The new tax laws have had a lot of interesting consequences, one of which was that a new class of people are good candidates to convert their traditional retirement accounts into Roth accounts.

The trick is whether investors think tax rates are lower today than they will be down the road.

James Lange, a Roth fan and author of a book on the subject, thinks it’s a no-brainer for a lot of folks since the individual tax cuts provided by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act expire at the end of 2025. So rates could be headed back up in a few years.

“The tax rates are much lower now than ever before,” Mr. Lange said. “So, if you take my premise that the best time to do a Roth IRA conversion is when your tax rate is the lowest it will ever be, right now might be a great time to convert.”

Advertise with us

Others aren’t sure that such a move would benefit everyone. Older individuals, for instance, may not have enough life expectancy left to break even if they were to pay all their taxes upfront in a Roth conversion. But there seems to be agreement that it’s something investors should consider.

The most attractive feature of a Roth IRA is that all withdrawals from the account are tax-free, though you do not receive an income tax deduction on contributions.

Contributions to traditional IRAs or retirement plans, on the other hand, typically are deducted from income taxes and are allowed to grow tax-deferred during the years before retirement. After reaching age 59½, all withdrawals are treated as taxable income and not subject to penalty.

Before the tax cuts became law in December 2017, a married couple paid 25 percent on taxable income between $75,901 and $153,100; 28 percent on the next lump sum of income from $153,101 up to $233,350; and 33 percent on taxable income from $233,351 up to $416,700.

Now, a married couple pays 24 percent on taxable income between $168,401 and $321,450.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lange said the sweet spot for his clients’ converting from a traditional to a Roth IRA under the old law typically came when they retired but were under 70 years old, so they weren’t yet collecting Social Security or taking required minimum distributions.

But thanks to the wide 24 percent tax bracket, more younger and older folks can benefit from the Roth conversion.

The best way to benefit from a conversion is to do it at the lowest tax rate possible, especially if the person expects his or her tax rate to be higher in the future.

The deadline for making annual Roth contributions is the same as the deadline for annual traditional IRA contributions, which is the due date for filing federal tax returns. For example, the contribution deadline for the 2019 tax year is April 15, 2020. However, taxpayers can make a 2019 contribution anytime between now and then.

Roth IRAs are gaining popularity, but they still have a long way to go to catch up with Traditional IRAs. According to the Washington, D.C.-based Investment Company Institute, a total of $7.85 trillion in assets was invested in traditional IRAs at the end of 2017 compared to $810 billion total assets invested in Roth IRAs.

Advertise with us

But the way Mr. Lange sees it, the sooner retirement savers make the conversion, the sooner they can start earning tax-free income.

The most attractive feature of a Roth IRA is that all withdrawals from the account are tax-free, though you do not receive an income tax deduction on contributions.

Contributions to traditional IRAs or retirement plans, on the other hand, typically are deducted from income taxes and are allowed to grow tax-deferred during the years before retirement. After reaching age 59½, all withdrawals are treated as taxable income and not subject to penalty.

When a traditional IRA is converted to a Roth, it means the account owner is changing the tax treatment of the retirement fund. The account owner opts to pay income taxes due on the accumulated earnings and on any savings contributions that he or she took a tax deduction on in previous years. This converts the funds in the Roth IRA to after-tax money.

The conversion is not taxable for Pennsylvania income tax.

Advertise with us

Time needed to invest

Pittsburgh CPA Alex Kindler said he agrees that the new tax laws open a wider door for more people who could benefit from a conversion. But for some senior citizens, a conversion may not make economic sense.

“There is a break-even point,” said Mr. Kindler, a partner at the Green Tree-based  accounting firm H2R CPA. “If you do a Roth conversion, you’ll have to pay the tax. You have to live a number of years to break even.

“For someone who is 85 years old, a Roth IRA conversion is probably not a good idea,” he said. “Someone that old probably doesn’t have enough years of investing to make up for the tax they would pay on the conversion. Conversely, for someone 40 years old or younger who could afford to pay the taxes on a conversion, it’s a no-brainer.”

Mr. Lange is convinced it’s never too late.

Advertise with us

“I have done plenty of deathbed Roth IRA conversions and even conversions for older taxpayers,” he said.

The way Mr. Lange explains Roth conversions to his clients is it’s a way of buying out your partnership with the government in a retirement account.

“If you have $100,000 in a 401(k), it’s not your money,” he said. “You have a partnership with Uncle Sam, because when you pull that money out in retirement, Uncle Sam will take a big bite. You will pay $24,000 to the government. But by doing a Roth conversion, you write Uncle Sam a check for $24,000 now and what you have effectively done is bought out your partner.

“After 10 years go by and the money stays invested at 7 percent, you now have $200,000, but you no longer have a partner,” Mr. Lange said. “All of that money belongs to you or your family. That’s what a Roth conversion does.

“There is a general feeling that tax rates will go up in the future. With a Roth conversion, you are buying out your partner at today’s tax rate.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.