The 2016 Nissan Rogue SL AWD vs. 2017 Kia Sportage SX: Battle of the off-brand small crossovers.
This week: Nissan Rogue
Price: $33,175 as tested. $29,890 for a base SL. The SL premium package added $2,190 and panoramic sunroof, LED headlights, forward emergency braking and more.
Marketer’s pitch: “Accelerate your expectations!”
Conventional wisdom: A 2014 Rogue put through the Mr. Driver’s Seat Test Course a few years back left some distinct impressions. “This Nissan goes a little Rogue over bumpy roads” and “The acceleration from the 2.5-liter is only OK” among them. Now let’s see how the new model compares.
Reality: The Rogue seems much improved despite no major redesign.
What’s new: The Rogue received a complete redesign for 2014, and simply adds a few new features for the latest model year.
Up to speed: First off, Nissan must have tweaked the accelerator a bit. The 2.5-liter four-cylinder still provides 170 horsepower, but this time around I found that makes for a surprising amount of motivation for the 3,500-or-so-pound crossover. Pulling out from a standing start always seemed like a fun adventure.
But the CVT interfered with my ability to control adjusting my speed drastically. I found pulling out to pass or speeding from entrance ramps onto highway speeds left me wanting; I never knew how to position the accelerator, a complaint I had two years ago (and only discovered after this review was written).
On the road: The Rogue had handling like nothing if not The Mrs. Passenger Seat’s Kia Soul. It was pleasant and controlled, but not a great deal of fun. And either Pennsylvania’s roads are getting much better or the suspension seems more up to the task; I didn’t feel jostled during Rogue Week.
Shiftless: But where the Soul offers shift capabilities in both manual and automatic transmissions, the Rogue is having none of that. The standard CVT means not even pretending to offer the driver some shift control.
The Rogue CVT also leaves one with a golf-cart feel, and some “downshifts” on inclines could be random, especially when the weather turned colder.

Driver’s Seat: The power-controlled seat offered comfort, but height control was a bit limited. I could raise the seat about halfway up before it began to tilt forward slightly. This is better than many models, where up-down equals lift-chair arcing.
Still, I felt better off than shotgun passenger Sturgis Kid 4.0, who found the manual passenger seat sat way down on the floor, and there was no going up.
Tough controls: After driving the Rogue for nearly a week, I confess, Mr. Magoo-ver’s Seat finally discovered all the buttons near his left knee. That’s the usual location for couple nonsense switches like Eco switches and lights (the Sportage has three).
But the Rogue’s eight, count’ em, eight, buttons controlled important features like AWD, Sport mode, and sensor alarms.
Adding to the confusion, some buttons light up themselves while others activate lights on the dashboard. In any case, most manufacturers have moved beyond this idea, to the betterment of the world.
Friends and stuff: Rear-seat passengers will find plenty of legroom but not an especially pleasing amount of headroom from the tall Rogue. The rear seat sits up quite a ways from the front, and space between the seat cushion and the ceiling is compromised.
The smallish console holds a few prizes, but not terribly many.
An optional third row left the Sturgis Clan feeling stuffed into the Rogue two years ago, but none was made available this time around.
Play some tunes: On the bright side, the Rogue’s base-level stereo system offered great sound.

CAPTION HERE (Photog/Credit)
Yet the touchscreen makes me wonder if anyone from Nissan has ever driven the Rogue on a highway while really putting the system to the test. Selecting a specific song requires phenomenal aim. I managed to pick the wrong song several times before the Rogue and I came to an agreement.
The system offers dials for volume and tuning, though, and buttons outside the touchscreen for source.
Night shift: The interior lights offer far more nuance and subtlety than one might expect in this price range. The LED headlights shone brightly on the road ahead.
Fuel economy: I averaged 25 mpg in the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat round of testing.
Where it’s built: Smyrna, Tenn.
How it’s built: Consumer Reports predicts good reliability for the Rogue.
Next week: The all-new 2017 Kia Sportage SX.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com. ..





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.