This story was updated April 22, 2020 to clarify that the Pennsylvania license revocation and fine and the Florida fines were directed not to Mr. Barnes personally but to his companies. He operates his limousine business under a host of names and websites. In December 2019, the Pennsylvania attorney general sued Mr. Barnes for violating the state’s Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law. In the complaint, the attorney general alleged that Mr. Barnes is the sole owner and principal of his businesses. 

Moira Nee of Brookline wanted to make her sister’s bachelorette party in Erie last September especially memorable by splurging on a limousine for the evening.

But what started out as a kind gesture turned into a nightmare for Ms. Nee, who still can’t believe that the roughly $400 she expected to pay for the four-hour booking ballooned to almost $1,600 — an amount that a year later she’s still trying to pay off on her credit card.

Eric Garcia-Tunon, of Miami, knows how she feels.

Advertise with us

He thought it would be fun to shuttle his son and a handful of friends to the local bowling alley in a stretch SUV for his son’s 13th birthday party in March. The boys’ 20-minute, one-way joyride ended up costing him nearly $1,300.

“I didn’t look at the reviews for this company. I should have,” Mr. Garcia-Tunon said.

Dozens of dissatisfied customers from numerous states have posted similar stories on Yelp and other review sites claiming they’ve been victimized by excessive and hidden fees charged by a limousine business run by Erie native Matt Barnes. Some disgruntled customers, including Ms. Nee and Mr. Garcia-Tunon, have formed a Facebook group to share stories and to try to get their money back.

Ms. Nee, Mr. Garcia-Tunon and others are steaming over the charges, which they say have included an administrative fee of $500 or more slapped on them for disputing charges on their credit or debit cards — or for simply asking questions about their bills.

Mr. Garcia-Tunon said that what bothers him the most are the stories he has heard from other people who have had the memories from their once-in-a lifetime events tarnished.

Advertise with us

“This is a luxury item people get for special occasions. They save up. They don’t have a lot of money,” he said.

Mr. Barnes, reached for comment Tuesday, denied there were any problems.

“I don’t know about any complaints. We run a fantastic business. We provide excellent service. We’ve been in business now almost 20 years,” he said. “We have a lot of clientele from princes and dignitaries.

“We provide service all over the globe,” he said. “We have less than .001 percent who are dissatisfied. That’s my guess.”

He said any complaints on review sites were “not vetted.”

Advertise with us

“Anyone can write anything online and it doesn’t mean it’s truthful. If anyone has any concerns, they can come directly to the company and we will take a look at it,” he said.

He declined to say where his company was headquartered or discuss particulars about his business. “The way in which the company promotes its business is not appropriate to talk about at this time,” he said.

Mr. Garcia-Tunon said that when he was searching for a limo for his son’s birthday party, he called the phone number on several websites. All of the calls led to Mr. Barnes, who personally answered the phone.

“I said to him, ‘Funny how all these websites are referring me to you.’ ” Mr. Garcia-Tunon said. “He said, ‘Yeah. That’s because we are the best.’ ”

In his interview Tuesday, Mr. Barnes wouldn’t say how many employees he had, of if it only was him on the payroll.

Advertise with us

Arranging rides

Mr. Barnes and his websites have grown by offering services as a limousine broker, arranging rides for people through various third-party companies.

The business has operated under a host of names and websites, such as Barnes Professional Limousine Service, Barnes Erie Limousine, Walten Point Productions, Barnes Worldwide, Go VIP Worldwide and PartyServiceMiami.com, which lists 16 “locations” in Florida.

“We are happy you are here ...You have found one of the most sought after transportation providers in the world,” the company states on its GoVIPWorldwide.com and BarnesWorldwide.com websites, which are filled with photos of limousines, SUVs, party buses, charter buses and private jets.

In his LinkedIn profile, Mr. Barnes is listed as the owner of Walten Point Productions and Barnes Limo, overseeing all operations for the last 20 years.

Advertise with us

“I am always looking for the next big opportunity,” the profile states. “All my business contacts thus far have referred to me as the consummate professional in my field.”

Warehouse time

Mr. Garcia-Tunon said when he called about getting a limo, Mr. Barnes quoted him a price of $250 an hour for a 20-person SUV, plus a 20% tip and 15% service charge. Mr. Garcia-Tunon said it worked out to about $340.

Because the ride to the bowling alley was only six miles, that’s all he expected to pay.

Mr. Garcia-Tunon’s contract with Mr. Barnes:

Advertise with us

After the bowling party, Mr. Garcia-Tunon says he got an alert from his credit card company showing a charge of just over $700.

He said he emailed Mr. Barnes, thinking it was a mistake. He said he was told that in addition to the time booked, he owed for an extra hour to cover the limo’s travel time to and from the warehouse.

Shortly afterward, he received an email saying he had been charged a $575 “research” fee, referencing the fine print in his contract that stated: “If the purchaser disputes or inquiries [sic] about any charge applied by the company to their credit/debit card, purchaser authorizes a charge of $575 per transaction.”

