2016 Nissan Altima SR vs. 2017 Hyundai Elantra Limited: Sedan test mashup.
This week: Hyundai Elantra
Price: $27,710 as tested. The Ultimate Package offers a bevy of safety technologies for $1,900. More on other packages later. (The base price for the Limited trim level was $22,350, and the base price for an Elantra is $16,620.)
Marketer’s pitch: “Style that raises the bar.”
Conventional wisdom: When I drove a 2013 Elantra GT, I reported “the sport mode changed the GT’s handling from lackluster to adequate … and power from the 1.8-liter four-cylinder is merely in the ‘OK’ category.”
Reality: Consider the bar raised.
What’s new: Everything for 2017.
The Elantra was the last of the Mohicans, one of the few Hyundais and Kias left that didn’t get the full revamp treatment. The last time I drove it I found it mundane and boring.
In pitting it against the Altima (see last week for that review), I looked at two sedans whose prices almost matched — a beefed-up Elantra and a stripped-down Altima.
Up to speed: The 147-horsepower 2.0-liter four is the same size engine as found in Mrs. Passenger Seat’s Kia Soul, but the Kia puts out 17 more horsepower.
Shifty: Where the Elantra has it all over the Altima, though, is in the gearbox. Hyundai stays with the six-speed automatic — and even offers a manual version as well.
The automatic in the tester functioned without calling attention to itself. But it does seem to have long gear changes and that can make climbing hills and passing difficult, much like the aforementioned Kia Soul.
The gearbox also doesn’t override shifting much in manual mode, giving drivers more control. The shifter feel is also a lot like the Sonata’s — Hyundais tend to be a little less fluid in the shifter motion, whereas Kias have a nice feel, along the lines of Mazdas.
On the road: Handling leaps forward noticeably. The new Elantra is not a Miata, but it’s competent and not at all boring. A sport mode seems only to bollox things up; it feels like the steering is on a coil spring, really loose on the easy moves and super taut on the tougher ones.
Driver’s Seat: The Sturgis derriere found the leather-covered seat comfortable and easy to conform to, although it had a touch more lumbar support than I prefer. The seats were definitely fancier than the Altima’s but both were plenty comfortable.
Keeping cool: Perhaps it’s the window placement, but the Elantra seemed to become toasty in a hurry, even in just a couple April days in the 70s. Buyers who run hot like Mr. Driver’s Seat would do well to add the cooled seats.
Friends and stuff: Six-foot-tall Sturgis Kid 4.0 found the back devoid of legroom and headroom both, and the seat Spartan and bench-like. Headroom in the rear is particularly impeded by the sedan’s wind cheating abilities. Victory, Altima.
The center spot sits up a little higher but is not rendered completely useless by the front console like many modern cars.
Play some tunes: A $2,500 Tech Package added an eight-inch touchscreen and Infinity premium audio with speakers. Dials monitor volume and tuning; buttons across the bottom handle other changes.
The touchscreen itself operated smoothly and without problems, even as the interior temperature seemed toasty.
Sound from the unit was an A-; no socks will be knocked off when listening to your favorite tunes.
Night shift: The view with the low beams was actually fairly challenging. The map lights could interfere with that outlook as well, although small lights under the visors could offer a better view. Still, I have better interior lighting in the Soul. A $250 light kit not included on the tester may help.
Watch those doors: Today’s swoopy sedans have pointy back doors, and the Elantra’s are probably the worst of these. Careful in parking lots, and with your hips.
Fuel economy: This is where the Elantra design, small engine and gearing pay off. I averaged 33.5 mpg in the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat array of highways, country roads and suburbs. I’m lucky to get 25 in our boxy Soul. The Elantra Eco, with a 1.4-liter engine and a seven-speed double-clutch automatic transmission, could be a real game changer.
Where it’s built: Montgomery, Alabama
How it’s built: Consumer Reports predicts the Elantra’s reliability to be good. Previous years have run from average to excellent.
In the end: Among these two, the Altima is definitely the choice for people who need room for full-size people in the back. But the fuel economy, driveability and reliability of the Elantra make it my favorite of the two.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.