2016 GMC Sierra Denali 1500 4WD Crew Cab vs. 2016 Nissan Titan: Big trucks go head to head.

This week: GMC Sierra Denali

Price: $60,765 as tested ($53,565 base price for the trim level. Power sunroof added $995, driver alert package $550, paint $395, polished aluminum wheels $300. More options outlined below.)

Marketer’s pitch: “We are professional grade.” (Nothing newer than that, huh, GMC?)

Advertise with us

Conventional wisdom: Car and Driver says “the biggest engine makes a big impression, smooth new transmission, sharp duds, ergonomically friendly controls,” while noting the “ride can be harsh on big wheels, fuel economy still not great.”

Reality: Not a bad truck, but with one big drawback.

What’s new: Some new grille and headlight looks and a new running board feature are the highlights of the Big Fella from the all-truck GMC brand.

On the road: On my introductory ride in the Sierra Denali, I found maneuverability to be a less than the F-150 — really the best in this category — and the runner-up Ram 1500. Specifically, the tires wobbled so much when cold that it almost felt like a rock was stuck inside a tread.

On country roads, the Sierra Denali lumbers a little bet less than the wavy Cadillac Escalade. But it can lose its composure over bumps, fishtailing a bit.

Advertise with us

Up to speed: The optional 6.2-liter V-8 ($2,495) really kicks up the dust. With 420 horsepower and 460 pound-feet of torque, getaways are made as quick as the other big boys offered by Ram and Ford.

Shifty: Large pickups only come with automatic transmission these days, a grave disappointment. The GMC’s is on the column, and features a manual setting below PRND, and a button changes gears from there.

The eight-speed automatic transmission worked smoothly throughout testing.

Driver’s Seat: It’s a comfy ride up here on Mount Denali. The leather seats are pretty, with plenty of support and softness, during a week of more than 600 miles of driving.

Sturgis Kid 4.0 and I definitely missed the massage seats from the F-150 after winding down a day of schlepping branches to the township compost site.

Advertise with us

Off-roading: I used four-wheel low for some of the yard work and found engaging the system could be clunky. Literally. The Nissan Titan was smooth and easy to operate.

In and out: The running board opens and closes automatically when the doors are opened, and almost make me feel a little guilty for forgetting something in the truck. The running boards ($995) also articulate via a foot switch and create a nice step for accessing the front corner of the bed.

Friends and stuff: Rear seats are comfortable for full-size individuals, although the seats sit straight up to accommodate the shorter cab. Seat bottoms fold up easily to make a nice storage compartment in the rear row.

Large storage bins are a must-have in any full-size pickups, and the Sierra Denali does not disappoint. Two narrow rows in front even give a standing zone for cell phones and tablets. A lay-flat charger is available on the armrest.

Play some tunes: General Motors offers Apple CarPlay and Android CarPlay throughout much of its lineup, and this makes accessing everything on a phone delightfully easy.

Advertise with us

The sound rates an A, providing a rich cascade of chords when playing quietly or cranked up to 11.

The system operates fairly smoothly, with volume and tuning knobs and a “Home” button making things easy.

Night shift: The Denali I tested had bright but subtle interior lights that didn’t interfere with the view of the road. The low beams could be a little on the dim side, but I only noticed that intermittently.

Fuel economy: This is where one pays for a big-hearted, fast truck. I averaged just under 18 mpg in a wide array of highway, country, suburban and city driving. Premium fuel is recommended. I filled it with regular and didn’t notice any decay in mileage or performance.

Where it’s built: Silao, Mexico.

Advertise with us

How it’s built: Consumer Reports gives the 2016 Sierra a reliability rating of “much worse than average.” This is far down from just two years ago, when it received better than average ratings.

In the end: Well, that last paragraph is kind of a dealbreaker. The new Titan was more fun anyway, offering a more authentic country feel. But buyers should check out the F-150 and Ram offerings.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer: mrdriversseat@gmail.com.