It’s an eat or be eaten kind of vibe in the supermarket space these days.
Regional chains are getting gobbled up by bigger companies, which themselves are trying to bulk up to avoid getting swallowed by an even bigger fish. Food price inflation is splayed all over supermarket shelves. The looming merger of two of the largest grocery chains in the country — so big that the proposed deal is trudging through the federal anti-trust process — has been casting a shadow over smaller chains, including O’Hara-based Giant Eagle.
Kroger, the Ohio-based company that from time to time surfaces as a possible suitor for Giant Eagle, announced in October that it plans to buy Idaho-based Albertsons Companies Inc. for nearly $25 billion.
“That’s going to impact the whole industry,” said Wendell Young, president of United Food and Commercial Workers Local 1776 KS, which represents thousands of workers in Giant Eagle’s corporate stores around Pittsburgh and at privately held franchises. “They’re going to be able to acquire products much cheaper. If you’re Giant Eagle — whether they admit it or not — they’re trying to figure out, ‘What are we going to do?’”
When Mr. Young heard the news last week that Giant Eagle’s board of directors had parted ways with its CEO Laura Shapira Karet, he saw two ways to interpret the news.
“You can look at the strategic realignment as an effort to grow and expand, or you can look at it as preparing to sell,” he said. “Because you don’t want to whittle away and be less valuable down the road. If you’re not growing, you’re declining.”
Read More
All in the family
Kroger has been in the periphery of Giant Eagle’s vision since before the local company’s inception.
In 1928, Kroger acquired 125 Eagle Grocery stores run by three Pittsburgh families — Goldstein, Porter and Chait. The deal came with a caveat that the sellers had to stay out of the grocery business for three years.
They dabbled in shoe stores but didn’t like it. When the moratorium was up, they partnered with two other Pittsburgh grocery owners, Moravitz and Weizenbaum, who operated a series of stores called OK Grocery, and together launched what became Giant Eagle.
According to family lore, the founders settled on the name because “Big Eagle” didn’t seem big enough.

For its part, Kroger sold groceries in the Pittsburgh region until the mid-1980s when the chain abruptly pulled out of the market — abandoning about 45 stores — when a strike dragged on for several weeks without the wage and benefits concessions it wanted. After the pullout, the grocer quickly resolved contract negotiations in other cities.
Giant Eagle picked up significant market share at that time. In recent years, a number of new competitors have entered the market, although Kroger has not yet returned.
Joe Goldstein, a Hill District native and one of the original founders, led Giant Eagle for decades until his son-in-law Saul Shapira took over in 1968. Saul’s son, David Shapira, served as CEO from 1980 until 2011, handing over the reins to his daughter Laura Shapira Karet in January 2012. Ten years into her tenure, she was also made chair of the board.
When Giant Eagle announced last week that it had appointed Bill Artman as interim CEO and Bart Friedman as board chair, it marked the end of an era.
The company has not articulated what this change means or what prompted the move.
Ms. Shapira Karet issued a statement saying she decided to step away from the firm and would be “taking some much needed time with my family.”’
Giant Eagle spokesman Dick Roberts said on Friday that “with a focus on the future, the guest will remain at the center of everything we do.”
“Our purpose remains the same, to provide our communities with life’s essentials so our neighbors have the opportunity to thrive,” he said, assuring that the online and in-store experience and the myPerks loyalty program would continue as before.
And while nine decades of the Goldstein/Shapira family leadership have come to an end, Mr. Roberts noted that Mr. Artman has decades of his own experience with the chain.
The new CEO began bagging groceries at Giant Eagle while still in high school and has spent his entire career with the grocer, moving up the ladder to store manager, vice president of retail operations and, eventually, president of supermarkets before he was selected to lead the entire enterprise.
The new chairman of the board, Mr. Friedman, is a more recent arrival. A New York-based attorney whose LinkedIn bio highlights his work in “significant corporate and securities matters, with particular emphasis on mergers and acquisitions and corporate compliance and enforcement challenges,” he was brought in as an independent director in October 2020.
While the original five families have board seats, Mr. Friedman is the only non-family director whose presence on the board has been made public. But others have joined in recent years.
