In the five years since Michael Taubes bought a home for $300,000 in Pleasant Hills, his property taxes have increased from $4,600 when he first purchased it to a current tax bill of just more than $8,000.
He thought it was a mistake when he received a tax bill this year that was higher than what he paid last year.
“I called the tax collector to find out why it went up,” he said “The person I talked to told me that it will keep going up for the next seven years to pay for the new school [in West Jefferson Hills School District]. She told me it was a done deal.”
The 46-year-old single dad had planned on making extra payments to wipe out his 30-year mortgage in 15 years. Now he’s trying to keep his head above water due to the $675 a month tax bill.
Owners of recently sold properties in Allegheny County are being hit with a disproportionately high tax burden compared to owners of similar properties that were not sold since 2012 — the last time the county reassessed homes — creating a disparity among homeowners.
Mr. Taubes said he recently pulled his twin 14-year-old daughters out of competitive cheerleading because the extra $200 or $300 a month now goes toward taxes.
“The thing that scares me is I don’t know where it’s going to end,” he said. “I don’t think it’s ethical to change somebody’s payments after you agree to something. When the bank approves you for a certain monthly payment that doesn’t mean they would have approved you for the higher amount you are now stuck with. I think the banks are being misled also.”
Mr. Taubes’ case isn’t unique. One year after Kristin Price, 31, and Andrew Scibetta, 34, purchased their home in Upper Lawrenceville for $232,000 in 2014, their property tax bill jumped 320 percent.
“I remember right before Christmas in 2015 we received a letter stating we owed an increased property tax of $5,000 that was due in two weeks,” said Ms. Price, an accountant.
After digging out of a $5,000 tax deficit that temporarily pushed their mortgage $900 a month higher, she and her partner, a financial adviser, held onto their home. Still, they are stuck with a tax bill that is $350 per month higher than when they bought the house. “We are fortunate to be able to absorb that huge increase,” she said. “A lot of people would not have been able to make that happen.”
Rising values
One downside of rising home values in the Pittsburgh region is that many homeowners have been saddled with higher property taxes due to increased assessed values.
But taxes have not been rising for all homeowners across the board. The last reassessment of home values in Allegheny County took place in 2012. Since then, school districts have been picking and choosing which homes to reassess, and some districts are more aggressive than others.
More often than not, the owners of recently purchased homes have found themselves in the cross hairs of tax collectors due to higher sales prices while the owners of properties that have not sold since the 2012 base year have generally been left alone.
“School districts target homes that have recently been sold because when they file appeals [for a higher tax assessment] they are responsible for bringing evidence,” said Janet Burkardt, a partner at Weiss Burkardt & Kramer, Downtown. “Evidence of recent sales is easy and inexpensive to get.
“There is no need to hire experts and appraisers,” she said. “School districts only need to show a deed for the higher sales price and comparable sales in the neighborhood.”
Tim Whitney and Dennis Palmer saw a 41 percent jump in their property tax bill the year after they paid $355,000 for a home in Green Tree in the Keystone Oaks School District.
“We definitely got the big surprise after we bought our house,” said Mr. Whitney, a 58-year-old clinical psychologist. “When we bought the house, we thought the current tax was our tax.”
Allegheny County is not alone. The same situation exists in other Pennsylvania counties that do not perform regular full-scale reassessments.
The unequal system of reassessment has created two sub-classes of real estate that are taxed differently — recently sold properties that are taxed based on current market values set by higher sales prices; and unsold properties that remained taxed at the lower 2012 base year values.
A ‘newcomer tax’?
“You could have a street where everyone has lived there awhile and everyone is being assessed at $200,000,” said Edward Friedman from the Downtown law firm Friedman & Friedman. “But one person sells his house for $300,000, and the local school district will file an appeal on that house alone based on the higher sales price.”
“The school district will raise the assessed value of that one house to about $280,000, but meanwhile everyone else on the street is assessed at $200,000,” he said. “The other houses are untouched, and the new buyer is singled out solely because of the sale. Only the new buyer’s taxes go up.”
Friedman & Friedman has filed a lawsuit on behalf of homeowners in the city of Pittsburgh who believe they have been unfairly targeted for a property tax increase due to what they are calling the “newcomer tax.”
“What you have is an unfair system, which penalizes buyers who often wind up with their real estate taxes doubled or tripled,” Mr. Friedman said.
“We believe this is unfair and a violation of the Pennsylvania constitution that requires uniformity of assessments for real estate. The only people who get tax increases are the ones who get appealed by school districts.”
School districts are sympathetic to people faced with increasingly unaffordable mortgages due to rising property taxes, said Ira Weiss, a Pittsburgh attorney who represents 14 school districts in Western Pennsylvania.
The problem, he said, is school districts don’t have a lot of options to raise revenue due to the taxing structure the state Legislature has created.
Mr. Weiss, a partner at Weiss Burkardt & Kramer, said public education is expensive. “There is constant upward pressure on the cost of operating schools. The average cost of salary increases in public education are at least 2 percent to 3 percent putting aside utilities, supplies and technology.”
He puts much of the blame for rising property taxes on state legislators.
“[Homeowners] need to talk to their state senators and state representatives and advocate for greater state support of local education,” Mr. Weiss said. “These state officials are passing the buck to local officials to raise taxes. That’s the problem. If the state were to step up and fund education as it should be funded, then you wouldn’t have these local taxes going up the way they do.
“I can understand the difficulties many homeowners have in the area of assessments rising and millage rises,” he said. “But in public education, the cost drivers go up. One of the big factors in the last eight or nine years has been the skyrocketing cost of pensions.”
He said school districts pay a percentage of salary costs into the pension fund. At one time it was 2 percent and 3 percent. Now, it’s more than 30 percent.
Although school districts stand to benefit the most when property assessments go up, the county and municipalities where the homes are located also benefit.
According to the City of Pittsburgh Department of Finance, the Pittsburgh school district collected $170 million in real estate tax in 2017 compared to $167.7 million in 2016 and $162 million in 2015.
The city, on the other hand, collected $140 million in property tax in 2017 compared to $139 million in 2016 and $133.6 million in 2015.
County revenue from the real estate tax was not available. However, the county millage rate has remained at 4.73 percent.
‘I went around the neighborhood’
Mr. Taubes bought his house in 2013 from June Jones, who had lived there since 2003 with her husband, Lynn.
Ms. Jones, 67, took money from the $300,000 sale and paid $278,000 for a carriage home in the same community.
A year and a half after moving, in she was informed by the West Jefferson Hills School District that her home would be reassessed for her purchase price.
She hired an attorney to fight the reassessment and won her appeal. Later, the school district appealed again.The second time around she reached a bargain for a new assessment of $250,000. However, the higher tax was retroactive from the time she moved in.
“I went around the neighborhood to see if others had gotten this appeal, and nobody had except for the people who had purchased recently,” Ms. Jones said.
“I paid the taxes and sold the home at a loss,” she said. “I couldn’t afford it. I sold it for a loss and gave the money to my daughter. She bought a house for $150,000, and my husband and I moved in with her.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.