In a new analysis of the financial health and transparency of large charities, the Pittsburgh region dropped to 27th out of 30 metro areas in the U.S., down from 10th highest last year.

The report from watchdog agency Charity Navigator said while Pittsburgh’s largest nonprofits had more assets and generated higher contributions than the national median, they also had higher total expenses and liabilities.

Despite its sharp decline in the rankings, Pittsburgh’s overall financial score was 86.82 out of a possible 100 points compared with the national median score of 87.64.

Sandra Miniutti, spokeswoman for Glen Rock, N.J.-based Charity Navigator, said some changes in how the agency computed the scores could have impacted Pittsburgh’s ranking. Among those were that Charity Navigator used three-year averages for some metrics instead of year-to-year comparisons.

Advertise with us

(Click image for larger version)

“We’re still talking about the typical charity in Pittsburgh having earned a high three-star rating [out of a maximum four stars],” Ms. Miniutti said in an email.

For the second straight year, Houston, Texas, topped the list as having the most financially healthy and transparent nonprofits. Rounding out the top five were St. Louis, Tampa-St. Petersburg, Dallas, and San Diego.

In Pittsburgh, the study examined 66 charities with median assets of $12.3 million, compared with the national median asset value of $6 million. The median revenue among the Pittsburgh nonprofits was $5.4 million, compared with median revenue of $3.8 million nationwide.

But program expenses among Pittsburgh charities accounted for 83.5 percent of their budgets compared with 81.5 percent nationwide. Administrative expenses were 10.3 percent of the median budget of Pittsburgh nonprofits compared with 9.3 nationwide.

Advertise with us

Chief executives at Pittsburgh charities earned slightly less than their counterparts nationwide. The median compensation here for top charity officials was $125,242, compared with the national median of $126,450.

Of the 66 charities in the Pittsburgh area that Charity Navigator included in its analysis, 20 earned four-star ratings. Among those is United Way of Southwestern Pennsylvania, which on Wednesday held its annual Women’s Leadership Council breakfast at the Wyndham Grand Pittsburgh Downtown.

The council includes approximately 2,000 women who pledge a minimum $1,000 annually and who together this past year raised just over $9 million or about 25 percent of a total $35 million raised by United Way in its last campaign. The council’s United for Women initiative provides funds to assist women who find themselves facing unexpected financial hardship.

The keynote speaker at the event was Heather Abbott, a survivor of the bombings at the 2013 Boston Marathon who runs a foundation to raise money for individuals who need prosthetic limbs.

Joyce Gannon: jgannon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1580.