Giant Eagle declined to confirm the number or the identities of its board members.
“As a private company, Giant Eagle would like for it to remain that way in matters like this,” Mr. Roberts said, adding that the company has a “long history of including independent directors on its board to strengthen and balance the expertise, experience, and viewpoints.”
Mr. Friedman said on Saturday that he has witnessed the company’s strength during his tenure on the board as lead independent director and stressed that all five families and the rest of the directors are “as committed as ever to seeing this company prosper and grow.”
“We are eager to move the business forward with continued investments in technology and our loyalty platform, and the expansion of our footprint, formats, offerings and more, in line with and in many cases even greater than the investments made over the last several years,” he said.
Giant Eagle’s role in the communities where it operates would continue, he promised.
“I could not be more excited for our future.”
Price check
There are great supermarket chains and there are the “not great but good” ones, said Joe Feldman, senior managing director and retail analyst with Telsey Advisory Group in New York.
He put Giant Eagle and many of the Northeast grocery chains in the latter category.
That makes competing with large players like Walmart or Target a challenge, he said.
“The big guys have much deeper pockets to invest in technology and customer service initiatives,” he said. “Plus, the big guys have more buying power, so they can keep prices lower.”
On a recent day in March, several Pittsburgh shoppers cited price and location as the main determinants of their supermarket preference.
The Market District Giant Eagle store is the closest store to Alex Gruskos’ Point Breeze home. “When you're grocery shopping, you don't want to travel,” she said. But, “it’s not cheap.” She’s mindful of sales and stocks up when prices dictate.
Ron Bennett used to shop at Giant Eagle more often before food costs spiked — grocery food prices were up 10% year over year in February, according to government data. Shopping at Aldi last week, Mr. Bennett said he’d noticed Giant Eagle prices rising “overnight.”
“They’re not nickeling and diming you,” he said. “If you find something that went up, it went up at least a dollar.”

He’d rather pay less for the off brands offered at Aldi’s, Mr. Bennett said. That’s not unique to Pittsburgh, Mr. Feldman said, nor to Giant Eagle.
“Without question, Walmart is the best-priced grocer out there,” he said. “So what drives people to the grocery store (is) the freshest produce, proximity, cleanest stores, and price.”
Freshness is where regional chains can set themselves apart, he said, if they can leverage relationships with local farmers or sell products from local restaurants on their shelves.
“That being said, the big guys are getting better at all of that,” Mr. Feldman said.
Uncertain future
The possibility of being an acquisition target has to be a constant concern for Giant Eagle, he said.
The company has grown appreciably over the past decade. Between its supermarkets and GetGo convenience stores, Giant Eagle has more than 470 locations in Western Pennsylvania, Ohio, northern West Virginia, Maryland and Indiana. It also has 34,000 employees.
Ms. Shapira Karet oversaw Giant Eagle’s lurch into the digital space, most notably when the COVID-19 pandemic tested the rudimentary online shopping platform that the company had built years before.
In 2018, the company opened a satellite tech hub in San Francisco, and in 2020, wanting to tap into Pittsburgh’s tech talent, it launched a tech center in Lawrenceville. Giant Eagle’s corporate office is now virtual — most employees work from home and some work out of the Lawrenceville space.
There’s broad agreement among industry analysts that increasing digitization — inside the grocery store and with customers ordering online — will be ever more important for supermarkets as they fight to stay relevant and viable.
But Mr. Young, the union president, said he takes comfort in knowing that Giant Eagle’s new CEO is “an operator that’s learned this business from the bottom up.”
Mr. Young has gotten to know Mr. Artman over the past several rounds of labor negotiations and called him a “rising star” in the company.
“In my opinion, the best supermarket companies in this business are run by people who are supermarket operators,” Mr. Young said.
The company and the union, which resulted from the merger of two smaller locals, had long had a “very tense relationship — sometimes you’d even call it adversarial and fighting,” he said. “But our last contract, we had the biggest breakthrough.”
He credited Mr. Artman’s willingness to listen, and the union acting in kind.
Mr. Artman declined to comment for this report.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com. Staff writer Jordan Anderson contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.