2016 Nissan Sentra 1.8 SR CVT Vs. 2016 Chevrolet Cruze Premier: Small sedan comparison.

This week: Chevrolet Cruze

Price: $28,640 as tested. The base price for the Premier is $23,120, and a Cruze can be had for as little as $16,120, theoretically even more tantalizing than last week’s Sentra. The RS package dressed up the outside for $995, the Enhanced Convenience Package was $865, and the Driver Confidence II Package $790. (More on options in below.)

Marketer’s pitch: “Introducing the all-new Chevy Cruze” (smiley face with hearts for eyes).

Advertise with us

Conventional wisdom: Are you going to disappoint us with a small car again, Chevy?

Reality: It’s better than it was, but it’s not as hip as that slogan.

What’s new: The Chevrolet Cruze gets a redesign for 2016, and copies its good looks from big brother Malibu and Uncle Impala.

Up to speed: The 1.4-liter turbocharged engine creates 153 horsepower, 23 more than the Sentra. It lacked a peppy feel from standing starts, but more motivation kicked in soon enough and acceleration felt fairly brisk overall. Still, it was first class compared to the Sentra.

On the road: The Cruze handling left me a little puzzled during testing. At first, the steering seemed loose and unresponsive. At low speeds, it’s an old Corolla. And it fares no better on the hard, winding old roads of Chester County.

Advertise with us

But I had a chance to do some lively driving on winding highways and found that the Cruze could even seem a little — gasp! — fun. So it actually fits into the usual Chevrolet mold — good for highway cruising, but otherwise, kind of dull.

Shifty: Speaking of “kind of dull,” the standard General Motors transmission with Drive and Low, with a plus-minus button — that’s not enough for this size vehicle. Full-on shiftable automatic would make the Cruzing that much better.

A manual transmission is available pretty much across the board, until the highest trim levels.

And somewhere in the transmission (or engine) lay a shudder in the test Cruze that was just an occasional annoyance. It mostly seemed to occur when the engine was cold or when the fuel was on the low side.

Driver’s Seat: The leather seats were slightly on the firm side, but nothing like the hard seats in the Sentra.

Advertise with us

Friends and stuff: Comparing the Cruze and the Sentra interiors, the Cruze wins, heads, legs and feet down. Plenty more space for bodies. And trunk space is 14.8 cubic feet, slightly less than the Sentra.

A nice-sized console holds a couple CDs or similar objects, and a tray in front of the gearshift holds phones and whatnot.

Rear seat heaters came on this model — pretty upscale for a Cruze.

Play some tunes: After just a bit of fine tuning, I found the Bose premium nine-speaker Cruze stereo to be one of the best I’ve heard in ages. Yes, I’m as surprised typing it as you are reading it, but it really brought out parts of songs that I only hear with earbuds. (It was part of the $1,995 Sun and Sound with Navigation Package, which also added sunroof, 8-inch touchscreen, navigation, and more.)

The Sentra had Bose with only eight speakers, so that ninth speaker must really be the bomb.

Advertise with us

Knobs control volume and tuning, and then a standard Chevrolet stereo touchscreen handles the rest. User friendly.

Night shift: The overhead interior lights were shiny and scattered, interfering with the already-dim headlights.

Fuel economy: I averaged a disappointing 29 mpg in the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat highway and suburban testing. This was far less than the Sentra.

Mr. Driver’s Seat’s mileage is generally improved by anything shiftable, so a manual might also clear this problem up.

Where it’s built: Lordstown, Ohio.

Advertise with us

How it’s built: The Cruze gets a fair reliability rating from Consumer Reports. It’s gotten good and poor ratings in previous years. Lordstown brought us the Vega, Monza, and Cavalier, so the history is not strong.

In the end: For people whose knee-jerk reaction has been “Japan good, America bad,” the Cruze-Sentra challenge should put that to rest.

In fact, the Cruze test should also dispel a long-held notion that General Motors isn’t really trying to driver-worthy small cars. This is a giant leap over the previous incarnation.

Still, I’d like to see the Cruze reliability a little higher. Maybe see how next year’s model stacks up, or look into some competitors.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.