2016 Hyundai Sonata: The Hybrid and the Turbo face off.

Price: $29,885, as tested, including $125 for carpeted floor mats. A base model can be had for as low as $21,750. Hybrid was $35,765, but it was decked out with the Ultimate Package, which costs $4,500 and adds panoramic sunroof, all manner of self-driving features, and upgraded stereo.

Marketer’s pitch: “Make every day, less everyday.” Come on, folks, that comma should not be there.

Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com appreciated “lots of standard and optional features for the money; quiet and roomy interior; smooth ride complemented by comfortable seats; easy-to-use controls and touchscreen; solid build quality” but not the “disappointing performance from the turbocharged 2.0-liter engine; relatively unrefined 2.4-liter engine.”

Advertise with us

Reality: Twice the enjoyment.

Two, two, two reviews in one: It’s rare that I’m able to examine two distinct versions of a vehicle for a week each. I was able to capture two different Sonatas and I found them to be disappointing in only one way: I had nothing to poke fun at.

When I started reviewing cars five years ago, it was a given that a Hyundai sedan would be at best a compromise and at worst a disappointment. Not anymore.

These days the sedans offer roominess, comfort and decent handling, although I would have liked to have tried the base model.

Up to speed: Naturally the turbo version provided far more enjoyment in this arena. The 245 horsepower provided for takeoff was plenty; on my first on-ramp test, I absentmindedly sent the car careening past 80 mph. Of course, in the wilds of southeastern Pennsylvania, that meant I was only traveling slightly faster than most of my highway companions.

Advertise with us

The Hybrid creates a mere 193 horsepower, still plenty to get a sedan on the road.

Shifty: The six-speed automatic accompanying the Turbo model shifted well, although a few minor hesitations on occasion seemed to accompany the cold weather more than anything.

In the Turbo, the shiftable portion of our roadshow was disappointing. The shifter required a forceful motion to upshift or downshift, much more than most other cars I’ve tested. I left it in automatic mode the whole time.

The Hybrid shifted with far less effort, surprisingly.

On the road: Both notes of the Sonata handled like a family sedan, no surprises there.

Advertise with us

As many vehicles do these days, driving modes are offered — normal, eco and sport.

The Sonata Turbo’s sport mode made steering tight but didn’t change handling. But standing starts quickly became troublesome in stop-and-go traffic.

There I switched to eco, which didn’t evince any fuel economy upgrade that I could discern, but did make highway handling so mushy that I felt as if I might be weaving a bit.

Fortunately, normal splits the difference just fine.

Driver’s Seat: I found the heated leather seats provided in the test models offered the right blend of support and comfort. The heat’s highest mode is “scald,” though.

Advertise with us

Hyundai has abandoned its door-mounted seat controls for the more common side-of-the-seat switches, a good move, I’d say.

Controls: Hyundai has also made the rest of the interior ergonomics a delight as well. The infotainment system features a touchscreen for much functions, though a pair of left and right knobs pay homage to historic stereo volume and tuning controls.

Heater controls also offer ease of use; buttons control the source and fan speed and dials control the temperature.

Attractive: The dashboard in the Turbo was nothing to write home about — fairly plain but not-cheap-looking plastic covers most of it. The heater vents can be challenging to direct. Still, the straightforward Sonata interior looks better than overdesigned Hyundai interiors of recent generations.

The Sonata Hybrid Limited was attractive inside as well as out.

Advertise with us

Friends and stuff: As Sturgis Kid 4.0 expands upward, he’s become quite the connoisseur of occupant space in the rear seat. He blessed the Sonata as providing plenty of room for his leggy, almost-six-foot frame.

Fuel economy: I averaged just over 25 mpg with the turbo model, and just under 35 with the hybrid.

Where they’re built: Montgomery, Alabama, for the Turbo, and Asan, Korea, for the Hybrid.

How they’re built: Consumer Reports gives the Hyundai Sonata an above average reliability rating.

In the end: I found both versions of the Sonata easy to live with. Though it adds a $4,000 premium, the hybrid means you’ll get some serious fuel savings without sacrificing performance. For shiftophiles, better to look for the cousin Kia Optima.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.