2016 Nissan Titan XD Pro-X 4WD vs. 2016 GMC Sierra Denali 1500 4WD: Big trucks go head to head.

This week: Nissan Titan.

Price: $57,830 as tested (The base MSRP is $50,970.)

Conventional wisdom: Car and Driver says it offers “smooth, quiet torque,” but suffers from “overwhelming flab and no ambition to be great.”

Advertise with us

Marketer’s pitch: “The every duty truck.”

Reality: A big boy with mostly good manners, though it belches audibly at the pump.

What’s new: The whole shebang. Nissan gave its fairly unpopular large pickup (Motor Trend called the previous generation “unrefined” and gave it a single star for 2015) a revamp for the 2016 model year.

Nissan says the Titan XD creates a whole new category of pickup, saying it combines “the capability of a heavy-duty hauler with the drivability and affordability of a light-duty pickup.”

Sincerest form of flattery: When the fleet company showed up with the Titan outside my door, I didn’t immediately go out to greet the driver. I assumed it was an F-150 that a second driver was using to pick up the Titan driver, who was still on his way. It looks that similar.

Advertise with us

On the road: But it was, in fact, the Nissan Titan at my doorstep. My first order of business was to deliver the fleet driver to Downingtown train station for his return trip. And it speaks volumes that though I still was getting started with my day, I could hop in the Titan and drive without feeling intimidated.

The big beast was at home on country roads. I could whiz through the old winding roads of southern and western Chester County horse country and fit right in.

The Titan was fine on highways, but the fat tires and tall overall height meant it felt tippy on highway curves. Tighter turns and parking are also shortcomings.

So its handling lands somewhere north of the Sierra but not quite as easy as the Dodge Ram. (Ford’s F-150 wins the handling competition.)

Under the hood: The big Cummins turbodiesel shows that Nissan means business. The engine creates 310 horsepower and a whopping 555 pound-feet of torque.

Advertise with us

But that’s not a lot of horsepower for a giant truck, so the Titan didn’t get moving as fast as one might think. The truck also could leave me in the lurch, as hesitation when pulling out and in most corners was fairly noticeable, especially before the diesel engine had warmed up.

Shifty: A steering column-mounted gear selection offers PRND, and a button allows shifting through 1 to 6.

Friends and stuff: The Titan offered plenty of room for passengers and their equipment.

The front seat accommodations were generous and comfortable. The seats were covered in stitched leather (part of the $3,310 Pro-4X Convenience Package, which also added heated seats all around, heated and power tilt and telescoping steering wheel, and more). The Pro-4X Luxury Package ventilated the front seats and offered Around View object detection for $1,510.

Rear seat passengers are afforded tons of leg room and head room.

Advertise with us

Truck stuff: I had the chance to fill the Titan with some old yard detritus on a Saturday afternoon. It had none of the toys of the Sierra, no movable running board — in fact, no running board at all! — and no special steps in the bumpers to make getting in and out much easier.

Play some tunes: The Titan stereo harkens back to the olden days of, say, 2012. Buttons down the side allow to choose what mode the stereo plays in or whether drivers are watching the map. The touchscreen controls the rest, but the display looks outdated and doesn’t offer a great deal of functionality.

Sound quality, though, is pretty good — A- with the Rockford Fosgate speakers, part of the $1,100 Utility and Audio Package, which also added front and rear sonar, power slide window with defrost, and some nifty bed tracks and lighting.

Night shift: The headlights cast a pleasant glow and never seemed slanted too low. The interior lights offer plenty of illumination without interfering with the view of the road.

Tough view: But that doesn’t mean looking out the windows was easy. The Titan’s main blind spot was in passing; nowhere I put my head made the view of the next lane clear. I could never get the passenger-side convex mirror to show what I needed to see.

Advertise with us

Fuel consumption: The word “economy” has no business in this review. The Monroney has a big notice that EPA numbers are not required for this vehicle, and Nissan is making the most of it. I fear what owners of the gasoline-fed 390-horsepower 5.6-liter V-8 will endure: I averaged 15 mpg in expensive diesel fuel.

Where it’s built: Canton, Mississippi.

Next week: GMC Sierra.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer: mrdriversseat@gmail.com.