The U.S. Department of Labor on Wednesday made its long-awaited announcement on new rules and regulations for the financial services industry meant to reassure Americans saving for retirement that they will have access to advice that is in their best interest.

Under the new rule, financial advisers overseeing retirement accounts will be required to act under a fiduciary standard — a standard that requires them to put their client’s interest ahead of their own. Still, the final version was not as onerous as some industry players had feared or as potent as some advocates for industry reform had hoped it would be.

“I am just a little bit disappointed in the Department of Labor’s fiduciary duty rule introduced today,” said Chicago-based securities lawyer Andrew Stoltmann. “It is unfortunately a watered-down version of the fiduciary duty imposed on registered investment advisers.”

Paul Brahim, chairman and CEO of BPU Investment Management, Inc., Downtown, called the announcement of the final rule an exciting day. As president-elect of the Financial Planning Association of Pittsburgh, he has been involved for a number of years in helping to create the rule.

Advertise with us

“Industries talk about disruptors,” said Mr. Brahim, whose firm has $1.2 billion in assets under advisement. “The iPhone was a disruptor for smartphones. This rule is a disruptor for financial advice, and more importantly those who consume it.”

Mr. Brahim agreed that relative to the DOL’s initial proposal in 2010, the final rule has been softened.

“It is true that the final release is watered down even from the last proposal about 90 days ago,” he said. “In the history of rule-making in our country, rules go through evolution. First, the rule makes a significant change that is palatable to the marketplace. Then it gets refined and strengthened.

“It’s still a great day for consumers because it is the beginning. We have not yet seen a proposal from the Securities Exchange Commission that will be forthcoming, and it could fill in some of the gaps.”

There’s a lot of money tied up in retirement assets in the U.S. Individual Retirement Accounts hold an estimated $7.4 trillion in assets and defined contribution plans hold about $6.8 trillion, according to the Investment Company Institute.

Advertise with us

The securities industry has been bracing itself for the potentially dramatic impact of the rule, which many firms feared could result in revenues and fees being squeezed in the coming years.

Brokers who rely on commissions may not be able to sell the most profitable products and receive the same payout. Fee-only advisers are concerned that people with low account balances may be turned away by financial advisers who do not see enough profit potential in servicing those accounts.

Advisers previously had a choice as to whether they would operate under a suitability standard or fiduciary standard. Advisers only have to prove that an investment is suitable for a client under the suitability standard, which opened the door to abuses such as unnecessary high commissions and fees for investment products and advice.

All advisers must now act as fiduciaries. Fiduciaries can only recommend investments that best serve the client in terms of cost, tax-efficiency, risk tolerance other factors.

The fiduciary rule was expected to hit the variable annuity business particularly hard. The DOL wanted to crack down on the practice of advisers recommending people near retirement roll money out of low-cost 401ks into variable annuities that charged high upfront fees.

Advertise with us

According to industry sources, insurance broker and consultant NFP recently exited the independent broker dealer business ahead of the fiduciary ruling. AIG announced in January it would be selling AIG Advisor Group, citing the fiduciary rule as one of the reasons behind the sale. MetLife also sold its U.S. adviser unit in February to Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Co.

While the DOL rule does impose a higher standard, the department ultimately decided to relax some terms it had previously said it would impose — possibly to address industry concerns that the new rules were too taxing and would likely lead to courtroom challenges.

The fiduciary rule still allows advisers to recommend investments that often pose higher risk and higher fees, such as non-traded REITs and variable annuities. The only difference is that now advisers must guarantee the client they are putting the client’s interests ahead of their own.

The rule also eliminates the requirement that firms give clients a projected cost analysis of the impact of fees on their investments over one year, five years and 10 years — a provision that would have provided more transparency to investors. The department decided the requirement would be too difficult and costly for firms.

Mr. Stoltmann wasn’t pleased with the final rule. “There are things brokers can do with retirement accounts that no real fiduciary could ever do.

Advertise with us

“Consider that under the rule, firms can sell high-fee variable and indexed annuities in IRAs, and brokers can continue to recommend proprietary products,” he said. “Many of the problems and abuses we’ve seen over the years in litigation and arbitration against brokerage firms have to do with exactly these sorts of activities.”

The DOL also extended the time frame for firms to comply. Instead of eight months, firms will have one year. The full requirements will go into effect Jan. 1, 2018.

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.