2016 Nissan Altima 2.5 SR vs. 2017 Hyundai Elantra Limited: Sedan test mashup.

This week: Nissan Altima.

Price: $25,525 as tested, including $220 for carpeting floor and trunk mats. Nissan is priding itself on offering trim levels without options throughout its model lineup. More about what the SR has — and doesn’t have — below. (A barebones Altima can be had for $22,500.)

Conventional wisdom: Car and Driver magazine calls it “a capable sedan with a decent options list and a roomy, comfortable cabin.”

Advertise with us

Marketer’s pitch: “Altima: Ahead of the game.”

Reality: Nice to look at, but a mixed bag for drivers.

How they compare: Readers may wonder why an Elantra and an Altima are put nose to nose. Of course, the Altima sets its sights higher; it’s a larger car with a $6,000 premium on the starting price.

But I happened to get test cars that both fell in the mid-20s, and I thought I’d show what buyers might get from two front-wheel-drive sedans for roughly the same money.

What’s new: Nissan has come up with some fairly impressive new sedans in the past couple seasons. The big-boy Maxima provides a smooth ride, nice handling and great acceleration, with plenty of room for passengers.

Advertise with us

The slightly smaller Altima also gets “an extensive mid-cycle makeover” for the 2016 model year, including the introduction of the SR trim level tested.

On the road: I’ve often found myself turning to the auto writer standby, that a car “goes where it’s pointed.” It’s a phrase I recall in Car and Driver and Autoweek dating back to the 1980s, and I’ve used it for vehicles like the Chevy Impala or Subaru Impreza. There’s not a lot of fun in the handling, but they’re competent.

Sometimes I ask myself the question, “Well, duh, Sturgis? Where else would it go?”

The Altima answers that question. In the Altima I found myself cutting intersections too short or too wide, and its handling on highway curves could be especially unpredictable. It’s not a collision waiting to happen, just a quirky car that requires more slowing down than I usually need to do.

Up to speed: It’s too bad, because the Altima has much to recommend it.

Advertise with us

For one, the acceleration. The 2.5-liter four gives out 182 horsepower, but it seems like more.

Shiftless: And this comes despite Nissan’s love affair with CVTs, the gearless automatics that often infuse unsuspecting vehicles with all the motoring luster of a golf cart. But the Altima’s performs admirably.

Inside: The interior is handsome and comfortable, even though the model offered was not the pinnacle of Nissan class. Nissan is known to offer interiors that feel more expensive than they are.

Friends and stuff: I confess we didn’t put the Altima through a complete series of family tests, because naturally the Altima wins hands down. Its legroom measurements are 45 inches in the front and 36 in the back, while the Elantra 42.2 and 35.5 inches respectively.

Play some tunes: Expect some stripped-down interior components in this price range. The barebones stereo in the test model offered adequate sound, probably a B+ for clarity with a little too much treble.

Advertise with us

But a five-inch color display without a map function or Sirius XM seems straight out of 2011.

Staying warm — and cool: Fancy electronic heater controls that set a precise temperature? Not in the SR. Here we have a fan knob and a temperature knob, with blue tint on one side and red on the other.

And I found the controls simple to operate and not fussy like many of the electronic heater controls.

Fuel economy: Not bad at all. I recorded 30 mpg in a wide variety of highway and suburban driving. But wait until we check the Elantra’s computer next week.

Night shift: The headlights can be a touch inadequate. The overhead lights provide a subtle glow without interfering with the view of the road.

Advertise with us

Where it’s built: Smyrna, Tenn., and Canton, Miss.

How it’s built: Consumer Reports calls the Altima reliability fair, and that its repair rate is 37 percent worse than average.

In the end: If Nissan is really committed to offering a sporty SR, it should commit to a manual or shiftable automatic transmission.

Next week: 2017 Hyundai Elantra Limited.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.