Many of the nation’s biggest banks continue to charge excessively high overdraft fees and employ unfair practices that make it more likely customers will overdraw their accounts multiple times, according to an annual study by Pew Charitable Trusts.

(Click image for larger version)

The Philadelphia-based nonprofit said high overdraft charges remain a major problem, particularly for lower-income households stung disproportionately by the fees.

The group called on federal regulators to do more to protect consumers by setting “reasonable limits” on overdraft charges and banning the practice of clearing transactions from highest amount to lowest (instead of chronologically), a maneuver that tends to drain an account more quickly and trigger the most fees.

Advertise with us

“Consumers — especially those who are most financially vulnerable — need protections to help them avoid expensive overdraft fees and remain viable in the banking system,” Pew said in the report.

The median overdraft fee among the banks surveyed was $35.

Virginia O’Neill, senior vice president with the America Bankers Association, said banks offer customers a variety of ways to monitor their balances and avoid overdrawing their accounts, including text alerts and the ability to check their accounts online or by phone.

She added that some customers prefer their largest transactions be cleared first because that helps ensure important bills such as rent and mortgage payments will be paid.

Pew’s fourth annual review scored banks on how they handle overdrafts based on a set of best and good practices. Just five banks earned a perfect seven-out-of-seven score, including Ally, Charles Schwab Bank, Discover Bank, HSBC and USAA.

Advertise with us

Among four banks in the survey with branches in the Pittsburgh region, Huntington earned 4 points out of 7, while KeyBank, Citizens Bank and market leader PNC each received 3 points.

Huntington and KeyBank received high marks for never re-sequencing transactions from high-to-low, while PNC and Citizens received partial credit for limiting the practice.

All four local banks got points for capping the number of overdraft charges per day, while Huntington, PNC and Citizens each earned a point for waiving fees for small overdrafts, typically amounts of less than $5.

Other practices that Pew said banks should follow include not allowing customers to overdraw their accounts with a debit card at ATMs or at the register.

Pew also said banks should eliminate so-called continuous overdraft fees, which are extra charges that kick in when an account remains in the red for a certain period.

Advertise with us

In a companion study, Pew found many small banks share many of the same overdraft policies as the big banks, with most charging $28 to $36 per overdraft.

On the plus side, the report found that high-to-low transaction reordering — which Pew said is conducted in at least a limited way at about 40 percent of the largest banks — was rare among the 45 smaller institutions studied.

The complete Pew overdraft study is available online in the research and analysis section at www.pewtrusts.org.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.