2016 BMW X1 xDrive28i: A fun little premium crossover?

Price: $43,945 as tested. (A basic model could be had for $33,100.)

Marketers pitch: “Versatility without limits.”

Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com liked the “class-leading cargo capacity; … interior materials “ and that it was “quickest and most agile among its competitors”; downsides include that its “sporty personality is a disadvantage when trying to reach fuel economy estimates; lack of a six-cylinder engine option.”

Advertise with us

Reality: Well …

What’s new: All of it, well, if you believe those things. But it is redesigned for the 2016 model year and features “a roomier interior, greater efficiency and technology on the forefront of innovation,” according to BMW’s media web site.

Up to speed: Getting on the highway was no sweat for the 228-horsepower, 2.0-liter Twinpower turbo four-cylinder engine, though 12 horses have gotten pink slips since the 2015 model year’s 240 rating.

Shifty: My first response to the X1’s eight-speed StepTronic shiftable automatic transmission — it’s actually too smooth. On my first ride into town, I couldn’t feel any shifts at all, and I started to wonder if BMW made a foray into cheapskateland and went CVT on me.

But the transmission features gears after all. The shift lever has nice feel, so pushing through all the gears is fun and not tiring.

Advertise with us

On the curves: Here’s where the X1 — like almost all BMWs — shines. Winding country roads were a joy, although the light, tall crossover did experience a touch of corner liftoff when really overdoing it.

Less expensive BMW: It’s funny how Kia will offer a Soul for under $25,000 — still a lot for a Soul — that has more expensive feeling materials than a bottom-of-the-line BMW crossover for nearly twice the price. And that I’m so substantively disagreeing with Edmunds on this point.

To me, the plastic dashboard, trim, faux wood materials, and steering wheel looked and felt super cheap. Door handles and the shift lever feel more upscale, though, as does the BMW interior design.

Friends and stuff: Sturgis Kid 4.0 reports legroom was disappointing although head room was OK. The rear seat does not move forward and back, although the recline adjusts.

The seats themselves are nothing to write home about. Sure they’re covered in dead cow, but their SensaTec material recalled cheap 1970s kitchenette, with a border trimming the sides and front. They’re comfortable, though, if a little firm.

Advertise with us

The cargo capacity is 58.7 with the rear seat folded down, again akin to the Soul.

Info, please: The classic BMW gauge pod — simple dials all around — remains attractive and functional.

Play some tunes: BMW’s interface remains my favorite (well, tied with Mazda, but BMW was the first in the game). A knob and buttons makes getting through the menu simple, although Mazda does allow users to dial through a more intuitive circle of choices in the main screen.

The CD player sits in the middle of the dash with an old-style radio look. The lone knob controls volume while buttons allow for easy changing of the band and mode.

The sound was an A-.

Advertise with us

Keeping warm and cool: Two dials control the heat separately for Mr. Driver’s Seat and Mrs. Passenger Seat. A sync button works them harmoniously, or more likely when I’m driving by myself, as there is little harmonious about thermostat control in our relationship.

Night shift: The awesome purply LED headlights provided plenty of glow to drive by. The interior lights were subtle and direct, casting just enough light without interfering with the view of the road.

The ambient lighting along the doors and the outer door handles was pretty, though.

Fuel economy: I averaged 27 mpg in the X1, which is fairly respectable. It dropped when I pushed it but rose back up with some more sedate drives. Premium is recommended.

Where it’s built: Regensburg, Germany

Advertise with us

How it’s built: The X1’s reliability was deemed very good for the 2016 model year by Consumer Reports; the 2017’s has slipped to average.

In the end: Perhaps I’m being too harsh, and readers should consider my differences with Edmunds.com. The X1 is fun and a worthy vehicle, but I can’t justify the expense over some lesser forms of crossover.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.