Like most of the motoring public, I’ve been watching the Takata airbag recall unfolding slowly over the past several months. It crept into my world when the 2008 Toyota Matrix airbag was recalled.
As the owner of a 2008 Pontiac Vibe — a twin of the Matrix — I was appalled at how long it took for the Vibe to then be included in the first 28.8 millions vehicles.
But when the big expansion came down last month, the recall added another 35 to 40 million vehicles, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, and the Sturgis Family Sienna was now included in the mix.
Two out of three is bad: That makes two-thirds of Sturgis vehicles subject to the recall.
As Sturgis Kids 1.0 through 4.0 might abbreviate, SMH (shaking my head).
But just how afraid should we be? Ruptures of the Takata inflators have been tied to 10 deaths and more than 100 injuries in the United States.
On one hand, Bloomberg recently titled an overview called “60 million car bombs.” On the other, NHTSA has allowed companies that still have airbags in stock to install them into new cars.
What goes wrong: The problem inflators are filled with ammonium nitrate, a highly volatile explosive.
The trouble develops over time, as high temperatures and humidity cause the material to break down. So the airbag may deploy at great force, and this may happen in a collision where an airbag would not even be needed.
Takata added a desiccant to more recent airbags, which in theory reduces the volatility and should prevent this type of problem.
Still being installed: Would you buy a car if you knew it was going to be recalled? That’s just what buyers of certain Mitsubishi, FiatChrysler, Volkswagen and Toyota models may be facing.
The recall of the last 35 to 40 million vehicles will not begin until 2018; otherwise the manufacturers would have to stop selling vehicles with the defective part right now.
I found this galling, as did Clarence Ditlow, director of the Center for Auto Safety consumer group in Washington, D.C.
“What NHTSA has done is enable to manufacturers to use up their stock of defective inflators,” Mr. Ditlow said.
Perhaps this adds a new term to the lexicon: the precall. The car buyers can purchase knowing they’ll be back at the dealer for a free repair soon. Only the 2016 Volkswagen CC, 2016 and 2017 Mitsubishi I-Miev, and 2016 Audi TT and 2017 Audi R8 were named by the automakers as potentially having the defective parts.
Get in line: But now the rest of us and our vehicles are part of what NHTSA has dubbed “priority groups” — as the agency, Takata, and the automakers try to flesh out who among us is most likely to have one of these explode in our faces, and thus prevent those from happening first.
The five recall phases are based on prioritization of risk, determined by the age of the inflators and exposure to high humidity and fluctuating high temperatures that accelerate the degradation of the chemical propellant, NHTSA said.
I asked a Department of Transportation representative just what he’d say to someone in my position, someone who’d watched this recall unfold slowly and swallow two of our vehicles.
He took some umbrage at my suggestion that it was a slow recall.
“Let’s start with the fact that before last month this was already the largest and most complex auto recall in history and last month we doubled it,” Bryan Thomas, communications director for NHTSA, said.
Mr. Thomas cited the record number of vehicles manufactured last year, and the fact that like all automotive parts, airbags are not interchangeable between the wide variety of models and styles of vehicle available.
The real risk: People who face the annoyance of buying new cars with bad airbags, or who have the recall notice posted on their refrigerator like Mr. Driver’s Seat, are not really at tremendous risk for trouble.
It takes time for these airbags to become unstable. The latest model vehicle to record an injury in the United States was made in 2007, Mr. Thomas said. And cars here in the Northeast don’t face the constant, wearying humidity of, say, the Gulf Coast.
The real risk is for the poor. People who are spending much of their money buying well-used cars that don’t have the recall repair work performed face the greatest potential for trouble.
“Used vehicles can be sold with open safety recalls,” Mr. Thomas said. “People need to know that they need to check their VIN and take seriously notices they do get in the mail.”
He encouraged everyone to check their VIN on safercar.gov regularly for new recalls.
“One of the problems that we’re seeing right now is that there are far, far too many vehicles that have gotten five, six, seven recall notices” for one repair that’s never been performed, he said. People should understand that the recall repair will be performed by the dealer for absolutely no cost.
What can you do? I wondered if we might not all be better off having the problem Takata airbags disconnected until proper units might be installed.
As expected, NHTSA’s Mr. Thomas said no. But CAS’s Mr. Ditlow said no, as well.
“In the case of these inflators, if you look at the statistics, it’s more than 100 to 1 that it’s going to deploy properly,” Mr. Ditlow said. “That means it’s going to save your life or reduce serious injuries.”
And that, for me, settled it. No, this should never have happened. Yes, Takata made some mistakes. But 60 million car bombs?
That’s kind of explosive.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.