Brookline — that mild-mannered South Hills community with good housing stock, mostly built after 1950, and easily accessible to the city’s subway line — had a big year in 2016.

“Right now, houses in Brookline are selling faster than any place — timewise — at least in the city, maybe in the suburbs, too,” said Howard “Hoddy” Hanna III, chairman of O’Hara-based Howard Hanna Real Estate Services, the region’s No. 1 real estate firm.  

Mr. Hanna keeps a close eye on the Pittsburgh market. His real estate agents sold 95,152 homes last year in all of the states where the company operates, up 43 percent from the year before. Its Pittsburgh-area sales represent a hefty 23 percent chunk of the overall 56,236 total units sold in the region.

Hanna works in several states, and last year acquired the largest real estate brokerage in the state of New York as well as other real estate agencies in North Carolina, Cleveland and other areas of Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

But this is still the company’s home turf, and the shifts and sales here are important.

Mr. Hanna identified three up-and-coming city neighborhoods where average sales prices for homes exploded in 2016, rising above the 3.5 percent average sales price increase in the Pittsburgh market.

Figures provided by West Penn Multi-List show that between 2015 and the end of 2016, residential home prices in Brookline appreciated 8 percent. Greenfield also had an 8 percent price increase, followed by Highland Park with a 7 percent increase due to the burst of housing demand in nearby East Liberty.

Average home prices in Brookline rose last year to $109,426 from $101,262 the previous year; Greenfield average sale prices jumped to $153,118 from $141,319; and Highland Park homes sold for an average $527,295 last year from $492,726.

In the fourth quarter of 2016, the median price of a home in the Pittsburgh region was $130,000, a steal in comparison to the national average of $235,000, according to HSH.com, an online mortgage broker. If homeowners in the metro area put 10 percent down on a median priced home, the website calculates buyers could afford the home with an annual salary of $36,862.

Advertise with us

Although interest rates are poised to march higher, Mr. Hanna does not see higher rates slowing down the housing market as long as they don’t spike more than 0.75 percent.

“The biggest thing when you increase rates is how many buyers do you knock out of the affordability factor,” he said.

A year-end assessment of trends in Pittsburgh housing showed several high-profile communities that consistently outperform the overall housing market remain strong even though some had lower than average price appreciation last year. One of them — Peters — actually lost value.

The top appreciating community in 2016 was Mt. Lebanon in the South Hills, where housing prices rose an average 10 percent to $290,481 from $264,073. Next was East End stalwart Squirrel Hill, which saw appreciation of 9.15 percent. Home prices in Squirrel Hill rose, on average, to $416,846 from $381,915. Shadyside homes, also in the East End, sold for 7.86 percent higher prices last year to $386,164 from $358,014.

But Lawrenceville, a neighborhood that has seen its housing values appreciate by double digits in recent years due to demand by millennial buyers as well as investors, is showing signs of a slowdown. The average sale price of homes rose by only 4.97 percent to $222,885 from $212,324.

Advertise with us

Cranberry home prices rose only 0.99 percent to $309,933 from $306,893. The average price of homes sold in Peters declined last year by 1.53 percent, falling to $395,531 from $401,678 in 2015.

Strong bones 

Mr. Hanna said one of the main factors driving the high sales activity and the jump in prices in Greenfield and Brookline is affordability.

He compares it to the early stages of Lawrenceville’s housing boom.

“We don’t know when that affordability will change,” he said. “I don’t know if we are going to see that kind of explosion in pricing in Brookline, Greenfield and Highland Park. But we did see a lot of explosion in pricing last year and I think that’s going to continue.

Advertise with us

“We are seeing real good price movement and demand in Greenfield, and when you think about it, with the shortage of houses that we have in the city and the convenience of Greenfield to the universities, Downtown, primary work places and the South Side, it’s very convenient there. They’ve got good housing stock, older housing stock like most of the city, but good housing stock.”

Brookline has always attracted city workers, police officers and firefighters. Now, Mr. Hanna said, young professionals are buying homes and upgrading them.

“The solid housing stock and the strong bones of these old houses makes these neighborhoods attractive,” Mr. Hanna said.

While housing prices in the Pittsburgh market continue to increase by a steady 3 percent each year, prices in some communities have barely budged. One example is Penn Hills.

“In Penn Hills, there is a lot of housing stock, but the prices aren’t going up,” Mr. Hanna said. “There is a lack of demand to live there. People have not invested in those houses to upgrade them.

Advertise with us

“Buyers want houses where they can come in and not have a whole lot of maintenance. So, it’s hard in a community like Penn Hills, where they feel like they need to upgrade a lot.”

But there is opportunity for buyers looking for solid communities.

“The South Side is solid. Downtown is great. The Strip District is coming back,” Mr. Hanna said. “Lawrenceville is superb. There is Shadyside, Squirrel Hill. Garfield is still in the throes [of a turnaround]. I’d like to say Homewood has come back, but has a ways to go. The West End of the city sort of let go.”

The upper part of the South Side needs some attention.

“You go to Carrick and Beltzhoover and Allentown and, housing-wise, those neighborhoods are not doing very well up there,” he said. “My theory about urban housing rebound is you’ve got to get Main Street fixed. People have to be on Main Street with businesses.”

Advertise with us

Apartment market overbuilt

One trend that has begun to affect the region’s real estate market is the growing number of apartment buildings, especially on the East End, where apartments are renting for about $1,500 to $2,500 a month.

Mr. Hanna has said that the apartment market is overbuilt.

“I think we are seeing the bubble right now — at least in the East End,” Mr. Hanna said. “The new buildings are renting out, but they are taking those people from other buildings. Apartment buildings that were 30, 40 or 50 years old but were experiencing high rental rates are now feeling it.

“If they were running a 90 percent occupancy rate, they are down to 80 percent right now. Almost everyone I know who is in that business is experiencing more vacancy than they have ever had in the last 15 years because there are fewer tenants to fill all those spaces.”

Advertise with us

The amenities of new buildings are a big attraction.

“Maybe you have got an apartment in an older building with less amenities and your rent is $1,000 or $1,100 a month, and you can go to a building right down the street that is brand new that’s got a gym inside or a fancy pool,” he said. “You might be paying $1,350. But you would rather pay an extra $250 a month to get more amenities.”

Firm looks to expand

Not only was 2016 a good year for Pittsburgh real estate as a whole, it was a good year for Howard Hanna Real Estate Services.

Closed real estate sales volume was up 38 percent in 2016 over 2015 at $17.5 billion, with 95,152 closed units, up 43 percent, making Howard Hanna the third largest real estate company in the U.S. and the country’s largest privately held real estate company.

Advertise with us

“This year we will probably expand a couple of different ways,” Mr. Hanna said. “We are going to hopefully buy a couple of new mortgage companies in New York state, in particular. We are going to probably continue to expand our commercial presence both here, Cleveland and New York for sure.”

The third area of growth will be through a company it has formed called Horizons Relocation, which works with corporations. Instead of the corporation forming its own real estate department, Howard Hanna becomes the company’s real estate department when it transfers workers.

“Our growth this year will be in mortgage companies, commercial companies and our relocation business,” he said. “Now that doesn’t preclude us from buying more real estate companies, but that’s not our focus right now.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.