Mr. Garcia-Tunon was stunned. “I laughed, because I realized at that point I’d been had.”

This email from Go VIP Worldwide notified Eric Garcia-Tunon that his credit card was charged a fee of $575 for inquiring about his limousine rental bill.

Advertise with us

Mr. Garcia-Tunon filed a dispute with the card issuer trying to get the charges reversed. “They said I authorized the charges because I signed that paper. In essence they said this is between you and him and a court of law.”

Ms. Nee said Mr. Barnes quoted her a price on the phone of around $400 for four hours in a five-passenger SUV. She said he emailed a contract without the total amount filled in and encouraged her to sign it to reserve her spot.

“I didn’t think twice” about signing it, she said. “In retrospect, that was unbelievably stupid on my part.”

Later that day, he sent her an email confirmation showing a total charge of $596.70, including an hour’s extra travel time to and from the warehouse, 20% gratuity, 15% service charge, plus a $22.95 convenience fee for using her credit card.

With her sister’s bachelorette party still nearly three months away, she asked to cancel. Mr. Barnes said she could cancel but would still owe the full amount.

Advertise with us

When she opened a dispute with her credit card company over the charges, he charged her another $500. When she disputed that fee, “He hit me with another one.”

The extra $1,000 brought her total bill to $1,596.70.

As with Mr. Garcia-Tunon, her credit card issuer denied her request for a charge-back.

Fearful that something would go wrong if she stuck with Mr. Barnes’ service, she canceled the job, even though she was out the money. “I didn’t want to ruin my sister’s day,” she said. “It wasn’t worth it to me, in spite of the money.”

When asked on Tuesday to explain the $500 plus dispute/inquiry fee, Mr. Barnes said he is always willing to talk with customers. “If someone believes they’ve been treated unfairly, we share in their concerns.... Bring it back to the company; we will take a second look,” he said.

Advertise with us

“We don’t have any fees like that,” he said when pressed. “I’m not sure what you are speaking of. I’d have to take a look. You can email it over.”

Fine print in the contracts reviewed by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette contain such a fee, which has risen over time. For Ms. Nee in 2018, the fee was $500 per transgression. In March, Mr. Garcia-Tunon was charged $575. More recently, the fee had risen to $585.

When asked about the practice of charging for travel time to and from the vehicle’s pick-up and drop-off locations, Mr. Barnes declined to address specifics.

“You understand what a contract is?” he asked.

Later, he added, “Every time our company transacts business, it’s done with a written agreement with specific terms that are explained up-front. If someone doesn’t like the terms they can contract with a different business.”

Advertise with us

The beginning

Filings with the Pennsylvania Department of State show Mr. Barnes started a limousine business — Barnes Professional Limousine Service — in 2009, and an entity called Walten Point Productions in 2016, both in Erie.

In the beginning, Mr. Barnes operated a few of his own limos, according to a former employee, Jean Johnson.

Ms. Johnson, of Erie, said she worked for Mr. Barnes for about a year as a driver on the weekends when he first opened his business and had a couple of limousines that he parked at his parents’ home in Erie.

She said she became suspicious that he was charging passengers a gratuity but was keeping the money. She said she confronted Mr. Barnes, telling him about her last run where a passenger thanked her for doing a good job. “I know your tip is included, but here is an extra tip because you were wonderful,” she remembered the customer telling her.

Advertise with us

“That’s when he [Mr. Barnes] admitted that he does keep them,” Ms. Johnson said.

That’s when she quit.

Daniel Eakman — a driver in New York who currently works for a limousine company that Mr. Barnes has used to fulfill bookings in Pennsylvania — said he believes Mr. Barnes is charging a 20% gratuity that doesn’t get passed on to the drivers.

“Clients [booked through Mr. Barnes] will say to me, ‘Did you get your tip?’ ” Mr. Eakman said in an interview. “When I say no, they say, ‘We paid for the tip. You sure you didn’t get it?’ ”

Mr. Barnes wouldn’t say whether the 20% gratuity he collects goes to the drivers.

Advertise with us

“The way in which we disburse funding in our company is proprietary,” he said.

Dealing with regulators

The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission revoked the operator’s certificate of Mr. Barnes’ company in 2017 for failing to maintain the required insurance coverage.

In April of this year, the PUC fined his company $500 for operating without a certificate. According to the agency, businesses that do not operate their own vehicles but arrange passenger services are required to be certified and carry insurance in the state.

Mr. Barnes’s company was also fined in Miami Dade County in Florida in 2018 for operating without a license. And earlier this year, his business was fined again for operating without a license.

Advertise with us

“We are fully in compliance with all regulations,” Mr. Barnes said in Tuesday’s interview. “All alleged penalties have been fully contested. In good faith, the company has fully satisfied any outstanding obligations to Pennsylvania and the federal government.”

He said he was “not aware of any penalties” in Florida.

Crisie Hernandez of Chapel Hill, Tenn., said she booked a sedan through Mr. Barnes for her wedding in Gatlinburg, Tenn., in February.

