2016 Nissan Rogue SL AWD vs. 2017 Kia Sportage SX: Battle of the off-brand small crossovers.
This week: Kia Sportage
Price: $33,395 as tested, with no options on the test vehicle. A base Sportage starts at $22,290 with a lot less to offer, I’m certain.
Marketer’s pitch: “Built for life’s adventures.”
Conventional wisdom: On reviewing the 2013 Sportage, three-years-ago Mr. Driver’s Seat reported: “Whatever it costs, buy the rear camera. This cute, swooptastic design with the tiny rear window makes seeing while backing up almost impossible. You’ll even wish it had a passing camera thanks to the giant rear pillars on either side.”
Reality: It’s getting harder to improve Kias.
Big league Sportage: The previous generation of the Kia Sportage was a pleasant enough vehicle, and one of my favorite small crossovers.
For 2017, Kia has taken that vehicle and given it a new look and several upgrades, including a stiffer structure, plus steering and technological improvements.
Handsome: Kia has turned to the Porsche Cayenne for styling cues. The high-up headlights and angular body will divide onlookers more drastically than the old look.
Better view: The real down side to the previous Sportage was the tiny rear window and high beltline on the rear-door windows. Changing lanes became a difficult prospect.
The redesign has made the Sportage far easier for getting a look at the road.
Inside: The leather seats came heated and cooled standard on the SX, and the dashboard was clean without feeling Spartan.
Driver’s Seat: The Sportage seat was quite comfortable, and allowed far more adjustment up and down than the Rogue. Kia’s gauges are clear and easy to read.
Up to speed: The 2.0-liter turbo engine creates 240 horsepower and really motivates the SUV far faster than the Rogue’s powerplant. Unfortunately, the power needs to be harnessed a bit better. The 2017 Sportage has all full-throttle handling of an old Econoline van.
Still, I never suspected I was driving a turbo, because there’s no lag. Years ago I found the standard 2.4-liter, 180-horsepower four to be a little sluggish, so take it on some real hills before buying.
On the road: Country roads in the Sportage are slightly more fun than in the Rogue. Strangely, the Rogue handled like the Kia Soul, while the Sportage offers better country road twisting and turning.
Shifty: The Sportage wins the gear-changing category hands down, because the Rogue forfeits. Kia’s six-speed automatic offers good shift capability and picks the right gears without intruding on the drive. The gearshift didn’t have great feel, but paddles allow shifting at the driver’s fingertips.
Compare that to the CVT Rogue, which offers no gears and doesn’t even pretend to.
Friends and stuff: The rear seat is comfortable and offers plenty of room for legs and heads. Where the Rogue rear seat sat up very high and the front passenger seat very low, the Sportage is more evenly arranged.
Play some tunes: The Harman Kardon Speakers standard on the LX model bumped the upgraded Kia stereo sound almost to an A. The sound is clear and rich, but doesn’t hold up at lower volumes.
Kia offers one of the best touchscreens available, a big 8-inch screen with easy-to-follow functions. Buttons across the bottom change the source and dials control the volume and tuning.
This is far better than the basic Rogue stereo in that test vehicle, but that’s comparing apples and oranges.
Night shift: The interior lights look like a cross between big, overly bright plastic jobs and nice subtle upgraded Kia lights. Unfortunately, they shine like the former, and the LED headlights don’t offer a shine that competes with it.
Fuel economy: I averaged 26 mpg in the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat routes, plus a trip to the Poconos on similar roads.
Where it’s built: Gwangju, Korea
How it’s built: Consumer Reports predicts the Sportage will have good overall reliability, which matches the Rogue. Kia, though, still offers the 10 year/100,000-mile warranty that saved their bacon (and Kia owners’ as well) when they were still selling craptastic Sephias.
In the end: Kia has impressed me during the five years I’ve been covering automobiles by making all the right moves in upgrading its vehicles. The Sportage was such a high starting point, though, that this upgrade is not so clear. Still, it’s a nice vehicle and superior to the Rogue.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.