Just as millions of Americans were being shaken by the colossal Equifax data breach, Javelin released its annual scorecard on how well big banks are protecting consumer accounts from fraud.

The California-based financial advisory firm rated 28 of the nation’s largest financial institutions, including four with operations in the Pittsburgh area: PNC, Citizens, Key and Huntington.

“Financial institutions’s account security measures must address an increasingly complex set of fraud threats,” said Al Pascual, chief of fraud and security at Javelin Strategy & Research. “Addressing these threats while facilitating consumers’ increasingly complex demands requires a robust and flexible set of tools.”

The banks were evaluated on three criteria: prevention, detection and resolution.

Advertise with us

In the resolution category, banks were rated on such things as whether they had a 24/7 toll-free number for reporting fraud, whether they had next day card replacement and funds availability, and whether they had zero liability coverage and a dedicated fraud resolution expert.

Scores landed the banks in one of four tiers, with the first tier being the best and the fourth tier the worst.

Pittsburgh-based PNC, the region’s market leader, scored the best overall among the local banks, placing in the top tier for resolution and the second tier for prevention and detection.

Key Bank fared the worst, landing in the third tier for prevention and resolution, and in the bottom tier (which Javelin termed “laggards”) for detection.

The Cleveland, Ohio-based bank emailed a statement saying it “constantly seeks to improve [its] security protocols in an evolving and increasingly challenging threat landscape,” and uses “sophisticated tools and technology to protect clients’ financial information.”

Advertise with us

Among the other local banks, Citizens placed in the second tier for prevention and the third tier for detection and resolution, while Huntington finished in the second tier for detection, third tier for prevention and bottom tier for resolution.

Citizens, headquartered in Providence, R.I., declined comment.

Huntington spokesman Michael Sherman said the Columbus, Ohio-based bank had not seen the study. “We are committed to doing all we can to protect our customers,” he said in an email.

Among all 28 banks, USAA based in San Antonio scored the highest, earning Javelin’s “Best in Class” award.

The report noted that in 2016, identity theft claimed a record 15.4 million victims in the U.S.

Advertise with us

More worrisome, the report said, was the resurgence of account takeover, which rebounded in 2016 to affect 1.4 million consumers, up from a low point in 2015 of 1 million victims.

Account takeover is when a crook changes login credentials, contact information or settings to gain control of an account. Locking consumers out of an account, and blocking alerts to any fraudulent activity, may allow thieves time to drain the account.

Experts recommend that consumers use strong passwords and change them frequently.

To see the results for all 28 financial institutions, visit http://bit.ly/2f6seXI

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.