WASHINGTON – Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf’s apology fell flat Tuesday during a Senate Banking Committee hearing at which he was blasted for being a “gutless leader,” for profiting from unethical behavior and for failing to hold the right people accountable for the massive scandal that has rocked his bank.
Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., called for Mr. Stumpf’s resignation and for a criminal investigation of his creation of a culture that encouraged low-level employees to open phantom banking and credit card accounts for customers who hadn’t asked for them, and then charging fees for them.
“You should resign. You should give back the money you took while this scam was going on, and you should be criminally investigated,” Ms. Warren told Mr. Stumpf, who was on the hot seat for three hours. “The only way Wall Street will change is if executives face jail time when they preside over massive frauds.”
Mr. Stumpf apologized for his bank’s missteps and said he accepted responsibility for them, but he refused to call what happened fraud and he continued to blame 5,300 rogue employees, who have since been fired. He said no one directed them to create unwanted accounts.
Lawmakers, including Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., appeared incredulous.
“When thousands of people conduct the same kind of fraudulent activity, it’s a stretch to believe that every one of them independently conjured up the idea of how they would commit this fraud,” said Mr. Toomey, whose state has 268 Wells Fargo branches. “Doesn’t it defy common sense to think there wasn’t some orchestration of this?”
Other lawmakers said bank employees have told them they feared for their jobs if they didn’t meet quotas, that managers sometimes required them to work Saturday phone banks if they were coming up short and that they begged friends and relatives to open accounts.
“This is the only way they could keep their jobs because of what was going on,” said Sen. Joe Donnelly, D-Ind.
Sen. Jeff Merkley, D-Ore., described their working environment as a pressure cooker and told Mr. Stumpf that if he truly accepted responsibility, he would resign rather than blame employees he put “in an impossible situation” by setting unrealistic performance goals.
“You say, ‘I accept responsibility, and by the way it’s the fault of those 5,000 people who just weren’t ethical enough.’ That’s not accepting responsibility,” Mr. Merkley said. “This is a systemic problem that you benefited from enormously, and you are scapegoating the people at the very bottom.”
He said it’s unfair to blame low-level employees who earned $35,000 a year while executives collected high salaries and bonuses based on the fraudulent activities. Mr. Stumpf was paid $19.3 million last year.
Carrie Tolstedt, the vice president responsible for the department where the scandal occurred, retired in July at least partly because of it. She took more than $100 million in stock options and other compensation with her and remains eligible for a bonus at the end of this year. If she had been fired, her compensation would have been $45 million less, Ms. Warren noted.
She pressed Mr. Stumpf to say whether he believes Ms. Tolstedt should have been fired and whether he believes she should be ineligible for a 2016 bonus.
He repeatedly declined to answer.
The scandal has resulted in $185 million in fines, a commitment to set aside $5 million to reimburse customers who were charged fees on the fraudulent accounts, the installation of independent overseers at the bank, and new procedures including a requirement for employees to get signatures of credit card applicants and to obtain customer confirmation before new accounts are created.
Mr. Stumpf said he became aware of the employees’ practice in 2013 — after it had already been going on for at least two years — and told them to stop.
He said there was no scheme to open unauthorized accounts.
“Wrongful sales practices goes entirely against our values, ethics and culture and runs counter to our business strategy of helping our customers succeed financially and deepening our relationship with those customers,” he testified. “The goal here is not products. The goal here is developing relationships” with customers.
But Ms. Warren produced a 2010 annual report that said Wells Fargo’s goal was for every customer to have eight accounts.
“Cross-selling isn’t about getting customers what they need. If it was, you wouldn’t need to squeeze your employees so hard,” she said.
“If there ever were a textbook case where consumers need protection, this is it,” said Banking Committee chairman Richard Shelby, R-Ala.
Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton also waded into the issue Tuesday. In an open letter to Wells Fargo customers, she said the bank betrayed them and that “there is no place for this kind of outrageous behavior in America.”
She said that as president she would work to stamp it out by bolstering the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which investigated the Wells Fargo case, and by pushing for legislation that would rescind compensation from Wall Street executives who break the law.
Republicans, including Mr. Toomey, want to dismantle the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, created in 2010 to protect against unscrupulous banking practices.
Mr. Toomey wants it to be governed by a board rather than an individual director — currently Richard Cordray. He also wants to make it more accountable by funding it through a congressional appropriation and wants to restrict it from routinely investigating banks with less than $50 billion worth of assets. The current threshold is $10 billion.
Ms. Warren, who was instrumental in creating the agency, said the Wells Fargo scandal helps justify its existence.
“Wells Fargo may wish the CFPB would disappear, and some Republicans may keep trying to leash up this watchdog, but that’s not going to happen,” she said.
Democrat Katie McGinty, who is running against Mr. Toomey, said the senator’s “phony outrage over Wells Fargo is hollow and shameful” after his attempts to dismantle the CFPB. “If he had his way, Wells Fargo would likely still be scamming its own customers.”
Toomey spokesman Ted Kwong defended his boss, saying he “wants strong tools to vigorously fight fraud, and has led the fight to ensure Wall Street is accountable for its own actions.”
Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com, 703-996-9292 or @pgPoliTweets.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.