For Vlad Tenev, the end couldn’t come soon enough.
The House Financial Services Committee may have summoned the main actors in last month’s meme-stock frenzy for a hearing, but their attention was centered on the Robinhood Markets chief executive officer and his brokerage’s starring role in the saga.
Mr. Tenev sat through more than five hours of testimony and questioning, with a majority of lawmakers focusing their attention on him. Representatives took turns accusing Robinhood of transforming the stock market into a casino and failing to protect retail investors, as well as probing the firm’s decision to restrict trading of stocks such as GameStop Corp. during the market mania. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., questioned the very business model behind the free-trading platform.
Throughout the hearing, Mr. Tenev struck a conciliatory tone, underscoring that the company would learn from the experience.
“I’m sorry for what happened,” he said. “I’m not going to say that Robinhood did everything perfect, and that we haven’t made mistakes in the past. What I commit to is making sure that we improve from this, we learn from it and we don’t make the same mistakes.”
Citadel CEO Ken Griffin and Melvin Capital Management’s Gabe Plotkin didn’t field quite as many questions from lawmakers, but they made clear they had no role in Robinhood’s decision to halt trading. Reddit co-founder Steve Huffman and Keith Gill, the trader known as “Roaring Kitty,” spoke only a few times.
Mr. Tenev was quizzed on matters including why Robinhood had to put trade restrictions in place after demands from its clearinghouse spiked, whether it exposes investors to undue risk and how it earns most of its money.
Payment for order flow, a widespread but little-understood revenue generator for Robinhood, came up repeatedly. The brokerage makes most of its money by sending customer trades to firms like Citadel Securities, which carry out the orders and pay Robinhood for the opportunity to do so. Mr. Tenev spent much of the day explaining that it’s legal, regulated and disclosed — and is part of the business model that supports free trading.
But lawmakers wanted more information. Toward the end of the hearing, Ms. Ocasio-Cortez asked if Robinhood would be willing, for instance, to immediately commit to share what it earns from payment for order flow with its customers.
“If removing the revenues that you make from a payment for order flow would cause the removal of free commissions, doesn’t that mean that trading on Robinhood isn’t actually free to begin with?” asked Ms. Ocasio-Cortez, a Democrat from New York.
“Robinhood is a for-profit business and needs to generate some revenue to pay for the costs of running this business,” Mr. Tenev said. “People were initially skeptical that the model even with payment for order flow would work when you remove the commissions, and I think we’ve proven that otherwise by making this the standard model by which brokerages operate now.”
Robinhood took in about $687 million from such payments in 2020, according to data from regulatory filings compiled by Bloomberg Intelligence. The firm has faced a regulatory penalty for its disclosures on the issue. In December, it agreed to pay $65 million to settle Securities and Exchange Commission claims that it failed to adequately inform customers about the practice. Robinhood neither admitted nor denied guilt.
Mr. Griffin, who was seated in a well-lit nondescript conference room and framed by two lush plants, received a stream of questions about payments Citadel Securities makes for Robinhood’s order flow. Is it in fact so, several lawmakers asked, that retail investors get the best possible deal in that bargain? Or is it simply a way for Citadel to enrich itself?
Mr. Griffin, whose $21 billion fortune makes him one of the richest people on the planet, said the practice dates back more than a decade, is approved by regulators and benefits small investors by sparing them from exchange fees.
“We give a better price, better execution, than the alternative of going to exchanges,” he said.
Citadel Securities paid its own $22.6 million fine to regulators in 2017, settling claims that it misled customers about how it priced trades. The firm neither admitted nor denied the findings.
There were other tough spots for Mr. Tenev. After telling lawmakers that the total value of customer assets on Robinhood exceeds the net amount of money they’ve deposited by $35 billion, he faced questions on what that actually means for the customer. The CEO demurred when Rep. Jim Himes, a Connecticut Democrat who previously worked at Goldman Sachs, pressed him to share a rate of return Robinhood customers received.
“A hard dollar number is meaningless unless you convert it to return,” Mr. Himes said.
Reiterating that Robinhood is a force for good, Mr. Tenev said the app opens users up to the wealth-building possibilities of financial markets. When Democratic Rep. Jake Auchincloss of Massachusetts, a state that accused Robinhood of gamification and initiated regulatory investigations, asked how the company was educating customers with no experience on trading options, the CEO once again pointed to the benefits of zero-commission trading and recent enhancements to the app, but he didn’t answer the question.
Gene Grabowski, a partner at crisis communications firm kglobal, said the evasive answers contributed to Mr. Tenev looking “terrible.”
“As predicted, he is the villain in this drama,” Mr. Grabowski said.
Customer service has been a sticking point for Robinhood, which has been criticized for a lack of a dedicated emergency support line. Rep. Sean Casten, D-Ill., invoked the suicide of a 20-year-old user, Alexander Kearns, who hailed from his state. Mr. Kearns’ parents filed a wrongful death suit against Robinhood, saying their son panicked after he incorrectly believed he had lost $730,000 on an options trade. Mr. Tenev testified that the event was “deeply troubling” and led to changes on its options platform.
In one dramatic moment, Mr. Casten asked listeners to imagine being a nervous Robinhood customer with an urgent question, trying to call the company.
“Let’s call, and let’s listen,” he said. A prerecorded message directed callers to Robinhood’s website or app for support.
Robinhood is offering more phone support in certain cases. In his prepared remarks Mr. Tenev mentioned that some customers were exercising worthless options contracts last month and immediately suffering losses as a result — instead of just letting the contracts expire. Users are now required to speak to a registered representative in such cases. The company also is expanding live phone support to customers with account security problems, Mr. Tenev said.
When lawmakers turned their attention to Mr. Gill, or “Roaring Kitty,” it was to congratulate him. “You outsmarted the system,” Rep. Blaine Luetkemeyer, a Missouri Republican, told him. Mr. Gill didn’t speak often, but when he did his remarks appeared to move GameStop shares, with the stock rising Thursday on his opening comments and at least on one of his answers. It still ended down 11%.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.