inherited IRA’s who will file for bankruptcy over just 10 years.
The exposure of the inherited IRA to all types of problems is exacerbated because the inter-generational transfer of a retirement account is frequently accomplished by a simple beneficiary designation done in the financial planner’s office. When people think of traditional estate planning (wills, trusts, etc.), the protection of the IRA rarely enters the equation because they believe they have already solved the problem by simply naming a beneficiary on the account.
However, there are a variety of techniques that can be used to protect IRA’s and other retirement accounts for the next generation in case their finances are in jeopardy.
Here’s the catch:
You need to plan ahead and have the estate plan in place before the death of the original retirement account owner to create a roadmap for your IRA so that those who inherit it can enjoy it while keeping it protected from creditors and other potential predators.
This maneuver can be accomplished by working collaboratively with the estate planning lawyer, the financial planner managing the retirement account, and the client.
Julian Gray and Frank Petrich are both Certified Elder Law Attorneys with over 65 years of combined elder law experience who practice in the Pittsburgh area at Julian Gray Associates. Send questions for consideration in this column to elderlawguys@grayelderlaw.com and visit their web site at www.grayelderlaw.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.