An early entry in the annual debate on whether CEOs are paid too much concludes they are and puts some of the blame on mutual funds and pension plans that rubber stamp corporate pay packages that shareholders vote on regularly.

As You Sow’s second annual list of the 100 most overpaid executives— based on 2014 pay — is topped by Discovery Communications CEO and president David M. Zaslav. His $156.1 million pay was $142.3 million more than was justified by the cable network operator’s long-term performance, according to the nonprofit’s math.

Two executives with Pittsburgh connections made the list: Alcoa chairman and CEO Klaus Kleinfeld, whose total pay of $18.2 million included $6.4 million more than he was worth based on the metal producer’s performance; and PPG Industries’ Charles E. Bunch, who was chairman and CEO in 2014. Mr. Bunch’s total pay of $21.6 million included $6.3 million in undeserved compensation, according to the nonprofit..

The report also examined how mutual funds and pension plans cast their ballots in the “say on pay” votes most companies conduct at their shareholder meetings each year. The votes are non-binding, but companies whose pay packages are rejected or garner low shareholder support often change their pay practices.

Advertise with us

Some of the largest mutual fund operators, including Vanguard, TIAA-CREF and Blackrock, routinely approved the pay packages at the 100 companies identified in the report, voting for them 96 percent of the time or more. Public pension plans put up a little more resistance — the Pennsylvania School Employees Retirement System opposed overpaid CEO pay packages 37 percent of the time — but do not reject outsized pay plans often enough, according to the report.

“The 100 most overpaid CEOs deserve more scrutiny than they are getting today from mutual funds and pension funds,” said Rosanna Landis Weaver, the lead author of the report.

She said fund managers are ignoring their fiduciary duties by voting in favor of what the report called an ”extraordinary misallocation of assets.”

As You Sow’s mission is to promote environmental and social corporate responsibility through shareholder advocacy and other means. The group looked at 35 indicators of excessive compensation. Among other things, the group penalized companies that: paid the highest cash incentives despite low five-year returns to shareholders; had excessive stock buybacks, which can boost earnings per share, a major determinant of pay; and those that issued excessive stock awards, option grants and perquisites.

Estimates of how much executives were overpaid were developed by HIP Investor, a San Francisco firm that advises clients on impact investing (think: earning a good return while doing good). HIP analyzed actual pay compared to what the executives should have earned based on 1-, 3-, 5- and 10-year cumulative returns, including reinvested dividends, and calculated a CEO’s excess pay based on the five-year performance.

Advertise with us

The rankings reflect As You Sow’s criteria as well as HIP’s look at pay vs. performance. According to their math, 16 of the 100 CEOs made at least $20 million more than they were entitled to if they were paid strictly on the basis of performance. Eleven of the 25 most overpaid CEOs on this year’s list also made the roster last year.

Mr. Kleinfeld’s excess compensation stemmed from performance issues such as low return on invested capital, Ms. Weaver said. Even though PPG’s five-year total shareholder return exceeded that of the S&P 500, the company earned low marks for things like paying more than its peer companies and generous executive retirement plans, she said.

“Even if performance is outstanding, we believe it is still possible to overpay a CEO,” Ms. Weaver said.

The report mentions many of the issues that executive pay critics have cited for years, including the over reliance on earnings per share. That number can be inflated by a number of measures that could hurt a company’s long-term performance, including trimming research and development budgets, delaying maintenance, or using cash to repurchase shares instead of investing it in new products or factories.

Ms. Weaver said it is hard to measure how much of a role stock buybacks play in inflating CEO pay, but added: “There’s a lot of legitimate concern about that.”

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.