2016 Mazda CX-9 Signature AWD: The biggest Mazda goes SkyActiv.

Price: $45,215 as tested. Only option was machine gray paint, which is totally not worth $200. A base CX-9 FWD starts at $31,520.

Marketer’s pitch: “Introducing the driver’s SUV.”

Conventional wisdom: Up against the Honda Pilot for 2015, I concluded “if Mazda would correct this (low fuel economy), and offer a better screen, it would be the CX-9 hands down.”

Advertise with us

Reality: Keeps the best parts and improves on some of the worst.

Family units, part 2: After spending last week in the new 2017 Chrysler Pacifica minivan, I decided to do a bit of a comparison with the new-for-2016 CX-9. Like a minivan, this crossover features three rows of seats, and the Sturgis Family was able to take both units across Pennsylvania to visit family.

Welcome revisions: I’d been eager for the all-new CX-9 to land in my drive since I’d first heard first plans for it. The previous generation was one of the sportiest three-row crossovers on the market, right up there with the BMW X5.

Unfortunately, despite its sporty styling and cozy interior, the old CX-9 was a piggy. With its 3.7-liter V-6 engine, my testing put it in the bottom of all vehicles tested, at 16 mpg in the 2015 model.

Under the hood: First and foremost, the CX-9 has gotten a whole new powerplant, a 227-horsepower 2.5-liter SkyActiv turbocharged four-cylinder. (That’s a 43-horse improvement over the normally aspirated version in the smaller CX-5.)

Advertise with us

Like other SkyActiv engines, the horsepower ratings are far below competitors’, which land in the high 200s or even low 300s. But the 310 pound-feet of torque mean the engine motivates the vehicle quite well. Getting on highways and up hills — even over the Alleghenies — is a breeze.

Fuel economy: I averaged just over 20 mpg in the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat array of highway and suburban driving. This may be a 25 percent improvement, but one thinks it could still be far better. It was 4 mpg less than the Pacifica.

On the curves: I feared that perhaps as Mazda improved some things, maybe the company would finally design the fun out of one of these vehicles.

Not this one. I dubbed it “super fun to drive” in my early notes. And then I found Sport mode and it got even better. It does have its limits, but it is an all-wheel-drive taller crossover.

Shifty: But Sport is best left to people who like doing their own shifting; the shift logic for the six-speed automatic transmission in automatic mode was difficult. It held gears far too long for my tastes, even when the accelerator was off and I was headed downhill.

Advertise with us

Driver’s Seat: At first I found the leather seats quite firm, but they softened up on the second day.

Friends and stuff: Too-tall Sturgis Kid 4.0 (now approaching 16 and beyond the six-foot mark) kept whining about the third row being far too small for even a short trip. I spent some time back there taking notes. It sits low and knee and foot room are difficult, but headroom is ample.

But let me whine about the cargo space, which behind the third row can hold about four small bags or so, before you have to start stacking. And third-row heads sit frighteningly against the rear glass.

A generous console can hold plenty of goodies, and a tray in front of the gearshift holds more than one phone with ease.

Play some tunes: The CX-9 benefits not only from BMW-like handling, but also from a BMWesque dial and three buttons to control the stereo interface. With some practice, your eyes almost never have to leave the road.

Advertise with us

And then there’s the sound. I switched to my test song, and the guitar licks that go missing in so many vehicles come in loud and clear, even when the volume was turned down. As Miss Shields would grade Ralphie’s theme in his “A Christmas Story” dream, “A plus-plus-plus-plus-plus-plus-plus.”

Keeping warm and cool: Mazda came to the tech revolution slowly, and the HVAC interfaces remain subpar. They’re not difficult — dials control the temperature and buttons control the fan and location of the air — but those buttons are really, really small.

Night shift: Interior lights are quite bright. The headlights are set fairly low on low beam. The combination makes it difficult to see the road from the CX-9 after hours.

In the weather: Rain handling was confident; strong storms came while I had the CX-9 and it stayed the course throughout.

Where it’s built: Hiroshima, Japan

Advertise with us

How it’s built: Consumer Reports predicts the CX-9 will be better than average for reliability.

In the end: If you need all-wheel drive and don’t need a third row for grown-ups, the CX-9 could be the choice for you, though a look into the Kia Sorento might be in order. But this and the Pacifica both make for significant upgrades over previous products and make these family units better.

Note: In last week’s Pacifica review, I included the reliability of the 2014 Chrysler Town& Country, which I reviewed. Consumer Reports notes the reliability of the 2016 T&C has improved to “good,” so the Pacifica looks even better.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.