2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS Coupe vs. 2016 Ford Mustang GT Coupe Premium: Midsummer muscle show.

Prices: The Mustang came to $43,865 as tested, while the Camaro totaled $47,590.

Marketer’s pitches: The Camaro is “Reengineered. Redesigned. Rewarded.” The Mustang is “Four engines. One soul.”

Conventional wisdoms (wisda? Or since it’s from Mr. Driver’s Seat, wisduh?): Of the 2012 models, I called myself “less than thrilled with the new Camaro. It looks like a modern Hot Wheels car. It's too long, too wide, too low and the tires are too big. Ford, though, drew a winner when it made the 2012 Mustang. This takes the original design — which was a beauty — and pays beautiful homage.”

Advertise with us

Reality: New looks, new rides.

Side by side: Over the years I’ve done all kinds of comparisons, but this is the first time I’ve been able to run with the big boys like Car and Driver magazine and compare muscle cars side by side. For one glorious week, a Mustang and a Camaro faced off in front of Chez Sturgis.

And, as if in honor of the political conventions, one car came in ruby red and the other in hyper metallic blue.

This week we'll hop inside both, and next week we’ll put them to a test — side by side.

Outside: Both cars look the part, paying homage to the original 1965 Mustang and 1967 Camaro pony cars. Chevrolet has managed to morph the square shape of the ‘60s models with the sleek fastback of the ‘70s — the look grows up a bit from the Hot Wheels design of the previous generation — while Ford aims for the same era. Both scream “speed.”

Advertise with us

What’s new: The Camaro brings more than just a fresh face to the 2016 model year. Chevrolet says the body has lightened by 223 to 390 pounds, better handling and faster acceleration — the SS reaching 60 mph in 4 seconds.

The Mustang had a redesign for the 2015 model year, and only gets a few new touches for 2016, while its 0-60 takes another 0.6 seconds.

Driver’s Seat: The Mustang interior harkens more strongly to the past; the Camaro’s has gotten cleaned up from the last incarnation.

Both are black plastic/vinyl, but the Mustang had a carbon fiber-like trim accenting three round center dashboard vents. Heater controls seemed to roll on the side of a cylinder — push up toward the red for warmer and down toward blue for cooler — and the rest of the controls are tucked inside that cylinder as well.

The Camaro, on the other hand, has a large unbroken swath of black leather-covered plastic from the gauge pod all the way across to the door. Roughly 15 heater buttons were tucked inside a long stretch so cleverly I almost didn’t notice them at first.

Advertise with us

Keeping cool: The Camaro’s temperature controls are built into the round vents — a nice touch. But the center vents sit low, making cooling on hot summer days difficult. The Mustang’s three round center vents are augmented by rectangular outboard vents, and cooling seemed an easier process.

Play some tunes: The Mustang stereo also nods to the past, with volume and tuning knobs trimmed in silver that add to the car’s classic interior.

The Camaro looks like many other General Motors cars in this regard — one volume knob and a couple buttons under a large touchscreen. The stereo functions well, though. Unfortunately, the screen is angled a bit downward.

Friends and stuff: Nobody in the back seats of either of these cars is going to be happy. Sturgis Kid 4.0 has made that clear — the last time we tested these, he was just 11.

This time, the tallest of the Sturgis family members was unhappy even sitting in the front and trying to make extra room for Mrs. Passenger Seat in back.

Advertise with us

But while the Mustang rear seat is ridiculously small, the Camaro is soooo not even funny. I had to turn my feet sideways to slide them in the footwell, and the front seat was set for 5-foot-10-inch little, old me. After that, I felt entrapped.

I joked that the rear seats are designed with today's teen in mind — keep your head bent forward staring at a phone or other device, but even that doesn't yield full comfort. After trying them out myself, I apologized for being a terrible father.

The trunks looked remarkably big, but the Camaro only holds a tiny 9.10 cubic feet, while the Mustang offers 50 percent more — a grand 13.5.

Next week: Enough messing around — let’s take a ride!

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.