As more American shoppers use their chip-enabled smart cards at the register, some have begun yearning for their old swipe-style cards.

One month after the Oct. 1 deadline for retailers to start accepting security-enhanced chip credit and debit cards, a survey by Allentown, Pa., point-of-sale systems provider Harbortouch found 20 percent of U.S. consumers using a chip card think it takes too long.

On average, it takes seven to 10 seconds to pay with a chip card vs. two to three seconds using a traditional swipe-style card, according to Harbortouch CEO Jared Isaacman.

That may not sound like much, but the added time could mean longer checkout lines for shoppers, he said. “While seemingly small, during busy times like the holidays, these increased processing times could add up quickly,” Mr. Isaacman said.

Advertise with us

At discount retailer Target, which activated smart card terminals at its stores in mid-August, the “slightly longer” processing time hasn’t been an issue, said Molly Snyder, spokeswoman for the Minneapolis-based retailer.

“We worked to streamline [processing]. We wanted to make sure the prompts moved you through the process quickly,” she said. “We haven’t had any [negative] feedback because it’s going pretty smoothly for guests at Target stores.”

Craig Shearman, a spokesman for the Washington, D.C.-based industry group National Retail Federation, said the longer processing time for chip cards is a concern, but other factors are generally more important in how fast checkout lines move.

Those factors include how quickly people retrieve and return their cards to their wallets, how fast they put their packages in their carts and whether they chitchat with the store clerk, for example, Mr. Shearman said.

“Chip cards have been used in Europe and other places for 20 years, and they don’t slow down the lines there,” he said.

Advertise with us

“It’s largely a matter of making sure that the cashiers are well-trained in how this works and trained to help customers along.”

If chip cards end up making checkout lines longer, then retailers should add more registers, said Gayle Marco, professor of marketing at Robert Morris University in Pittsburgh.

The added cost of opening more checkouts should be offset by lower fraud costs associated with chip cards, she said.

Although the deadline for retailers to be chip card enabled was last month, many stores haven’t met the deadline. And it’s expected to be several years before banks and other card issuers complete the rollout of chip cards to consumers.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3066.