Some people don’t have a long credit history. Or their credit score falls below lending guidelines, so they won’t be approved for that car loan.
A new scoring system being tested in the new year could open the door to more loan approvals — if consumers decide to embrace it.
The rating, called the Ultra FICO Score, will look at financial behavior that has not been considered before under the widely used Fair Isaac Corp. or FICO, system. It will not only size you up for how much you borrow and how quickly you pay it back, it also will consider how you manage money in the bank.
To get one of the new scores, consumers must make checking, savings and even money market accounts fair game for the prying eyes of lenders.
“This is the first time ever something other than your payment history will be considered in a credit score,” said Chris McConville, owner of Cure My Score, a Carnegie-based credit repair company.
Ultra FICO scores will launch as a pilot program in early 2019, according to an announcement made by Experian, FICO and Finicity, a company that aggregates financial data.
The pilot is designed to validate the score and, importantly, assess the willingness of consumers to share such financial data. If the pilot goes well, the Ultra FICO is expected to be more widely available by the summer.
What makes this credit score unique is that consumers must “opt-in” for lenders to use it.
Under the traditional system, when lenders request a borrower’s FICO score from a credit bureau, the score is calculated based on information in the person’s credit file.
In the new system, if that score is too low, the lender can request a recalculation using the Ultra FICO score.
Ultra FICO uses the same range — 300 to 850 — as the traditional FICO score. When banking information is factored in, the recalculation could boost the person’s score just enough to win the approval.
To opt-in for a recalculation using the Ultra FICO score, you must meet certain criteria:
— You must not have had any negative bank account balances within the last three months.
— You must have had an average balance of $400 over the last three months.
— You must be applying for credit with a lender who uses Experian for a credit report and credit score.
“Ultra FICO looks at things like how often someone overdrafts, how regular their deposits are, how much savings they have,” said Brittney Mayer, credit strategist at CardRates based in Gainesville, Fla. “It's basically a way to augment thin files and generate scores for people with limited credit history.”
She said marketing materials for the program indicate that even people with established credit could see a score boost from maintaining a good banking history.
Experian is the only one of the three major credit bureaus currently offering a recalculation using the Ultra FICO score. Representatives from Experian did not return phone calls seeking comment.
The other two major credit bureaus are TransUnion and Equifax. All three use the credit scoring system developed by FICO, which is also the most commonly used score among lenders.
In addition to evaluating an individual’s debt management, the FICO score also is used to determine what interest rate borrowers will pay.
People with scores in the 690 to 720 range will be offered the lowest rates to borrow money. Those with credit scores of 630 or below will usually be denied loans or required to pay higher borrowing costs.
The rationale behind the Ultra FICO score is that people who do a great job managing their bank accounts and have some savings are better credit risks.
But critics say the ability to handle cash might not always mean someone will handle credit well and anytime the credit industry makes it easier for people to borrow, more people are at a higher risk of default.
Consumers appear to be loading up on debt. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York reported total household debt rose by $193 billion to an all-time high of $13.15 trillion at year-end 2017.
Matt Schulz, chief industry analyst at CompareCards.com in Charlotte, N.C., said lenders and credit scoring companies have for a long time been trying to figure a way to create a credit score for people who have never had a loan before. Unless a consumer has a car loan, a student loan, a credit card or a mortgage, that person will not have a FICO score.
“There are plenty of people out there who are good risks but banks have no way of knowing that if they never borrowed before,” Mr. Schulz said.
If they’re willing to share a bit more information, they might be able to prove they are a good risk.
“The more data points you have about how someone handles their money, the easier it is to judge whether someone handles their money responsibly.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.