2016 Alfa Romeo 4C Spider: Spinning a web of fines and court costs.

Price: $74,295 as tested. The base price is $63,900, and the test vehicle added $2,200 for Spider Track Package, which put a lot of lightweight carbon fiber in spots; more options discussed throughout.

Marketer’s pitch: “Exhilaration exposed.”

Conventional wisdom: Car and Driver says, “The 4C practically anticipates road challenges, but the seats are tight, there's almost no luggage room, and it's so low it's tough to get out of …”

Advertise with us

Reality: “Well, hello, officer.”

“73 in a 55 zone”: My days (and late nights) testing premium sedans and exotic sports cars have finally caught up with me. Nabbed on a Philadelphia-area exurban expressway by The Man.

My thought while waiting for the trooper to ask for my license, insurance, and registration? “Ohmygod, ohmygod, ohmygod, this thing doesn’t have a glovebox; I have no idea where the paperwork could be.”

After handing him my license and explaining who I was (without saying indignantly, “Do you know who I am?” or I’d certainly be writing this from the cell), the trooper broke out in a big smile, told me my speed, and said I’d showed “some restraint, considering the car.” He let me off with a warning.

(And he was right; that was the restrained portion of my testing.)

Advertise with us

Race ready: Really, though, what else is the 4C Spider good for? This tiny two-seater faux convertible is missing most of the elements of a modern car, but it’s still among one of the most fun little machines you can buy.

Up to speed: The 237-horsepower 1.75-liter engine rockets the 2,487-pound Spider. Hit 60 mph in 4.2 seconds, according to Car and Driver. Hit 100 in 11.1.

On the curves: There’s almost no need to slow down for twists and turns, except that it’s really fun to floor the accelerator coming out of them.

In the driveway: The Spider lacks even the most basic of accoutrements, so any power assist to the steering mechanism is verboten. Parking this little car is misery, for both shoulders and arms, unless you remember to ease the car a little forward (or reverse) as you turn.

Spider’s-eye view: The tiny rear window and large B pillars make looking backward and changing lanes challenging. No backup camera came on the test model, though a beepy radar tried — and failed — to make things easier.

Advertise with us

And from down here next to the road, even normal-sized cars appear huge. I remember on one trip wondering what kind of super-tall SUV I was approaching, and it turned out to be a Subaru Outback.

Shifty: Alfa follows the Italian exotic car approach to shifting: Four buttons sit in a diamond pattern in the console. A 1 button is for forward, an R button for reverse, an N button for neutral, and an A/M button to switch between automatic and manual shifting mode.

Shifting is done via paddle levers. The car comes with Dynamic, Natural and All-Weather modes. In all but the last, downshifting was especially abrupt.

I’d still rather have a clutch. Or at least a shift lever.

On the road: Expect to become well acquainted with all the fissures and cracks in the road surface. The tires tend to wander into seams running parallel to the lines and grooves. Tall seams between some sections of concrete that in other cars are annoying become teeth rattling in the Spider.

Advertise with us

Then again, I could lay rubber from the rear wheels shifting into fourth gear (and spin the 18- and 19-inch five-hole wheels, $2,500).

Friends and stuff: One friend. One carry-on behind each seat, as long as neither of you is very tall. One cupholder for normal coffee cups, and one so short that you should expect to be riding in the splash zone.

Behind the engine, there’s room for a picnic basket and the stowaway removable soft top. Really, that’s all.

It takes some practice to remove the soft top. Two levers on either side hook in the four corners, and two twist-off screws secure it over the visor.

Play some tunes: Or don’t. The Alpine stereo certainly looks like it’s from the 1980s. And while it offered my USB and CD as a choice, I never did find the appropriate slots in the vehicle during the scant three days I had it.

Advertise with us

The sound quality was terrible, despite the $1,800 Preferred Customer Package featuring premium speakers (plus cruise control, parking assist, and alarm), and the antenna had only about 25 miles of range for AM.

Fuel economy: I averaged 24 miles per gallon in three days of truly ticket-worthy driving. This Spider drinks only premium.

Where it’s built: Modena, Italy

How it’s built: Consumer Reports hasn’t tested this one but I’m going to hold the Monroney to my forehead a la Johnny Carson. Carnac say, if you can’t afford a lot of repairs, don’t buy it.

In the end: For this kind of money, I’ve had much more refined fun in the Corvette, and for a bit more cash there’s the Jaguar F Type, which is the epitome of refinement, style, and racing.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.