Honda HR-V vs. Mazda CX-3 vs. Kia Soul vs. Buick Encore: Small crossover four-way.
This week: 2015 Buick Encore AWD Premium Group
Price: $32,395 as tested (including $495 for audio system with navigation; more on that later). A basic front-wheel drive could be had for as low as $24,065.
Marketer’s pitch: “Perfectly sized to suit your next adventure.”
Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com liked the “quiet interior; good fuel economy; long list of tech and safety features,” but not the “tepid performance; small size limits interior room and cargo space.”
Reality: No ovation for this Encore.
Cute as a button: The last time I tested an Encore (2013) I had the same reaction: Awww. It’s so adorable. Its tiny size and eggy shape continue to make it Most Likely to be Cuddled in a parking lot.
But as with puppies, babies and car columnists, sometimes it’s better to think about the consequences before getting sucked in by all that cuteness.
At first, I thought focusing a column on infotainment glitches seemed petty. Surely, it’s not a major component. And yet, if a simple upgraded radio can’t function properly, can’t we extrapolate that major components would fare no better? You, the reader, must make your choice as to the priority of this problem.
Full crash: The Intellilink system from Buick trumped any troubles I’d ever experienced from the much-maligned Ford Sync system from the 2012 era. The Encore’s system froze three times in a week, twice to the point where nothing would happen — the screen wouldn’t change, none of the controls worked, and it wouldn’t power down. Even turning the vehicle off for 30 seconds to two minutes didn’t reset it.
Though it seems minor, all navigation functions were then lost, along with the backup camera.
Button explosion: Even before its final demise on Day 5 and Day 6, living with the system was darn near impossible. A total of 22 buttons across the front makes for puzzlement.
On the bright side, the sound quality is good.
Up to speed: Back to our regular vehicular insight, the 1.4-liter EcoTec turbo four-cylinder powers the Encore adequately. It takes a moment for all 138 horses to come to life, as in many turbos. (A 153 horsepower version is on tap for the 2016 model year; I’d be interested in trying that.)
Shifty: The Encore’s momentum is unaided by the six-speed automatic transmission. It leaves the vehicle in low gears for a while, but still feels soft and uninspiring.
On the curves: For a tall, narrow vehicle, the Encore handles winding roads fairly well. It’s not exciting, but it doesn’t feel like it’s about to fall over either. Still, the CX-3 or the Soul wins here.
Friends and stuff: The rear seat is snug as a bug, narrow with minimal foot room. The center seat is comfortable, although the console does intrude.
Cargo space behind challenging as well. Owners will get 48.4 cubic feet with the seats folded, which beats only the CX-3 in this group.
An armrest that sits over coffee cups seems like it should generate the same complaints as the CX-3 did, but this one allows drivers to reach in to get the cups with the armrest in place. It’s not easy, but it’s doable.
Keep warm — and cool: I might have ignored this if not for the media malfunction, but keeping a set temperature seemed to be a problem. The heat wouldn’t cool down slightly; it would drastically drop. Changing the temperature four degrees would warm things up, and five minutes later I’d be roasting. This complaint also appeared in my review of the 2013 model.
Night shift: The overhead lights are fairly bright and difficult to watch the road by.
Fuel economy: I averaged just under 27 mpg in the usual mix of testing.
Where it’s built: Bupyeong Gu, South Korea. This was the location of Daewoo plants.
How it’s built: That’s Daewoo, the company that offered “Buy one, get one free” sales when it shut down in the early 2000s. Consumer Reports calls the Encore’s reliability rating “average,” but I remain wary.
In the end: Despite its attractiveness, price and equipment malfunctions ruled the Encore out from about Day 3. Of the other three, the Soul remains a bargain, in price and in spaciousness. Honda’s reliability track record makes it a fair choice as well. Other journalists are enamored with the CX-3, but I’m not so impressed.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.