Here’s a cautionary tale for investors who don’t appreciate the difference between holding a stock in street name and being a registered shareholder by physically holding a stock certificate.
Jeffrey Slemrod, a 70-year-old do-it-yourself investor from Bucks County, bought shares of Swissvale specialty glass maker Kopp Glass [ticker: KOGL] more than two years ago through Fidelity Investments, which holds his shares in street name. That means Fidelity, not Kopp Glass, has a record of how many shares he owns.
Mr. Slemrod said he purchased more than 4,300 shares — more than a 1 percent stake in Kopp — on the basis of a 2014 analysis of the company in Odd Ball Stocks Newsletter, written by Nate Tobik of Ross.
Kopp is so small and its shares so thinly held that the company is not required to file financial statements with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. That’s where studious investors like Mr. Slemrod often turn for financial information about the companies they own.
With that source eliminated, Mr. Slemrod called Kopp last year and asked for a copy of the company’s financial statements. After showing his brokerage statement as proof he was a shareholder, Kopp sent him the statements as well as a glass keepsake the company sends out to registered shareholders along with its annual report.
That episode left Mr. Slemrod with the impression that Kopp would automatically treat him like a registered shareholder every year. When he didn’t receive the statements this spring, Mr. Slemrod spoke with president and CEO Grant Wirth. He didn’t like what he heard.
Mr. Wirth told him that Pennsylvania law requires Kopp to send financial statements only to shareholders of record, another term for registered shareholders who physically possess a stock certificate. Based on that, Mr. Wirth denied Mr. Slemrod’s request.
“I didn’t understand the basis for his position since I was a documented shareholder,” Mr. Slemrod said. “I said to him: ‘In the amount of time we’re talking about this, you could have mailed it to me.’ ”
Mr. Wirth agreed that it wouldn’t take much to send Mr. Slemrod what he wants. But Kopp has no information about who owns shares in street name and how many shares they own, and the company doesn’t want to get in the business of providing financial statements to anyone who calls, identifies themselves as a shareholder, and asks for the information, Mr. Wirth said.
“We’ve gotten advice from our legal counsel, who said this is what we’re supposed to do: send it to the registered owners,” he said.
Kopp’s attorney, Patricia Farrell of Meyer, Unkovic & Scott, Downtown, said Mr. Slemrod’s problem isn’t with Kopp. It’s with Fidelity, who should provide him the company’s financial statements on request. She said another solution is to not hold the shares in street name.
“Just make yourself a shareholder of record and this all goes away,” Ms. Farrell said.
That doesn’t satisfy Mr. Slemrod, who said he called Fidelity and was told they never received statements from Kopp.
“I never really experienced this before,” said Mr. Slemrod, who added that he has owned stocks for 40 years. “Every shareholder in the company should have the same treatment.”
Mr. Tobik, the Ross stock newsletter author, shares Mr. Slemrod’s gripe about not getting Kopp’s financial statements. But he has no beef about Mr. Wirth’s performance.
“As an operational leader, he seems to do a very good job,” Mr. Tobik said.
The SEC cautions investors that there are advantages and disadvantages to holding a stock certificate compared with owning shares in street name. The most obvious is who is responsible for safeguarding records that prove ownership. But street name and registered shareholders are treated differently when it comes to buying and selling, as well as in terms of what information they will automatically receive from a company.
If you invest in thinly traded companies that don’t report to the SEC, and if you — unlike many investors — meticulously analyze financial reports, the difference between being a registered shareholder and owning stock in street name is a big deal. As Mr. Slemrod has discovered.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.