2016 Nissan Sentra 1.8 SR CVT Vs. 2016 Chevrolet Cruze Premier: Small sedan shoot-out.

This week: Nissan Sentra

Price: $25,245 as tested. (The SR started at $20,410, and added $1,230 for the technology package and $2,590 for Premium Package. A base S with six-speed manual starts at a tantalizingly low $16,780.)

Marketer’s pitch: “Your upgrade awaits.”

Advertise with us

Conventional wisdom: “Oh? You’re upgrading me from this Sentra to what kind of car?”

Reality: I’d hate to see a downgrade.

Compact mashup: I put the Sentra and the Cruze side by side to see how the old Japanese-versus-American competition stacks up these days, about 40 years after the Pacific nation first began cleaning our automotive clocks.

A long trip: I’d been lucky enough to schedule a 100-mile trip to the Poconos to see Mama Driver’s Seat for my initial day in the Sentra.

Upon first embarking on our journey, Sturgis Kid 4.0 had pronounced the Sentra too small, since rear headroom and legroom were snug. But it’s a small car, I said; it’s not so bad.

Advertise with us

Then Mrs. Passenger Seat and Sturgis Kid 1.0 agreed that the seats were hard.

Maybe “lucky” isn’t the right adjective to describe this trip after all.

What’s new: The Sentra sedan fits in Nissan’s second row up, between the economical Versa and the compact Altima.

It gets a restyling inside and out featuring the latest Nissan design touches, and the Sentra looks like nothing if not — a Chevrolet Cruze.

Up to speed: Nissan’s continuously variable transmissions have been improving quite a bit, especially in the high-end Maxima.

Advertise with us

But down here in Sentraville, the CVT seems designed to encourage owners to upgrade to the Maxima as quickly as their bank accounts will allow.

Tied to 130 horses from the four-cylinder engine, this meant no hope of pulling out with any dignity. Either the 1.8-liter engine revved far too high, or the start was just far too slow.

On the hills: Granted, I had this car loaded up with four grown occupants, which is more than the typical Sentra would ever see. Still, consider its highway hill-climbing performance before purchase, as this stood out among small cars for me, even compared to some disappointing older Kia models.

No shiftability was offered in the Sentra, and unfortunately only the basic S level trim gets a six-speed manual gearbox. The shifting would probably make the Sentra a great deal more pleasant, but a depressing lack of options might counterbalance that.

On the road: The handling felt more competent than my experience in the larger, more expensive Altima, which I found a bit quirky and unpredictable. I’d compare this to the Honda Civic for winding-road performance.

Advertise with us

Information, please: The speedometer and tachometer deliver results clearly. Fuel economy and trip information is in between, and simple as well.

Play some tunes: A basic radio offered a small touch screen, and then several external buttons controlled the source and some other functions. Getting around and adjusting sound seemed reasonable enough.

Sound quality was about an A- from the Bose Premium eight-speaker audio system, good enough but missing that last level of low-end clarity for the top grade. (This was part of the $2,590 Premium Package, which also added navigation, 5.8 inch display, leather seats, power driver’s seat and more.)

Friends and stuff: As previously mentioned, Sturgis Kid 4.0, the tallest of the bunch, found the rear seat to lack head room and legroom, and the space under the front seat for feet could be dicey. Still, this is a small car, so anything beyond awfully cramped should be considered victory.

And the aforementioned hard seats seem to be a common complaint in small cars with leather seats. Try the cloth.

Advertise with us

The Sentra offers adequate storage. A console box could hold half a dozen CDs, and a tray in front of the gear selector holds a phone, but not really two.

Trunk space totals a healthy 15.1 cubic feet.

Night shift: Low beams were a little short in the way they cast light. The interior map lights cast a glow that seemed far above the Sentra price range.

Fuel economy: The Sentra gave a highly respectable 32.3 miles per gallon over its trips, featuring a mix of highways and country and suburban roads.

Where it’s built: Aguascalientes, Mexico

Advertise with us

How it’s built: The Nissan Sentra gets a poor reliability rating from Consumer Reports, much worse than average. Oops.

Next week: 2016 Chevrolet Cruze.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.