Rebecca Panza of Oakmont was headed to a dog-sitting appointment in Fox Chapel one Sunday afternoon last summer when she heard a loud “pop” and a hissing sound.

Realizing she had a flat, she quickly pulled to the side of the road and called AAA.

Then came the big surprise.

When the AAA driver opened the trunk to retrieve the spare in her 2015 smokey blue Kia Optima sedan, it was missing.

Advertise with us

The man then showed her a label on the driver’s side door frame. In capital letters, next to the words “Spare tire,” it read “NONE.”

“I was furious,” Ms. Panza, 45, remembered. “When you buy a new car, you’re under the assumption that you have a spare.”

She waited another hour for a flatbed to arrive to give her a tow.

As automakers look for ways to cut costs and reduce vehicle weight to meet tightening fuel economy standards, spare tires — including temporary spares known as donuts — are increasingly ending up in the scrap yard.

According to a AAA report released last month, roughly one-third (36 percent) of 2015 model year vehicles sold in the U.S. came without a spare. That’s up from 5 percent for the 2006 model year, the motor club said.

Advertise with us

The trend angers some customers unaware that they don’t have a spare until the worst possible moment — when they get a flat.

In place of the spare, automakers typically include an inflator/sealant kit as a stop-gap. But the kits are designed only to fix simple types of damage. The kits won’t work, for example, unless the puncture-causing object, such as a screw or nail, remains in the tire. They’re also useless if the sidewall is damaged or a blowout occurs.

Unwelcome surprise

For motorists used to buying cars with spare tires included as standard equipment, the change can be jolting. In Ms. Panza’s case, the repair kit was no match for the gaping wound in her tire.

What angered her most is that she didn’t know she was driving around without a spare.

Advertise with us

“It was never told to me by the salesperson or anyone else at the dealership,” she said. “My car has all the bells and whistles on it: leather seats, cooling and warming seats, a double sunroof, heated steering wheel. I thought at least a donut would be in there.”

In vehicles equipped with repair kits, spares generally are offered as an option. Ms. Panza said, after her flat, she returned to the dealer and bought a donut for $200, plus tax.

It is unclear if, or how often, car buyers are being told about not having a spare. Or even if they should be told.

Paul Auffenberg, general manager at Century III Kia in West Mifflin where Ms. Panza bought her car, said it was his dealership’s policy to inform buyers when a vehicle doesn’t come equipped with a spare.

“We want to make sure all customers are aware what’s happening with these tires,” Mr. Auffenberg said last week. “Does it happen 100 percent of the time? Absolutely not,” he said. “I would like all the sales personnel to do that.”

Advertise with us

He also noted Kia offers free roadside assistance for flat tires, a service that’s good through the vehicle’s five-year, 60,000 mile warranty.

Philip Reed, senior consumer advice editor at the car shopping website Edmunds.com, said he suspects the topic of spares doesn’t come up much in showrooms.

“The car salesman won’t say, ‘Oh, this isn’t included,’” Mr. Reed said. “They are trying to make a sale.”

“I think the salespeople should point it out,” at least until cars without spares become the norm, he said.

At the same time, he added, “People need to take some responsibility for informing themselves about the car.”

Advertise with us

Bill Moran, a retired middle school teacher from Pottsville, Schuylkill County, is adamant that no one told him a spare wasn’t included when he bought his new 2013 silver Hyundai Elantra Limited at Freedom Hyundai in Hamburg.

A recent trip home from his son’s house turned sour when he got a flat tire after hitting a pothole at a rest stop 45 minutes from home. “I opened the trunk and there was no tire there,” he said. “There was just this box.”

He read the kit’s instructions and tried the sealant but quickly realized it wasn’t going to work on his blowout.

He waited 45 minutes for a tow and had to find a ride home for his mother-in-law and wife waiting in the car. Luckily their son was able to drive out to get them.

Mr. Moran, 63. said he later returned to the dealer where he had a “heated discussion” with the sales manager about letting him leave the lot without a spare.

Advertise with us

“He said I was told about it,” Mr. Moran said. “I was not told.”

The general manager at Freedom Hyundai did not return repeated phone calls seeking comment.

“While there is no official policy on handling vehicles equipped with the repair kit, we are confident that the sales training process has prepared the dealer staff to inform consumers about the vehicles they’re purchasing,” Hyundai Motor America spokeswoman Christine Jew said in an email.

“In addition, the vehicle window sticker displayed on every new car does list out the emergency tire repair kit if the vehicle is not equipped with a spare,” she said.

Ms. Jew said the automaker had not received “a large percentage of complaints” on the issue.

Advertise with us

Why they are doing it

She said spare tires were being replaced in some Hyundai models to “improve efficiency and fuel economy,” but did not indicate how much fuel was saved by chucking the spare.

Mr. Reed at Edmunds said that in terms of miles per gallon, the savings was “minuscule” — way less than 1 mpg. But he said weight reductions in a number of places on a vehicle combine to produce more significant savings.

The AAA motor club has been calling on car makers to put spare tires back in all vehicles for safety reasons. Besides helping to avoid a tow, spares are important for people stranded in remote areas, said Chelsea Pompeani, spokeswoman for East Central AAA.

But Mr. Reed said he thinks making spares an option rather than standard equipment isn’t a bad idea, given that fuel efficiency is such a high priority.

Advertise with us

In addition, he said, better tire technology — including government-mandated tire pressure monitoring systems — is reducing the need for spares.

However, “Despite advances in vehicle technology, we have not seen a decline in tire-related calls over the last five years,” said John Nielsen, managing director of AAA’s automotive engineering and repair.

Mr. Reed said another factor may be contributing to the steady level of calls. “Fewer people change tires themselves, and automatically call AAA.”

The motor club said another drawback of repair kits is the cost to consumers. Replacement kits can cost up to $300. Even if unused, they should be replaced every four to eight years to remain effective, the group said.

In addition, using sealant on a flat often renders the tire unrepairable. The sealant “can damage the car’s tire if it’s left in,” Mr. Reed said.

Advertise with us

Some car makers have been equipping vehicles with four so-called “run-flat” tires as another alternative to providing a spare. Run-flats have been falling out of favor, however, because consumers have been complaining about high replacement costs, Mr. Reed said.

For Ms. Panza, the most important issue is forcing automakers and dealers to do a better job disclosing whether a vehicle has a spare.

“What if I had been somewhere else in the middle of nowhere without a cell phone?” she asked.

“Consumers should be told.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.

Advertise with us

Here’s a complete list of vehicles being sold that do not have a spare tire:

Vehicles-Sold-Without-a-Spare-Tire (PDF)

Vehicles-Sold-Without-a-Spare-Tire (Text)

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.