Consumers paid some $14 billion in late fees to credit card companies in 2019, and although it might not be a surprise, the biggest burden fell on people with the lowest credit scores, according to a new report by the nation’s consumer watchdog.
Consumers with the lowest credit scores — categorized as subprime and deep subprime — made up 12% of credit card accounts but paid 42% of all late fees in 2019, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau said.
Late fees — which are assessed when a cardholder misses a minimum monthly payment — averaged $26 in 2019 for the first late payment and $34 for subsequent late payments, the bureau said.
Credit card late fees disproportionately burden consumers in low-income and majority-Black neighborhoods, the report said.
These penalty fees are flat fees, meaning they are the same amount no matter if the card balance is $200 or $2,000. They can equate to a surcharge of 24% annually on top of interest assessed on unpaid balances, according to the bureau.
“As consumers in poorer areas tend to carry smaller balances when they are late on a payment, the late fee they pay on top of a finance charge is typically a larger cost relative to their average daily balance,” the report said.
Overall, late fees fell in 2020 to about $12 billion during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic due to record-high payment rates and public and private relief efforts. But in 2021, they were on the rise again, the bureau said.
Smaller banks and credit unions tend to charge lower late fees than the largest credit card issuers, the bureau said.
One way consumers can avoid paying late fees is to ask their card company for a break.
Many card issuers will forgive a late fee as a courtesy, no questions asked, particularly if it’s the first time the account holder missed a payment.
Many people likely don’t request a break because they assume they’ll be shot down.
Be polite, experts say, and if the request is denied, ask for a supervisor, who may have more power to waive a fee than the first-line representative.
“The overall credit card market continues to rely on late fees disproportionately paid by economically vulnerable consumers,” the report concluded.
“For some households, late fees are a costly mistake for payments that may only be a day or two late. For others, they are a significant added hardship during a time of financial precarity.”
Credit card late fees are capped by federal regulators and adjusted annually for inflation. Most of the largest issuers set penalty fees at or near the maximum level, the report said. A small percentage of cards, such as the Citi Simplicity card, charge no late fees.
“As limits increase, late fees’ impact on consumers will likely remain substantial unless something in the credit card market changes,” the report said.
In January, the bureau asked the public for input and stories on exploitative junk fees. Comments are being accepted through April 11. The feedback will help shape the agency’s rulemaking agenda and enforcement priorities.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.