Wilkinsburg resident Connie Raymond recently switched her cable TV provider from Comcast to Verizon Fios looking to save a few bucks.
Her bills are lower now — but she isn’t happy.
In August, she and her husband Dale selected Verizon’s entry level “Home and Family” package. It included all of the couple’s must-have TV channels: the Game Show Network for her, and ESPN, ESPN2 and several other sports channels for him.
But when Mrs. Raymond settled in with her new service and tried to switch on the Game Show Network, she was stunned.
Her favorite channel was missing. She was livid.
Numerous calls to Verizon yielded numerous unsatisfying results.
She was told the Game Show channel had been pulled from the Home and Family lineup more than a year earlier — even though the channel was listed in the brochure she was given by Verizon’s door-to-door salesman.
Another representative implied the mix-up was her fault because she hadn’t checked the company’s website for the latest channel offerings. Mrs. Raymond says no one at Verizon advised her to do that.
In another call with Verizon, she said she was told that the company can “haphazardly change channels so you don’t always get what’s in the brochure.”
“So they can change channels whenever they want to? It doesn’t seem right,” she said.
Verizon offered to cancel her service at no charge, or switch her to a higher-tier package costing $50 more a month in order to get the Game Show Network along with the sports channels that her husband wanted.
“We must have talked to 10 different people,” but no one was willing to make things right, she said. “I wanted them to admit their mistake. I wanted somebody to step up and fix it. I wanted to get what I paid for.”
She said she felt like the victim of a bait-and-switch scheme.
“Don’t assume the brochure is correct. It isn’t,” she said.
As a matter of policy, Verizon reserves the right to change channels at any time, according to spokesman Ray McConville, who was interviewed about company practices but wasn’t given Mrs. Raymond’s name.
“We do from time to time move channels in and out of packages,” he said. “That’s not unique to us. That’s generally the standard practice in the TV service industry.”
He said Verizon’s brochures and other marketing materials “are accurate and up-to-date.”
An attempt to get clarity on the issue from regulators wasn’t easy.
The Federal Communications Commission referred questions to the Federal Trade Commission, the state Attorney General’s office or local franchising authorities.
The FTC in turn referred questions back to the FCC, while the AG’s office suggested contacting the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission about the matter.
A spokesman for the PUC said the agency had no jurisdiction over cable TV operators. He pointed to the FCC as the main regulator, which again deferred to the FTC, saying Mrs. Raymond’s problem appeared to be a truth-in-advertising case.
Finally, the FTC stepped up, agreeing to comment in general terms about truth-in-advertising rules.
Although the agency doesn’t get involved in individual disputes, it compiles complaints and can take action if it determines a company is repeatedly breaking the law.
“We would look at the representations made either in advertising or the sales process, and whether there were material omissions made,” said Kristin Williams, an attorney in the FTC’s bureau of consumer protection.
Any qualifications or restrictions— such as the ability to change a product or service — must be disclosed, she said. In addition, disclosures must be “clear and conspicuous,” meaning they should be something “a reasonable consumer would see,” she said.
When asked about Verizon’s disclaimers, Mr. McConville said he would check, but never followed up.
Mrs. Raymond provided a copy of her Fios TV brochure, which at the bottom of the last page stated, “Verizon Fios TV occasionally changes its channel offerings.” Further down it stated, “Programming services offered within each package are subject to change.”
Ms. Williams advised consumers to read sales materials closely before signing up for any service.
“If there’s something of particular importance, you should ask the representative directly about whether it’s included and whether it could change,” she said.
Meanwhile, Mrs. Raymond said she was disappointed, but resigned to doing without the Game Show channel, including $25,000 Pyramid, Cash Cab and Jeopardy re-runs.
“I’m not giving Verizon 50 more bucks a month,” she said.
To file a complaint with the FTC about unfair or deceptive business practices, visit www.ftccomplaintassistant.gov/ or call 1-877-382-4357. The Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General takes consumer complaints at www.attorneygeneral.gov/submit-a-complaint/ or 1-800-441-2555.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.