Mortgage rates could jump past 8% and home sales activity might fall by nearly a quarter if the U.S. defaults on its debt, according to a Zillow analysis.

While the country has a stellar history of paying its bills on time, recent fears that the nation could default on its debt as early as June 1 have led to widespread speculation about the impact a default might have on the economy.

Financial experts agree that a U.S. debt default would be traumatic for every area of the economy.

“Not raising the debt ceiling and officially defaulting on the debt sends a very negative message to the credit markets,” said David Root Jr., CEO of DBR & Co., a Downtown financial planning firm. “That would skyrocket interest rates and that’s where Zillow is coming from.

Advertise with us

“It would send a shock wave through the stock markets, the housing markets and all the way down.”

Jeff Tucker, senior economist for Zillow, a Seattle-based online marketplace for real estate, said, “Home values might not see a notable drop, but higher mortgage rates would severely impair affordability.”

Read More

Fortunately, indications from Washington, D.C., suggest President Joe Biden and congressional leaders will strike a deal to raise the nation’s debt ceiling before the June 1 deadline.

“It’s good news that we are moving toward a deal, though progress has been slow,” said Kim Fleming, vice chair of Baird, who works Downtown for the Milwaukee-based wealth management firm.

Home values ‘might’ hold up, but ...

Advertise with us

Thanks to the overall health of the U.S. housing market, Zillow economists don’t expect home values would lose much ground even though mortgage rates could spike as high as 8.4% due to a default.

Like other housing markets across the nation that did not overheat during the housing boom, Pittsburgh home values have barely budged despite the doubling of interest rates in the past two years.

While home values might hold up in a debt default, interest rates would skyrocket and stock markets could plunge, according to financial experts. And Ms. Fleming said a default of U.S. debt would destabilize stock and bond markets.

“What is important is that the political debate is now about ‘how’ to raise the debt ceiling, not ‘whether’ to raise the debt ceiling — that is an important distinction,” she said. “With that said, Congress often acts right before a deadline. So we are advising our clients to plan for short-term market volatility this summer and potentially beyond.”

Average mortgage hike: $370 a month

Advertise with us

Zillow projects a debt default would have ripple effects throughout the economy and take a punishing toll on the housing market.

Interest rates would jump. Shaken confidence in U.S. treasury bonds being repaid would lead investors to require a higher rate of return to buy them, Zillow said.

“Buyers and sellers have finally been adjusting to mortgage rates above 6%, but we project that rates could rise above 8% in the event of a default,” Mr. Tucker said. “That would mean the mortgage payment on a typical U.S. home rising by $370 extra each month.”

Many home shoppers would simply be priced out if that happens — especially those seeking their first home.

The Treasury Department is keeping a close eye on what it calls the x-date: the date when the treasury will exhaust the various cash and debt management options available to stay under the national debt limit.

Advertise with us

Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has informed House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., that the federal government could reach the x-date as early as June 1. With no congressional action to raise, suspend or eliminate the debt ceiling, the nation could have to delay payment or default on its legal obligations.

House Republican leaders are demanding that an increase in the borrowing limit be accompanied by spending cuts and other cost savings. Mr. Biden is opposed to tying spending cuts to raising the debt ceiling.

Politics aside, economic experts predict hard times ahead if the two sides don’t soon see eye-to-eye. Moody’s Analytics projected that a default lasting even a few weeks could cause a recession on the scale of the 2008 Great Recession.

“Chances are, it will probably be temporary,” said Mr. Root of DBR & Co. “But it will rattle markets, for sure.”

700,000 fewer homes sold

Advertise with us

Despite the 30-year mortgage rate more than doubling from less than 3% in 2021 to more than 7% now, Pittsburgh’s housing values have mostly held steady. While the number of home sales this year in Allegheny County fell to 4,093 from 5,024 by this time in 2022, selling prices have seen only a slight drop.

West Penn Multi-List data shows the average sales price for Allegheny County homes is down only 1.3% from $274,871 in 2022 to $271,327 now.

In the city of Pittsburgh, average home values fell 5.2% since last year from $286,648 in 2022 to $271,721 this year. Meanwhile, the number of home sales in the city also tumbled from 1,206 sold in 2022 to 1,039 home sales this year.

Zillow projects that nationwide, 700,000 fewer homes would be sold in the next year and a half if interest rates shoot up.

“That helps to illustrate why it’s so critically important to find a solution before entering default,” Mr. Tucker said.

Advertise with us

The market, meanwhile, does not appear to be currently predicting a default, said Greg Weimer, CEO at Confluence Financial Partners. And even if one were to occur, a political compromise is expected shortly thereafter, he said.

“Despite the usual situation in Washington, D.C., we believe it will have minimal long-term impact on the market for investors,” Mr. Weimer said. “Any disruption would be short-term, and a compromise is anticipated, further reducing the likelihood of long-term effects.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834