The images of children and other struggling refugees from war-torn Syria can be powerful tools to spark donations to nonprofits involved in relief efforts.
But those heart-tugging accounts of people in crisis can also generate lots of money for fake charities — especially during the holidays when people are most inclined to share their blessings with the needy.
Just last week, the Better Business Bureau issued an alert about scam emails seeking help for Syrians trying to leave their country. The scammer claims to be a Syrian with gold to sell to finance a trip out of the country. Those who agree to help will be offered a percentage of the profits from the sale.
But here’s the rub: Responders will be asked to forward a series of payments for taxes and other costs.
“The money will never materialize, there are no funds, and it’s all a con,” the BBB said.
That’s the kind of scam more consumers are likely to fall prey to during the Thanksgiving-to-New Year’s Day stretch when charitable contributions typically peak, said Carol Kando-Pineda, an attorney with the Federal Trade Commission’s Division of Consumer & Business Education.
Read More
Doing the research
■ Federal Trade Commission's consumer information
■ Better Business Bureau Wise Giving Alliance
■ IRS search for tax exempt organizations
■ National Association of State Charity Officials
Source: Federal Trade Commission
“We’re all a little bit more attuned to those kind of pitches right about now,” she said. “Scammers and fake charities know that and adjust their messages accordingly” by playing off headlines about world conflicts, natural disasters or shocking tragedies such as the terrorist bombings in Paris.
Around the holidays, people are thinking about helping others. “They want to make sure others are cared for if they are struggling,” said H. Art Taylor, president and chief executive of the BBB’s Wise Giving Alliance in Arlington, Va.
The alliance estimates charities collect one-third of their donations in the last quarter of the year. It’s the height of the giving season, plus Dec. 31 is the deadline for charitable tax deductions.
More than one-third of those who donate — about 36 to 37 percent — don’t properly research the groups they want to support, Mr. Taylor said.
Those who monitor fake charities say the simplest and best way to avoid being scammed is to research a charity before making a donation and to keep detailed records.
While that sounds like obvious advice, as consumers get caught up in the holiday season, their defenses go down, said Nicole Coleman, assistant professor at the University of Pittsburgh’s Katz Graduate School of Business whose research focuses on consumer psychology and behavior.
“No matter what religion or nonreligion you ascribe to, it’s a time to make connections and be aware of people in our lives and the fortunes of having a roof over our heads and food on the table, and that often puts people in the mindset to help others,” she said.
Some scam artists, Ms. Coleman said, capitalize on all that good will by showing up at malls or bus or train stations posing as representatives from a bogus charity.
“We’ll erroneously drop $5 in that bucket or pay for toys that [the scammers] will sell later on eBay. Once you realize it’s fake, there’s no recourse. [Those people] or their stand are no longer at the mall in January.”
Her advice is to go on the offensive before writing any checks.
“Choose your charity and give one large donation rather than dropping $5 in a bucket here and $1 in a checkout line there. The best plan is to sit down and make a decision about where to give this year. Then you’ve done the charitable action and given to a reputable source. When you encounter the flyers, you don’t have to give.”
Also take a hard look at the charity’s name — especially those that ask for donations to military or veterans groups and feature military logos in their appeals.
“Scammers will throw ‘military’ or ‘vets’ into the name to lead people to believe it’s going to benefit some big charity that people know such as the American Legion, Veterans of Foreign Wars or Red Cross,” Ms. Kando-Pineda said.
Also beware of high-pressure appeals that ask for on-the-spot giving or for donors to wire money immediately, she said. “Any legitimate charity will let you take your time.”
Among the organizations that offer online data and charity ratings are Charity Navigator, Charity Watch, GuideStar, Wise Giving Alliance, the FTC and the Internal Revenue Service.
Or if an organization is nearby, visit in person and ask questions, Mr. Taylor said.
He acknowledged that many of those most vulnerable to scams are senior citizens who don’t have computer access or the ability to do an on-site charity visit.
The Wise Giving Alliance publishes a print edition of its annual report that evaluates 1,300 charities. “We get some younger people who call and want to give it to their parents,” he said.
To receive a free copy: 703-247-9321.
Joyce Gannon: jgannon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1580.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.