For officials at Advantage Credit Counseling Service on the South Side, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is considered an important, if underappreciated, champion of consumer rights.
“Not a lot of consumers are aware of what the CFPB does,” said Heather Murray, manager of community relations at the counseling service. “But from the regulatory perspective, the big bank settlements, [the exposing of] Wells Fargo — who knows if any of that would have come to light without the CFPB.”
One of the most dramatic reforms in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis was the creation of the bureau to serve as the nation’s top consumer watchdog.
In operation since 2011, leading consumer advocates say the agency’s success in protecting the average consumer’s wallet from deceptive and abusive practices is hard to overstate.
“Before the consumer bureau, there was no agency that either had the focus or the resources or the tools to protect consumers,” said Lauren Saunders, associate director at the National Consumer Law Center in Washington, D.C. “We saw the devastating consequences in the mortgage market, the credit card market and many other places” preceding the financial meltdown, she said.
“The silver lining of the crisis is hopefully we have an agency now that can prevent this kind of crisis from happening again.”
The years leading up to the Great Recession were the “wild, wild west days of lending,” when lenders peddled products such as interest-only mortgages and no-doc loans without regard for whether borrowers could repay them, said Yana Miles, senior legislative counsel at the Center for Responsible Lending based in Durham, N.C.
Enter our In the Lead special section
“We got to the almost complete collapse of the economy. Congress responded with the Dodd-Frank” legislation that created the consumer protection bureau, she said.
High on the list of the agency’s top accomplishments is the creation of the qualified mortgage rule, experts said. The rule established an ability-to-repay standard in an effort to prohibit lenders from offering mortgages to borrowers who can’t afford them.
“It’s pretty groundbreaking,” Ms. Miles said. “It addresses the abuses and the direct causes of the housing meltdown and the financial collapse.”
To be sure, the agency isn’t without its critics — notably the Trump administration and the financial services industry — which contend the bureau has been overly aggressive and lacks enough oversight.
These opponents argue that the agency’s actions have limited consumer access to financial services. And they say the bureau has too much power because it’s run by a single director who can’t be fired by the president at will and because it gets its funding from the Federal Reserve instead of Congress.
In January, the constitutionality of the bureau’s structure — which had been challenged by a New Jersey mortgage service provider — was upheld by a federal appeals court. The ruling meant the CFPB could continue to be run by a single director instead of by a commission as some critics had advocated.
Besides the qualified mortgage rule, some of the bureau’s other top achievements cited by consumer groups include:
• Ordering credit card companies to refund $3.5 billion to consumers tricked into accepting costly add-on products and services, such as debt protection and credit monitoring;
• Fighting discriminatory auto lending through a joint investigation with the U.S. Department of Justice that concluded Ally Financial was charging minorities higher rates than white consumers with similar credit histories. Ally was ordered to return $80 million to borrowers harmed by its practices;
• Fining American Advisors Group, Reverse Mortgage Solutions and Aegean Financial for ads that duped consumers into believing they could not lose their homes with a reverse mortgage;
• Adopting rules requiring issuers of reloadable prepaid cards to provide better fee disclosures and the same protections that cover debit and credit cards, such as protections from unauthorized purchases. (The new rules have not yet been implemented.)
• Playing a key role in exposing Wells Fargo for misusing customers’ personal information by opening nearly 2 million fraudulent accounts in their names. The agency fined the bank $100 million — the largest ever penalty imposed by the bureau — finding that bank employees opened the accounts to hit sales targets and earn bonuses.
Another crucial function is its online complaint system, experts said. “The bureau actually looks into complaints and gets consumer issues resolved,” said Anna Laitin, director of financial policy at Consumers Union, a nonprofit investigative group that publishes Consumer Reports magazine.
The agency studies the complaints — it’s received some 1.2 million so far — to spot patterns of abuse. Roughly 34,000 came from Pennsylvanians.
A new direction for the bureau’s future
The same consumer advocates who consider the bureau’s work invaluable worry about its future in the wake of President Donald Trump’s appointment in November of former U.S. congressman Mick Mulvaney as acting director.
Mr. Mulvaney, who also serves as White House budget director, had been one of the agency’s most vocal critics, referring to it as a “joke” and saying he’d like to get rid of it.
In his first few months at the helm, several of Mr. Mulvaney’s actions drew harsh criticism from consumer advocacy groups.
They included a funding request of “$0” to finance the agency for the first quarter in order to spend down the bureau’s reserve fund; a restructuring of the fair lending office — a move seen by consumer groups as a way to rein in the unit’s enforcement powers; and the release of a strategic plan in mid-February that dramatically restructured the bureau.
Mr. Mulvaney also drew fire for reportedly scaling back the agency’s probe of Equifax, the credit bureau that was hacked last year — exposing Social Security numbers and other sensitive financial and personal data of an estimated 145 million Americans. In March, Equifax disclosed another batch of 2.4 million customers whose names and partial driver’s license numbers were compromised.
More recently in April, the bureau releasd its semi-annual report in which Mr. Mulvaney recommened major structural changes, including funding the bureau through Congressional appropriations and requiring legislative approval of major rules.
“The bureau is too powerful, with precious little oversight,” he said at the time. “The power...could all too easily be used to harm consumers, destroy businesses or arbitrarily remake American financial markets.”
Consumer groups quickly bashed the recommendations, saying they would politicize the agency and dramatically diminish its independence.
A spokesman for the American Bankers Association said the group was pleased with the consumer bureau’s new direction.
“We appreciate the willingness of the bureau’s new leadership to fully consider the perspective of our members and other stakeholders in setting financial rules that will genuinely help consumers by expanding choice and improving availability of services,” spokesman Jeff Sigmund said in an email in February.
“While we have disagreed with the CFPB in the past over specific policies, we have always shared the bureau’s goal of wanting to help consumers,” he said.
Ms. Saunders of the consumer law center said it was time for the public to step in to fight for the bureau.
“It’s an agency that not a lot of people know exists,” Ms. Laitin of Consumers Union said. “But it’s doing a lot of good. The states may try to step in, but it’s not replaceable.”
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.