A credit score as low as 580 would have been good enough to qualify for a mortgage earlier this year at Union Savings Bank, but borrowers would need at least a 660 FICO credit score today for the same loan.
It’s an increasingly common scenario as an abundance of caution has taken hold of the nation’s home lending industry.
From the lenders who approve mortgages to the pension funds and institutional investors who buy them in bundles on the secondary market, worries are running rampant that sky-high unemployment numbers and the economic slowdown brought on by the COVID-19 crisis might translate to more mortgage defaults and late payments down the road.

“It’s almost impossible to do an FHA [Federal Housing Administration] loan with a credit score of less than 660 right now,” said Justin Rosenal, senior sales vice president at Union Savings Bank, a federally chartered lender with branches in Upper St. Clair and Richland.
He said one institutional investor informed the bank Thursday that until further notice it will require borrowers to have a minimum 740 FICO score for approval of any cash-out refinance mortgage applications for conventional loans.
Conventional mortgages are typically for borrowers with higher credit scores who have more money to put down. Borrowers tend to use FHA loans when they have lower credit scores and less money for a down payment.
FICO scores help lenders determine how likely a borrower is to repay a loan. In general, many lenders find scores above 670 indicate good creditworthiness. Typically, the higher a person’s score, the lower the risk and the more likely creditors are to approve the loan.
The FHA provides mortgage insurance on loans made by lenders throughout the country. The FHA loan guarantee means if borrowers default, the federal government will pay the lender for any losses.
The FHA provided insurance endorsements on 990,429 single-family mortgages with a total unpaid balance of $214.6 million for fiscal year 2019, ending Sept. 30, 2019.
Since the COVID-19 crisis began, FHA lending guidelines have not changed.
It will still guarantee mortgages for low-income borrowers with a credit score as low as 580 and as little as 3.5% of the home purchase price down. People with FICO scores as low as 500 could still meet FHA criteria for a home loan if they put down at least 10% of the purchase price.
What has changed is that investors, in the face of epic uncertainty, have put pressure on banks to restrict their loans to only the most creditworthy borrowers.
“When you close a loan, it is resold 99% of the time,” Mr. Rosenal said.
Banks collect fees for packaging and selling the mortgages to investors. That allows the banks to free up their capital to make new loans, while investors who buy the mortgages get a safe and stable return on their money as the loan principal and interest is paid down over the years.
“If you are an investor making risk assessments, FHA is the riskiest mortgage because the borrower is only putting 3.5% down,” Mr. Rosenal said. Conventional mortgage loans typically require a down payment of at least 5%.
Changed home equity rules
But it’s not just FHA-backed loans that are seeing tighter requirements.
Conventional mortgages dwarf the FHA loan market. According to Statista, an online portal for market data, mortgage originations in the third quarter of 2019 amounted to $375 billion.
With the economy in crisis mode, some of the nation’s largest financial institutions have announced they are tightening their underwriting standards.
A spokesperson for Bank of America confirmed that the bank has raised its FICO credit score minimum from 660 to 720 for home equity loan borrowing. JPMorgan Chase, the nation’s largest bank, now requires a credit score of 700 or higher as well as a 20% down payment for most new mortgages, according to Keosha Burns, vice president of public relations for home lending at Chase.
Other banks, including some of the Pittsburgh region’s largest lenders, have followed that lead in recent weeks.
“Pittsburgh is a very important market for us,” said Sonu Mittal, head of retail mortgages for Citizens Bank. “For house purchases and refinances, the guidelines are similar to what they were. Folks looking to pull equity out of a house will see the majority of the changes.”
With total assets of $160 billion, Citizens Bank, owned by Citizens Financial Group, based in Providence, R.I., is the fourth-largest mortgage lender in Allegheny County among banks with local branches.
Citizens said customers who want to refinance their homes in order to pull cash from the equity will need a credit score of at least 660, while the bank’s loan-to-value ratio has been reduced by 5%.
That means the bank would have loaned 80% of the value of a $100,000 home prior to the COVID-19 shutdown but will loan only 75% of the home value now.
PNC Financial Services Group, the largest bank in the Pittsburgh region, is the No. 2 mortgage lender in the metropolitan area behind Dollar Bank. PNC Bank has a retail branch network of banks located in 41 markets across the Mid-Atlantic, Midwest and Southeast and strategic international offices in four countries outside the U.S.
In a statement to shareholders following the release of its first-quarter earnings report, PNC said it has been modifying mortgage loans, extending grace periods and waiving fees, and it has halted all foreclosures. As of April 13, the bank said it had granted postponement of payments and reduced payments on some 41,000 consumer loan accounts primarily related to COVID-19.
A wave of forbearances
The avalanche of forbearance requests from distressed homeowners has only intensified the strain on the mortgage industry.
Borrowers with government-backed loans can delay up to a year’s worth of payments if they have experienced financial strain caused by the novel coronavirus. Nearly 7% — 3.5 million — of all mortgage borrowers have asked to be put into forbearance plans, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association in Washington, D.C.
Forbearance plans allow homeowners to delay making payments with no late fees or damage to their credit history. However, interest continues to accrue on the loan and all missed payments are due in a lump sum at the end of the forbearance period.
Mr. Rosenal at Union Savings Bank said banks that service mortgage payments face considerable risk.
Banks like Wells Fargo, JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America originate mortgages and then collect loan payments from mortgage borrowers. They funnel those payments to the investors who own the bonds backed by those loans.
Banks receive a fee for operating as a mortgage servicer, but the role becomes double edged in a broad economic downturn.
When large numbers of borrowers are granted forbearances and they stop making mortgage payments, the servicer has less cash coming in yet is still obligated to make full payouts to investors, along with paying property taxes and insurance bills on behalf of property owners.
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.