While doing an annual review of a client’s finances, Pittsburgh wealth manager Carrie Coghill noticed a six-figure amount of money had disappeared from the client’s net worth.
“This didn’t look like your typical shopping spree,” she said. “It was a lot of money that vanished.”
Ms. Coghill said the client, embarrassed by the discovery, sheepishly admitted making a personal loan to a friend who wanted to start a business. The decision not only caused the client to lose the money, but also a friend.
“One thing we know about anything related to money is when emotions are involved, the likelihood of making a mistake goes up,” said Ms. Coghill, CEO and president of Coghill Investment Strategies, Downtown.
“We see it with the stock market when decisions are driven by fear and greed,” she said. “The same holds true when being asked to loan money to friends and family because we don’t do our homework to determine if that person will be in a position to pay it back.”
The hard lesson her client learned is consistent with what Bankrate.com found in a recent study. The conclusion: lending money to friends and family is usually a bad idea.
Read More
The Bankrate.com study found 46% of people reported either losing money (37%) or experiencing a damaged relationship (21%) with the borrower.
Similarly, 37% of those people surveyed who lent a credit card to a friend or family member had something bad happen. 21% said they lost money, 16% said it damaged their relationship with the friend or family member, and 12% took a hit on their credit score.
Bankrate also found 1 in 5 adults has co-signed a financial product for a family member or friend, and 45% of them were left holding the bag.
“I’d avoid lending cash and credit cards and co-signing,” said Ted Rossman, an industry analyst at Bankrate. “All too often, these situations end poorly. It’s OK to say no, Perhaps offer to help in a different way.
“If you really want to do it, only offer as much assistance as you can afford to lose,” he said. “In your mind, assume it’s a gift and that you won’t get paid back. Let that sink in ahead of time so that a negative experience doesn’t harm your relationship along with your account balance.”
Overall, the survey of 2,490 adults conducted in late August found 60% have lent cash, 21% have co-signed for a financial product and 17% have loaned a credit card. Parents of adult children were the most likely to report lending cash (65%), co-signing for loans (29%) and lending their credit cards (23%).
Even though they didn’t lend their credit cards, some people reported getting stiffed by friends when they used a card to pay a group bill.
The cardholder expected to accrue credit card rewards by paying a group expense with the card, but instead 70% of people who used their card this way said they got burned at least once when friends didn’t pay the cardholder back.
Two researchers at Carnegie Mellon University concluded in a 2012 study that borrowers had self-serving biases when it comes to personal loans.
George Loewenstein and Linda Dezso found that with personal loans between family members and friends, borrowers are more likely to believe that the loan was initiated by the lender and that the loan had been paid off as agreed. If the loan was delinquent, they were inclined to feel it was a gift.
The CMU resesarchers’ second finding was that personal loans that had not been paid off and were overdue resulted in wide-ranging negative consequences, such as loss of closeness, loss of trust and lenders feeling the delinquent borrowers were going out of their way to avoid them.
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.