2016 Honda Civic 1.5 T Sens vs. 2016 Mazda3 4-door Grand Touring: Little four-door face-off.

This week: Honda Civic

Price: $23,200 as tested (no options). A base Civic can be had for as little as $18,640.

Marketer’s pitch: “Unmistakable and unforgettable.”

Advertise with us

Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com liked the “zesty and fuel-efficient turbocharged engine; advanced infotainment and safety technology; roomy cabin; big trunk; satisfying handling” but not that it’s “a bit pricier than some rivals.”

Reality: It’s pretty nice, but …

What’s new: The humble Civic gets a handsome new look for 2016. Several friends and acquaintances were surprised when I told them it was a Civic. The look is sporty and, to me at least, Mazda3-like.

Driver’s Seat: Sadly, though, the Civic retains what, for Mr. Driver’s Seat, has been a problematic ergonomic structure.

Upon entry, the Civic has an arcade racing game feel, with a sporty seat slung low to the ground. The low-end manual seat does not raise straight up and down, but only from behind, like a lift chair. So I could never arrange the pedals, steering wheel and seat for maximum comfort.

Advertise with us

I reviewed my notes and found that the right Achilles tendon issue that developed during my test week has been a recurring Civic theme. I’m not Dr. Driver’s Seat, but a couple days after returning the car, the pain went away.

Your mileage may vary. But if you’re driving a Civic and experiencing leg pain, I’d like to hear from you, if only to prove to Mrs. Passenger Seat that I’m not crazy. Or, at least not crazy in this regard.

Up to speed: The 1.5-liter turbo packs 174 horsepower and creates not a bad punch for the small Civic. (A 158-hp 2.0-liter four is standard.) Turbo lag posed no problem like some (mostly older) turbocharged vehicles.

Shiftless: The continuously variable transmission in the test vehicle functioned fairly well. These transmissions can often give small cars a golf cart-like quality, but the Civic moved smoothly. (Only the 2.0 offers a six-speed manual option.)

The CVT offers no shift capability, a light disappointment.

Advertise with us

On the road: A test drive of the nimble new Accord made me wonder if Honda had begun adding some improved handling capabilities to its lineup, but the Civic disabused me of that notion. The steering remains as vague and uninspiring as ever at low speeds, although on highways and country roads it seems far more surefooted and less of a floating boat than previous incarnations.

Make some noise: Sturgis Kid 4.0 said he could tell when I pulled up in the driveway; the Civic made plenty of noise as it puttered along.

Friends and stuff: Though buyers don’t consider this category of vehicle for family-carrying capacity, it remains worth noting. The Civic offered tight headroom but ample legroom. Conversely, the Mazda3 was tight for legs and roomy for heads.

A decent-sized console holds a few items. A phone tray in front of the shifter is too shallow to hold a smartphone properly during acceleration and hard corners.

Play some tunes: The Civic I tested sported the standard Honda stereo interface, a pretty ebony unit with touch controls.

Advertise with us

Unfortunately, the function seemed less able than the Pilot or the Accord version. If you’re moving along the road and plug in your iPod, the autoplay function says it can’t operate when the vehicle is in motion. Pressing it causes no change in display. Steering wheel buttons don’t work; neither does Source or Menu. Only Home removes this display.

The iPod USB port is hidden in a bin below the main console and the hunt to plug it in can be challenging.

Keeping warm and cool: A “climate” button underneath the display changes the touchscreen to HVAC functions. But a pair of dials underneath the screen does allow for temperature, sync, and fan speed control as well.

Fuel economy: I averaged 32 mpg in the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat stomping grounds — country roads, suburban highways, and such.

Where it’s built: Greensburg, Indiana.

Advertise with us

How it’s built: No information is available from Consumer Reports for this all-new model, but previous Civic incarnations have all fallen in the excellent category, dating back to 2009.

Next week: 2016 Mazda3 4-Door Grand Touring.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.