American families had more than $300 billion stashed away in 529 savings plans at the end of last year, as they tried to prepare for the expenses of sending their children to school.

But the big tax reform bill that went into effect last year changes which schools families can use that money to pay for — it’s not just college anymore but also tuition for grades K-12. And that has changed the kind of advice that financial firms should give them on investing it.

FINRA — officially the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority — is giving advisors a little time to admit they may have gotten it wrong.

The securities industry regulator has set an April 30 deadline for investment advising firms to come clean with any recommendations they have made to customers with 529 plans that are inconsistent with the accounts’ investment objectives.

Advertise with us

Firms that voluntarily report themselves by the deadline will face no fine as long as they outline how the firm will supervise future recommendations for 529 plan accounts — and they return money to any harmed investors as quickly as possible.

FINRA officials would not say if any firms have yet come forward to disclose any overcharging of fees due to poor recommendations. The organization also did not say what if any fines or penalties financial firms will face for not disclosing any violations prior to the April deadline.

“529 plans are incredibly important investment vehicles for a lot of Americans who are trying to save for the education of beneficiaries like their children, and FINRA has learned through the course of reviewing some firms’ 529 plan sales that this can be a blind spot,” said Susan Schroeder, FINRA head of enforcement.

“We’ve identified a few different kinds of supervisory issues at firms; and given the importance of the vehicle and the importance of getting money back to impacted customers if they have been impacted by issues at their firms, we think it makes sense to tell firms what we are seeing and what we’re concerned about.”

529 savings plans are tax-advantaged savings plans designed to assist families in paying for educational expenses.

Advertise with us

Unlike custodial accounts — which are taxable based upon income and capital gains — funds used for qualified educational expenses grow federal tax-free within a 529 plan, allowing more of a family’s savings to be used for tuition.

According to Chapel Hill, N.C.-based research firm Strategic Insights, families had saved $311 billion in a total of 13.9 million such accounts by the end of 2018.

“The number of accounts continue to increase in 529 plans and that’s against market volatility in 2018,” said Paul Curley, director of college savings research at Strategic Insights. “More families are contributing and the families that are contributing are contributing more.”

FINRA is concerned about the fee structure of the investments as well as the time horizon that advisers are using to make the investment choices.

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act legislation that went into effect in January 2018 was a game-changer for 529 savings plans because it dramatically broadened the scope of how the funds can be used.

Advertise with us

Such funds had been restricted to paying for college expenses, which would have made the investment horizon 18 years if the fund were started for a child at birth.

But the new tax law also allows families to use the 529 plans to pay for tuition for grades K-12.

Now, up to $10,000 per year in withdrawals will be tax-free if used for elementary or secondary school expenses, which could be incurred when the beneficiary of the account is as young as 4 or 5 years old.

“The recommendations firms are making for 529 clients are not always appropriate for the time horizon of the beneficiary,” said Michael Watling, a partner at the Atlanta law firm King & Spalding, which practices securities enforcement and regulations.

Shares of 529 plans are commonly sold in different classes with differing fee structures.

Advertise with us

Class A shares typically impose a front-end sales charge but have lower annual fees compared to other classes. Class C shares typically impose no front-end sales charge but impose higher annual fees than Class A shares.

These classes have a differing cost impact depending on the length of time the customer holds the securities.

The age of the beneficiary and the number of years until the funds will be needed to pay qualified educational expenses of the beneficiary are relevant in weighing the investment objectives of the customer.

FINRA stated in a recent regulatory notice that it has repeatedly cautioned firms to supervise recommendations to purchase higher-expense share classes, particularly when an investor seeks a long-term investment.

With Class C shares, the authority has cautioned that customers should be informed of the potential long-term effect of the higher ongoing sales charge and that firms should maintain written records of such discussions in their files.

Advertise with us

“What FINRA observed is that firms are failing to supervise the recommendations — not that the recommendations are poor,” Mr. Watling said.

“But the system for overseeing the recommendations is not robust. This is really related to the supervision of the recommendations, not necessarily the recommendations themselves.”

Mr. Watling said financial advisers need to ask more questions about how a family intends to use the money and firms need to change the way they supervise the accounts.

“What may have been an appropriate recommendation five years ago may not be true today,” he said. “Firms will need to change their supervisory systems to account for those changing circumstances.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.