2016 Toyota Tacoma TRD Sport 4x4 Double Cab: Midsize hauler?

Price: $38,290 as tested ($33,730 for base TRD Sport 4x4 Double Cab; the Tacoma starts at $23,330, for one row of seats and rear-wheel drive).

Marketer’s pitch: “Built for the endless weekend.”

Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com liked the “Refined V6 engine with available manual transmission; excellent off-road ability; responsive touchscreen interface; extensive list of options; peerless resale value” but not the “low driver seat with no height adjustment; steering wheel's minimal telescoping range; unimpressive V6 acceleration times.”

Advertise with us

Reality: Compromises — and noisiness — made me holler.

Spring is in the air: It’s April, the time when a middle-aged man’s fancy turns to thoughts of landscaping, and what better way to celebrate what we dig most by trying out some trucks. Don’t call it a full-on comparison, though — the Tacoma is much smaller than the new Nissan Titan, and after that will be the GMC Sierra.

What’s new: Quite a bit. Redone for 2016, the V-6 is new, as well as interior upgrades.

Tough looks: Both inside and out, the Tacoma exuded rugged manliness. The large hood scoop drew lots of attention, and the round heater vents and chiseled-looking dashboard touches gave the Tacoma a no-nonsense feel.

Driver’s Seat: The low-budget standard cloth seats would satisfy cheapskates like Mr. Driver’s Seat just fine. The adjustments were not aplenty, but comfort could be had, even on a four-hour drive across the Keystone state.

Advertise with us

Up to speed: The 3.5-liter V-6 really hauled the truck forward with great ease, thanks to the 278 horses the engine creates.

Shifty: I was glad I got to take the Tacoma outside my usual stomping grounds. The six-speed automatic handled flawlessly in my normal driving, but push hard on the gas and a large thump could be felt as the transmission selected the new gear.

I’d definitely like to try a manual version; those are hard to come by in trucks these days, sadly.

On the road: The tall, narrow, four-wheel-drive Tacoma handles brilliantly. It goes where it’s pointed without the floppy, foot-dragging feeling I got from a Tundra of a few years back.

But the ride remains bouncy at best. Highway travel across Pennsylvania in the Tacoma was a bumpy affair.

Advertise with us

Friends and stuff: The compromise of a mid-sized truck also appears in the rear seat. Sturgis Kid 4.0 found the rear seatback plenty vertical. Staying hydrated was a problem, because tilting his head back for a drink meant contorting his spine just so.

Legroom was also at a premium. Middle passengers won’t be bothered by the hump so much as the console, but said console does hold plenty of detritus.

Truck stuff: The model tested came with a fairly short five-foot cargo bed. I never had a chance to haul anything in it besides a pair of duffle bags, but the space is tight.

Play some tunes: This was my first experience with this Toyota stereo interface, or at least my most pleasant. The ebony touchscreen mimics what Honda offers, but a pair of knobs makes controlling volume and tuning much easier.

Using the touchscreen to find a specific song was actually easy -– often a tricky proposition. The alphabet was broken up into letters I could actually see on the fly, and scrolling was then easy as well.

Advertise with us

Sound quality, though, is simply B+. The stereo plays too much in treble and bass ranges.

Noisy: And this is a truck where a good stereo would be a real benefit. Simply holding a conversation with back-seat passengers was a challenge.

I couldn’t decipher if the problem was wind noise, tire noise or acoustics, but it seems to be a combination of the three.

Fuel economy: Disappointing. I got 19 mpg on my first tank in the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat range of suburban and country roads. It dropped to 17 on the highway.

Where it’s built: San Antonio, Texas.

Advertise with us

How it’s built: Consumer Reports bets the Tacoma will offer very good reliability for 2016. That’s a safe bet, as it’s gotten only a handful of average ratings and one below average across 17 component areas for the past six years. Solid.

In the end: The sacrifice in cargo and passenger space is not balanced by a big increase in fuel economy. Still, if reliability is your game and you’re aiming for a mid-size pickup anyway, the Tacoma can’t be beat. But learn sign language, because conversations from front to back can be hard to hear.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer: mrdriversseat@gmail.com.