2016 Honda Civic 1.5 T Sens vs. 2016 Mazda3 4-door Grand Touring: Little four-door face-off.
This week: 2016 Mazda3 4-door.
Price: $30,135 as tested. A $2,800 GT Technology Package offered regenerative braking, radar cruise control, forward obstruction warning and more. Mobile start and red paint added another $1,000. A base Grand Touring can be had starting at $25,795. A base 3 can be had for $17,845, $600 lower than the 2015 price.
Marketer’s pitch: “It’s like hitting every green light, every time you drive it.”
Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com liked the “precise handling; very good fuel economy; quick acceleration; top crash test scores; refined interior with intuitive controls; available hatchback body style; many advanced features are available” but not the “above-average wind noise; ride quality can be choppy with the optional 18-inch wheels.”
Reality: Yeah, pretty much that green light thing.
What’s new: There’s not much new with the Mazda3, but why would you start monkeying around with this?
Up to speed: The 2.5-liter SkyActiv four-cylinder creates 184 horsepower, which motivates the Mazda3 fairly well. I found the little car got onto highways in short order. A base 2.0-liter four performed acceptably for me in earlier incarnations.
On the curves: The Mazda3 continues serving up the driving delights that the Japanese automaker is known for. Very little body roll means high speeds on country roads are as fun as ever.
Shifty: The test vehicle came equipped with the company’s six-speed shiftable automatic, and it functions well whether you like to control the shifting or let the vehicle take over. Either way, expect to endure many shifts on slight highway inclines to keep up to speed.
For clutchophiles like myself, Mazda offers some of the best and easiest-to-use manuals on the market.
Driver’s Seat: Overall, the Mazda cockpit does a fine job of sharing information, although I find the larger circular tachometer with the small digital speedometer inset kind of puts the emphasis on the wrong information. I like to know the engine speed as much as the next driver, but this seems out of proportion.
Lack of a temperature gauge still burns me up as well.
Friends and stuff: The rear seat is a snug fit for most normal-sized individuals. The center spot is almost unworkable. Legroom is poor, reports Sturgis Kid 4.0.
Trouble from behind: Though the Mazda3 comes in sedan and hatchback forms, both look for all intents and purposes like hatchbacks, because the sedan roofline is so sloped.
This puts the sedan at a disadvantage in two areas. The first is window clearing; because the vehicle is considered a sedan, it gets only a rear defroster with no wiper, while it still receives all the rain and splash of a hatchback-style window.
The other disadvantage is in the “trunk”; its opening is so short that, even with a fold-down seat, large objects aren’t coming along for the ride unless you have a roof rack. Furthermore, I always manage to conk my head on the Mazda3 trunk every time I test one.
A backup camera is now standard.
Plenty of room: The Mazda3 provides a comfy armrest with storage inside, cupholders in front and correct elbow positioning for the shifter and infotainment operation. This was a pitfall of the CX-3 small crossover.
Play some tunes: The infotainment system is standard issue Mazda, and getting through the functions with BMWesque knob and buttons is simple.
The sound quality gets an A.
Night shift: The overhead lights Mazda has provided in its last few test vehicles have been plenty bright, but they are plasticky and don’t match the subtle glow of most of the competitors I test. Nor do they fit in the fine interiors Mazda provides.
Fuel economy: I averaged 29 mpg in the usual Driver’s Seat mix of highway and suburban driving.
Where it is built: Hofu, Japan.
How it’s built: Better than average, according to Consumer Reports, and varying between that and excellent back to 2009.
In the end: Dang, but why don’t I own one of these? If you can live without the passenger space, it’s just really one of the most fun bargains around; if you can’t, try the 5-door model.
Go for the Honda Civic if you feel must. It’s not bad and extremely reliable.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.