Honda HR-V vs. Mazda CX-3 vs. Kia Soul vs. Buick Encore: Small crossover four-way.
This week: 2016 Honda HR-V AWD EX-L Navi
Price: $26,720 as tested. No options. A base front-wheel-drive model starts at $19,115.
Marketer’s pitch: “One HR-V fits all.”
Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com likes the “roomy interior and seating; versatile cargo loading thanks to unique rear seat; high fuel economy; excellent outward visibility” but not the “underwhelming acceleration; touchscreen interface can be frustrating to use and lacks full Android integration.”
Reality: Small CR-V or big Civic? Sorry, folks: big Civic.
Popular size: Small crossovers are supposed to be all the rage now. An auto expert told me that any entry into that segment would sell like hotcakes. I decided to pit two of the newest comers to the category — the Honda and the Mazda — against a pair of perhaps unusual challengers. But size-wise, they all fit together.
Welcome to the Honda: The CR-V and the Toyota RAV4 have both grown up over the last few years and really needed a baby brother in the lineup.
Outside, the handsome egg shape echoes the Honda Fit, a car with so much versatility that it makes my own must-have list for small cars.
On first sitting, it seemed Honda just didn’t measure up to all my great expectations. That reaction mellowed a bit over time.
Love me or hate me: I’ve followed certain movie reviewers and political columnists for ages simply because I know if they hate something, I’ll like it. On that note, if you like new Hondas — and I know lots of you do — then I’m your Charles Krauthammer.
Driver’s Seat: From the moment I sat down, I was disappointed. Many Honda models come with far more lumbar support than I need, and the HR-V was no exception.
I sat atop the seat rather than snuggling into it. The leather felt hard and unwelcoming, but worst were the seat bottoms that were far too short for my thighs, and I’m just 5-10.
Up to speed: The 141 horses working inside the 1.6-liter four provided acceleration that was somewhat erratic. I’d just get finished telling someone how disappointed I was when, zoom, off I’d tear on the next pullout.
Shiftless: I lay the burden squarely on the CVT — which I may or may not have referred to on social media as the Cheapo Venomous Torture. The HR-V’s continuously variable transmission offers a “shift” mode, but I wasn’t fooled. Mainly it seemed to produce much sound but no fury. Make sure you wait for just the right spot in traffic.
On the turns: Light steering did nothing to make the driving experience more fun.
And the Honda leaned hard on corners.
Play some tunes: I know I sound like the Goldilocks columnist. “This seat is too hard.” “This transmission is too soft.” But, here, Honda gets it just right. The infotainment system sits atop the dash like a tablet, and the graphics are superbly clear and helpful. Steering wheel buttons are clear and easy to operate.
Turn to the right: Honda’s nifty right-turn camera — activated with the turn signal — offers a clear view of what’s going on in the next lane. And that camera and back-up camera offer crisp views of the outdoors, even better than the real thing.
Friends and stuff: Mrs. Passenger Seat echoed my complaints when sitting in her side of the vehicle. Legroom in the rear was sufficient, and the seat was comfortable enough, reported near-six-foot Sturgis Kid 4.0, but a lack of an armrest was notable.
Up front, a tiny armrest console didn’t hold much more than a couple smartphones. An open console underneath the shift lever holds a few pieces, but not securely. Fortunately, the glovebox is large.
The HR-V offers 55-58 cubic feet of cargo space behind the first row of seats and 23-24 behind the second. (That’s less than the Soul, more than the Encore and far more than the CX-3.)
The view: Unfortunately, the HR-V is one of those vehicles where I could pick two out of three of the following: seeing the speedometer, keeping my arms comfortable or keeping my back comfortable.
Fuel economy: I averaged just above 28 miles per gallon in a mix of driving that included a trip to the Poconos. Not the worst, but I was expecting a little better.
Where it’s built: Celaya, Mexico
How it’s built: New for the model year, the HR-V doesn’t rate Consumer Reports reliability data. The Fit is also made in Mexico, and its reliability has been found to be slightly above average.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.