After the wedding, she noticed an extra $99 charge on her debit card. She said she was told the driver had dropped her and her new husband off three minutes late — at 5:03 p.m. instead of 5 p.m — so they owed for an extra hour, plus applicable 15% service charge, 20% gratuity and 4% convenience fee for using her debit card.

When the couple disputed the extra fees with their bank, another $550 fee was tacked on.

Advertise with us

“I said, ‘Are you kidding me?’” Ms. Hernandez remembered saying. “I questioned an unreasonable charge. That’s my consumer right.”

Mr. Garcia-Tunon, Ms. Nee and Ms. Hernandez all say they have reached out to various state and federal regulators.

The Pennsylvania PUC says officials are listening.

“The commission’s Motor Carrier Enforcement Division is investigating recent complaints involving Barnes and is working with other consumer protection and law enforcement agencies to address complaints from consumers in Pennsylvania and other states,” PUC spokesman Nils Hagen-Frederiksen wrote in an email earlier this month.

In recent days, Mr. Barnes has reached out to some vocal customers in the Facebook group, offering certain refunds in exchange for signing a release form absolving him of any wrongdoing and ending their rights to any legal actions. It also requires that settlement terms be kept confidential.

Release form offered by Mr. Barnes:

On Sept. 11, Ms. Nee, who didn’t end up using Mr. Barnes’ service, was offered a refund of $1,596.70. She said she was leery of signing another contract with the business. Ms. Hernandez on Tuesday was offered $300 in exchange for signing the release form, but was hesitant.

Ms. Nee, Mr. Garcia-Tunon, and Ms. Hernandez all said they want Mr. Barnes to change his business practices.

“If we absolve him of this and take our money back, I’m afraid he will continue to do this,” Ms. Nee said.

Negative reviews

Both Mr. Garcia-Tunon and Ms. Nee said that when they wrote negative reviews online, Mr. Barnes threatened to sue them.

“We have considered taking the appropriate action at all times when someone has spread falsehoods,” Mr. Barnes said Tuesday. “I think all businesses would do that.”

Ms. Nee also received an email threatening a lawsuit in July 2018 when her dispute began, warning her not to fight any charges with her credit card company.

“We are formally placing you on notice that if we receive a chargeback/credit card dispute on your behalf from your credit card issuer, we do intend to not only file a civil law suit against you for all damages for your breach of contract, but also may file a criminal complaint against you depending on how the dispute chargeback is coded and presented to us,” the email read.

This May, her employer received a letter from “Barnes Worldwide” stating that she had libeled the business in social media posts. The letter said the company was “considering filing a civil lawsuit,” and that Ms. Nee’s employer could be a party in the suit because she had used company email.

“I was mortified,” Ms. Nee said. “It’s my personal life. I had to explain it to HR.”

It wasn’t the first time a dispute involving Mr. Barnes got personal.

In 2016, before Mr. Barnes’ company’s license was revoked, the Pennsylvania PUC fined his company for exposing passengers to unsafe conditions during a party bus ride from Mars to Downtown Pittsburgh for a birthday celebration.

According to the complaint filed by the customer, Robert Sarver, an air conditioner on the bus was broken that sweltering August day in 2014, causing passengers to become overheated and nauseated. Two people allegedly vomited.

Sometime after Mr. Sarver filed his complaint, Mr. Barnes wrote a negative one-star Google review of Mr. Sarver’s landscaping business, according to the PUC administrative law judge who recommended the $500 fine.

Is it a contract?

Consumer attorney Gary Lynch of Carlson Lynch, Downtown, said the contracts that Mr. Barnes had customers sign could be running afoul of consumer protection and contract laws.

“Arguably, there is no contract,” Mr. Lynch said after reviewing the terms. He is not affiliated with any of the parties in the disputes.

The company reserves “so many rights and discretions” that the contract is “almost illusionary,” he said.

For example, the fine print states that the company has the right to terminate service without a refund if there is an “indiscretion” on the part of the customer, “to be decided solely” by the company or third party providing the service.

“It’s like saying I’ll paint your house for $1,000, but only have to paint it if I’m in the mood,” Mr. Lynch said.

In total, the terms could be considered “unconscionable,” he said, or so extreme that the contract is unfair and unenforceable.

Mr. Barnes said he didn’t want to discuss the details in his contracts. “I think our contract is very descriptive and very thorough and extremely professional compared to the industry standard,” he said.

Mr. Garcia-Tunon said that even though a contract may be unenforceable, going to court is not a viable option for many people because of the time and money involved. “People just cut their losses and walk away,” he said.

In August, Ms. Nee decided to sue Mr. Barnes in small claims court in Pittsburgh, serving him with legal papers at his address at a $1 million condominium on exclusive Fisher Island in Florida.

Mr. Barnes said he was unaware of the complaint.

Both Ms. Nee and Mr. Garcia-Tunon say they want to send a message.

“I want to see this guy liable for what he has done,” Mr. Garcia-Tunon said. “And let him know it’s not OK.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.